Coming into the 2026 CFL season, the Hamilton Tiger-Cats built their offensive personnel around the unique playmaking abilities of starting quarterback Bo Levi Mitchell. However, with Mitchell out indefinitely with a lower-leg injury, the Tiger-Cats have learned that the other quarterbacks on their roster, including Tre Ford and Jake Dolegala, are not equivalent to Bo Levi Mitchell. The result of that lack of continuity at the quarterback position has been a Tiger-Cats offensive unit without a clear identity.
That lack of identity led to a 38-7 blowout loss to the Saskatchewan Roughriders this week, despite a good first-half defensive performance by the Tiger-Cats. Hamilton’s greatest strength on the offensive side of the ball is their dynamic group of wide receivers, but without a quarterback that is capable of attacking all parts of the field, the impact of the Tiger-Cats receivers is minimized due to opposing defenses being able to sit in zone coverage and challenge the Tiger-Cats to run the ball offensively. Unfortunately, the Hamilton running game is another aspect of the Tiger-Cats’ offense that is undermanned after an off-season in which the Tiger-Cats did not prioritize signing a workhorse running back.
The Bo Levi Mitchell Void is Massive
One of the keys to the success of the Hamilton Tiger-Cats’ passing game when Bo Levi Mitchell is healthy and playing his brand of football is his ability to attack all points, spreading the field horizontally and vertically for the Tiger-Cats’ offensive game plan. Because the defensive secondary must always be wary of Mitchell’s ability to push the ball downfield to his vertical threats in the passing game, teams must play deeper in coverage. The need to put a vertical cap on the Hamilton passing game then allows the Tiger-Cats’ receivers to exploit the short and intermediate areas of the field, allowing Mitchell to find open receivers across the field.
QB Jake Dolegala’s Rough Outing
The biggest shortcoming of the Tiger-Cats’ backup quarterbacks, including Jake Dolegala, is their inability to consistently push the ball downfield vertically. Without the constant threat of a deep pass over the heads of opposing secondaries, defenders can tighten their coverage, leaving the Hamilton receivers less space to exploit with their route-running. That results in the receivers being forced to create their own space or catch passes in traffic, neither of which is necessarily a strength of the Tiger-Cats receivers’ skill sets.
The inability to stretch the field forced receivers to catch passes under pressure, and, not surprisingly, that has led to more drops than usual from wide receivers Kenny Lawler and Kiondre Smith. Later in the game, the Tiger-Cats coaching staff allowed Tre Ford to enter, and he found more success than Dolegala due to his dynamic running ability. Similar to establishing a serious threat in the passing game, Ford’s running ability forces opposing intermediate defenders to keep an eye on him in case he runs, and that distraction creates more space for receivers in the intermediate zones.
Costly Second-Half Meltdowns Continue
While the loss of Mitchell has created problems for the Tiger-Cats recently, they have had another problem that has plagued them all season, whether Mitchell is leading the way or not. That problem has been Hamilton’s inability to win close games in the second half. Against Montreal, the Tiger-Cats fumbled away their opportunity to knock off the East-leading Alouettes with a series of turnovers in the second half and overtime. Again, the Tiger-Cats had the lead over the Winnipeg Blue Bombers at home in the Hammer, but despite both teams losing their quarterbacks, the Tiger-Cats failed to protect their lead down the stretch, and the Blue Bombers won the game with a field goal to close out the game. Even in their blowout loss to the Roughriders, the Tiger-Cats’ defense kept Hamilton in the game until the 3rd quarter, when Saskatchewan took advantage of the Tiger-Cats’ lack of offensive continuity.
Outlook in the East Division
While coming up short in three out of five games is not ideal for the Tiger-Cats, their recent struggles have coincided with poor starts to the 2026 season by the Toronto Argonauts (2-3) and the Ottawa Redblacks (4-1). In Week 7, the Tiger-Cats and Argonauts kick off the next chapter of their historic rivalry, and this week the winner of this game will take control of 2nd place in the East Division. That means that Hamilton has a week to make enough improvements offensively to find a way to grind out a win against the Argonauts, who are also struggling to find consistency offensively.
For more football content, check out Football Scientific
Follow me on X: @AaronSauter7