![](\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/1759569491_936_grey-placeholder.png\")
![\"AFP](\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/10\/54b668f0-a2bb-11f0-b2c5-019105d9c0cd.jpg.webp.webp\")
AFP via Getty Images<\/p>\nAFP via Getty Images<\/p>\n
Negotiators from Israel and Hamas are in Sharm El-Sheikh, Egypt, for indirect talks over an end to the Israel-Gaza war.<\/p>\n
It is the closest both sides have come to a deal since the war began two years ago.<\/p>\n
But Donald Trump’s 20-point peace plan<\/a> – which Israel has agreed to and Hamas has partly agreed to – is really just a framework, only a few pages long.<\/p>\n And there are still major sticking points for both sides to resolve.<\/p>\n Hostage release structure<\/p>\n Trump’s plan states that within 72 hours of a deal being agreed all remaining hostages would be released. It is thought 48 Israeli hostages remain in Gaza, 20 of whom are believed to be alive.<\/p>\n Trump said over the weekend the hostages could be released “very soon”, while Netanyahu said they could be freed before the end of the Jewish holiday Sukkot – or October 13th.<\/p>\n Hamas has agreed to the hostage “exchange formula” detailed in Trump’s plan, providing certain “field conditions” are met.<\/p>\n But the hostages are the group’s only bargaining chip – and it’s unclear whether it would be willing to release them before other elements of the deal are finalised.<\/p>\n Trust between the two sides is virtually non-existent. Only last month, Israel attempted to assassinate Hamas’s negotiating team<\/a> with an air strike on Doha – angering not only Hamas but also Trump and Qatar, a key mediator.<\/p>\n Members of that same negotiating team – headed by Khalil al-Hayya, whose son was killed in the strike – will now be meeting just a stone’s throw from Israel’s delegation in Egypt.<\/p>\n Hamas disarmament<\/p>\n Israel’s stated goal throughout the war has been the destruction of Hamas. Netanyahu has repeatedly stated he will not stop until the group is finished. <\/p>\n A key point in Trump’s plan requires the group to disarm. But Hamas has previously refused to lay down its weapons, saying it would only do so once a Palestinian state has been established.<\/p>\n In its response, Hamas made no mention of disarmament – fuelling speculation that it has not changed its position.<\/p>\n Over the weekend, Netanyahu vowed: “Hamas will be disarmed and Gaza will be demilitarised \u2013 either the easy way or the hard way”.<\/p>\n Future governance of Gaza<\/p>\n The plan states that Hamas will have no future role in Gaza, which will be governed by a temporary transitional body of Palestinian technocrats – supervised by a “Board of Peace” headed and chaired by Donald Trump and involving former UK Prime Minister Tony Blair.<\/p>\n Governance of the Strip would eventually be handed over to the Palestinian Authority (PA).<\/p>\n Though Netanyahu agreed to all of Trump’s 20-point plan, he appeared to push back on involvement of the PA even as he stood on the podium next to the president last week, insisting it would play no role<\/a> in governing the territory.<\/p>\n This is one of many points in the plan that will be objectionable to ultranationalist hardliners within Netanyahu’s governing coalition – many of whom want to retain control of Gaza and reconstruct Jewish settlements there.<\/p>\n In Hamas’s response, it indicated that it expects to have some future role in Gaza as part of “a unified Palestinian movement”. Though the wording is vague, this will likely be unacceptable to both Trump and the Israelis.<\/p>\n Israeli withdrawal<\/p>\n The extent of Israel’s military withdrawal is a fourth point of contention.<\/p>\n The plan states that Israel’s military will withdraw from Gaza “based on standards, milestones, and timeframes” that must be agreed by all parties.<\/p>\n