{"id":356926,"date":"2025-12-20T04:14:12","date_gmt":"2025-12-20T04:14:12","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/356926\/"},"modified":"2025-12-20T04:14:12","modified_gmt":"2025-12-20T04:14:12","slug":"instructors-share-which-is-best","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/356926\/","title":{"rendered":"Instructors Share Which Is Best"},"content":{"rendered":"

It wasn\u2019t always a trendy workout class\u2014Pilates<\/a> is an exercise method founded in the early 20th century by Joseph Pilates as a way to elongate, strengthen, and restore the body with intentional movements, according to the Pilates Foundation<\/a>. Since then, the practice has been broken down into two popular versions: mat Pilates vs. reformer Pilates. But which one is a better workout? <\/p>\n

Meet the Experts: Mo Wolfe<\/a>, founder of Evolution Pilates in Port Washington, NY; Portia Page, C.P.T.<\/a>, personal trainer and Balanced Body Educator; and Heather Andersen<\/a>, certified Pilates instructor and founder of New York Pilates.<\/p>\n

There are plenty of pros and cons of the two types of Pilates to consider. Below, instructors and fitness experts explain the differences and provide information to help you choose which method is best for you. (Who knows, you may find that you lean toward both!) <\/p>\n

Mat Pilates benefits<\/p>\n

Mat Pilates \u201cis the foundation of the entire Pilates method,\u201d explains Mo Wolfe<\/a>, founder of Evolution Pilates in Port Washington, NY. Unlike workouts with a reformer, which is a spring-loaded board apparatus that helps move you in and out of exercises, therefore making them lower-impact, mat moves require the body to supply all the control, Wolfe explains. With that, it has many benefits, which may include:<\/p>\n

Building strength<\/p>\n

Mat Pilates builds deep core strength and stability, sharpens body awareness and alignment, and supports mobility and functional fitness needed for daily responsibilities and activities, says Wolfe. <\/p>\n

Convenience and accessibility<\/p>\n

Simply roll out a mat and get to moving. \u201cThe most obvious benefit is that it\u2019s accessible anywhere\u2014the living room, a hotel room, the patch of carpet your dog just vacated,\u201d says Portia Page, C.P.T.<\/a>, personal trainer and Balanced Body Educator. \u201cNo equipment needed, or you can use home props such as a hand towel and pillows.\u201d This also makes mat Pilates far more budget-friendly than its reformer counterpart, because an (often pricey) studio membership isn\u2019t required. <\/p>\n

Beginner and veteran friendly<\/p>\n

\u201cBeginners learn alignment and breathing, and can take it easy. Advanced practitioners can make mat brutally delicious with variations and tempo,\u201d says Page.
<\/p>\n

Mat Pilates potential downsides<\/p>\n

Some of the potential drawbacks to mat Pilates, according to our experts, may include: <\/p>\n

Miseducation, if you\u2019re taking a class at home<\/p>\n

\u201cThe key is making sure you\u2019re taking an actual Pilates class,\u201d says Heather Andersen<\/a>, certified Pilates instructor and founder of New York Pilates, whether that is in-person or online. \u201cAs Pilates has grown in popularity, many other workouts have borrowed Pilates-inspired movements, but true Pilates is one part exercise and one part technique, so it\u2019s less about the exercise itself and more about how you move. The Pilates principles of precision, control, breath, and alignment are essential,\u201d she adds.
<\/p>\n

Intensity<\/p>\n

\u201cWithout springs to support or guide movement, people often feel like they\u2019re \u2018bad\u2019 at Pilates, when in reality, mat just demands more internal organization and body weight awareness and strength,\u201d says Page. Also, without props or springs to provide tactile resistance, it may take longer to make progress, Wolfe adds.<\/p>\n

Modifications can be tricky<\/p>\n

People with injuries or particular abilities may benefit from the support and modifications reformers provide. \u201cWhile you can modify anything, some bodies benefit immensely from the support and adjustability of the reformer carriage, footbar, and straps,\u201d says Page.
<\/p>\n

Reformer Pilates benefits<\/p>\n

Reformer Pilates uses a spring-loaded mat on a sliding carriage to offer both support and resistance, \u201cultimately making the work more accessible,\u201d says Wolfe. \u201cIt\u2019s adaptable for beginners, injury rehab, and advanced movers alike.\u201d Some other benefits may include:<\/p>\n

It\u2019s low-impact and adjustable<\/p>\n

For beginners, injured people, or those who simply prefer lower-impact exercise, reformer Pilates is a great way to gain strength more comfortably by creating a feeling of \u201cguided\u201d training, Wolfe says. That makes it accessible to people with a wide range of bodies and conditions, Page adds.<\/p>\n

More control over movement<\/p>\n

In addition to padded impact, the design of the reformer helps users with control, which can build body awareness over time, says Page. <\/p>\n

Adaptability<\/p>\n

Because the reformer has more bells and whistles, it and its accessories may be used to hyper-customize a workout. \u201cYou can make the same exercise rehab-gentle or athlete-intense with just a spring change or footbar adjustment,\u201d says Page.<\/p>\n

Instructor-led <\/p>\n

From both your instructor and the reformer (assuming you don\u2019t have an in-home machine), you can glean feedback on your form, alignment, and balance, which will help you improve over time, our experts say.<\/p>\n

Reformer Pilates potential downsides<\/p>\n

There are some obvious and not-so-obvious potential downsides to reformer work:<\/p>\n

Studio or equipment required<\/p>\n

A Pilates reformer<\/a> is a pretty significant machine, which is why studio memberships can get costly\u2014they need to be maintained. For the same reasons, in-home equipment is expensive, too. <\/p>\n

Beginner supervision is necessary
<\/p>\n

Although the reformer isn\u2019t as intimidating as it looks, it does require some education to operate safely. \u201cYou can\u2019t just jump into a class without some one-on-one instruction,\u201d says Wolfe.
<\/p>\n

Reformer Pilates vs. mat Pilates: Similarities<\/p>\n

Both mat and reformer Pilates build strength, mobility, and better posture, our experts say. That includes improved core strength and flexibility, enhanced mobility, and a mind-body connection. There is also an opportunity for both to be low-impact. They just take different routes to get there, Page says.<\/p>\n

Andersen adds: \u201cBoth emphasize controlled movement, breath, and precision, which helps create long, balanced strength while reducing strain and supporting longevity.\u201d<\/p>\n

Reformer Pilates vs. mat Pilates: Differences<\/p>\n

The reality is, the most comprehensive Pilates practice makes room for both mat and reformer. \u201cJoseph Pilates never intended the reformer to stand alone,\u201d says Wolfe. \u201cBeing over-reformed leaves gaps in strength and control that mat work and other apparatus naturally fill.\u201d
<\/p>\n

Go with mat, if…You prefer independence and minimalist exerciseYou prefer at-home exerciseIf you\u2019re looking for something travel-friendly or low-commitmentGo with reformer, if…You want more feedback, support, or modifications in body alignmentYou seek community in fitness or enjoy in-person instructionYou\u2019re looking for variety and a fun change of pace <\/p>\n

\u201cMat and reformer aren\u2019t competitors\u2014they\u2019re collaborators,\u201d says Page. \u201cPeople get the best results when they use both. Mat teaches you to organize your body. Reformer teaches you to apply that organization under load.\u201d<\/p>\n

However, we understand that doing both may not be realistic for your lifestyle (or wallet). So the good news is, both offer impactful workouts. <\/p>\n

Related Stories