{"id":4539,"date":"2025-07-18T04:15:09","date_gmt":"2025-07-18T04:15:09","guid":{"rendered":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/4539\/"},"modified":"2025-07-18T04:15:09","modified_gmt":"2025-07-18T04:15:09","slug":"what-to-know-about-nascar-antitrust-lawsuit-23xi-frm-to-be-open-teams-at-dover-indy","status":"publish","type":"post","link":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/4539\/","title":{"rendered":"What To Know About NASCAR Antitrust Lawsuit: 23XI, FRM To Be Open Teams At Dover, Indy"},"content":{"rendered":"<p>   <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/personalities\/bob-pockrass\" class=\"contributor-wrapper pd-t-b-10 flex\" data-v-d8ab971f=\"\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\"><img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/07\/1752812108_803_bob_pockrass.png\" alt=\"Bob Pockrass\" class=\"contributor-headshot\" width=\"36\" height=\"36\" data-v-d8ab971f=\"\"\/> <\/p>\n<p>Bob Pockrass<\/p>\n<p>FOX Motorsports Insider<\/p>\n<p> <\/a>   <\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">In hopes of trying to increase the revenues and influence of <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nascar\/cup-series\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\">NASCAR Cup Series<\/a> teams, 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports filed a lawsuit against NASCAR and Chairman Jim France.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams filed the lawsuit Oct. 2 in federal court in Charlotte, claiming NASCAR&#8217;s actions violate antitrust laws.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">This story will be updated with the latest developments and analysis in the case. Information comes from documents filed in the case and through conversations with those knowledgeable on antitrust issues and NASCAR racing.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">What is the latest happening in the suit?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">July 17 update<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports will be open teams for upcoming races at Dover and Indianapolis after they were denied a temporary restraining order to keep NASCAR from revoking their chartered status.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams each have had three cars with chartered status this season, but that status expired Thursday after the U.S. Court of Appeals reversed an earlier injunction.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams are seeking another injunction to remain chartered through the end of the 2025 season and possibly could still get that injunction in a couple of weeks. The ruling Thursday by U.S. District Court Judge Kenneth Bell said the restraining order wasn\u2019t necessary because there was no irreparable harm. There is no threat of them not making races over the next two weeks and no threat that sponsors or drivers would leave over that time.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Asking for an injunction to virtually be renewed after losing on appeal is rare, but the teams made a last-ditch effort this week by asking for the same injunction based on additional evidence generated in depositions and documents provided as part of discovery in the case, which is set to go to trial Dec. 1.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR argued in its court filings that the teams relinquished the charters they had prior to the 2025 season by not signing the 2025 charter agreement. By allowing them to run as chartered, NASCAR argued, has meant less money for the teams that did sign the agreement as well as no opportunity for prospective new owners to buy those charters and operate under the current agreement.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">A charter guarantees teams a spot in a race and significantly more money per race than open teams, who fight for the remaining spots in the 40-car field. Typically, there are 36 chartered teams (there will be 30 at Dover and Indy), and only twice in 21 races this year have more than four open cars entered a race. There are fewer than 40 cars entered for Dover and Indianapolis.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR has agreed not to distribute or sell the 23XI and FRM charters in any way until a ruling on the injunction, Bell wrote in his order. He also said if the number of entries changes for either Dover or Indianapolis, he would immediately reconsider his order.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">July 14 update<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">In a last-ditch effort to remain chartered as they face going into this weekend\u2019s race at Dover as open teams, 23XI and Front Row Motorsports filed a motion Monday for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Their current injunction expires Wednesday after it was overturned by the U.S. Court of Appeals last month.<\/p>\n<p>That injunction was based on District Court Judge Kenneth Bell&#8217;s ruling that the charter agreement clause agreeing not to sue NASCAR violated antitrust law and therefore the teams had a likelihood of prevailing in the lawsuit.<\/p>\n<p>The teams, in their filing in Bell&#8217;s court, said evidence gathered from discovery shows they would prevail on other grounds. And they argue that they face potential immediate harm because NASCAR sent them a letter that they would start to &#8220;unwind&#8221; the purchase of a charter each bought from Stewart-Haas Racing.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;New information surfaced through the discovery process that overwhelmingly supports our position that a preliminary injunction is legally warranted and necessary,&#8221; 23XI\/FRM attorney Jeffrey Kessler said in a statement.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR obviously opposed the motion and wants to go to Dover this weekend with 23XI and Front Row as open teams, meaning there would be 30 guaranteed spots in the field and 10 spots for open cars.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">There is no threat of the 23XI or FRM teams from making the field at Dover, as there won\u2019t be more than 40 entries. But they would earn less than a third of what they would get as open teams. Whether any races in the future would have more than 40 entries remains to be seen.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR, in a statement, said it is &#8220;unfortunate&#8221; that the courts are hearing this injunction request for a third time (NASCAR prevailed the first time while 23XI and FRM prevailed the second time before it was overturned on appeal).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;We will defend NASCAR\u2019s integrity from this baseless lawsuit forced upon the sport that threatens to divide the stakeholders committed to serving race fans everywhere,&#8221; NASCAR said in its statement.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;We remain focused on collaborating with the 13 race teams that signed the 2025 charter agreements and share our mutual goal of delivering the best racing in the world each week, including this weekend in Dover.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">July 9 update<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit denied the request of 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports for a rehearing on the reversal of the injunction that has forced NASCAR to recognize their three-car organizations as chartered teams.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The injunction expires seven days (July 16) from this decision, meaning that the teams could lose their chartered status starting with the July 19-20 race weekend at Dover.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Without charters, the three cars of each of their organizations would have to qualify for each race as open teams and they would earn less than a third of the money they would earn as a chartered team.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The 40-car field has consisted of 36 guaranteed spots for chartered cars (the chartered cars are required to come to every race) with four spots available for open teams. Only twice in the first 19 races this year has there been more than four open cars entered in a race.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR has not said whether it would proceed with 30 chartered cars and 10 open spots or make those charters temporarily available to other teams. Before the injunction, which also required them to approve the transfer of one Stewart-Haas Racing charter sold to 23XI and another sold to Front Row, NASCAR had told its teams to be prepared for a season with 32 chartered cars and eight open spots.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">A trial is scheduled for December, so there should be a decision on whether these teams could be chartered by the start of the 2026 season.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;We are disappointed by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals decision to deny our request for a full rehearing,&#8221; 23XI\/FRM attorney Jeffrey Kessler said in a statement. &#8220;This decision has no bearing on the strength of our antitrust case, which we look forward to presenting at trial.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;We are committed to racing this season as we continue to fight for more competitive and fair terms for all teams to ensure the future of the sport and remain fully confident in our case.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">June 25 update<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">U.S. District Court Judge Kenneth Bell issued a couple of opinions this week, and neither was a surprise.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Bell denied a motion by 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports to dismiss NASCAR\u2019s counterclaim that the NASCAR race teams colluded to get better terms in the charter agreement.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The judge noted that NASCAR had done enough to survive a motion to dismiss \u2014 where the judge must consider everything alleged as generally true and then determine that no law was broken \u2014 but appeared skeptical.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;The challenges to the counterclaim are best addressed at summary judgment, with a more developed factual record,&#8221; the judge wrote in his opinion.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The judge also ruled that 12 Cup teams not part of the lawsuit do not have to turn over as detailed financial data as NASCAR had asked. Bell determined the teams must turn over relatively basic information \u2014 average per car by organization with the organization not identifiable \u2014 to NASCAR, which was the teams&#8217; recommendation when trying to settle the dispute.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">During a 90-minute hearing Tuesday, Bell questioned NASCAR attorney David Johnson on why NASCAR needed to know driver salaries, sponsorship amounts, manufacturer deals and other information from the race teams.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Johnson argued that because 23XI and Front Row are alleging that the teams are not generating enough revenue to be economically viable, they need to know that information for their experts to analyze. Johnson indicated they would keep the information confidential and not identifiable by teams in any public disclosures.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Attorney Adam Ross, who represented five teams and spoke for all of them, argued that NASCAR\u2019s request has put the teams that signed the charter agreement \u2014 teams that NASCAR has referred to as &#8220;partners&#8221; \u2014 in a situation where they would have to divulge information to competitors, including NASCAR.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">He said NASCAR should not have access to how much they pay drivers and crew members as well as information on how much they pay for alliances and how much they generate in sponsorship (noting that the teams and NASCAR compete for sponsors). He indicated NASCAR is fishing to find a profitable team and then use that to disprove the 23XI and FRM allegations.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;This is a crisis for all 12 teams that are represented here,&#8221; Ross told the court.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams had offered to give certain financials to a third-party accounting firm, which would create a spreadsheet with an average per car for each organization, with the organization not identified. That is esentially what Bell ordered them to do.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">They must provide, to the best of their ability, covering only their Cup operations, total revenue, total costs \u00a0and net profits\/losses on an anonymized, average per-car basis for each year dating back to 2014. Sponsorship income must be included by the teams as part of total revenue. Only attorneys and their experts can see the info, not NASCAR executives.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR, 23XI and Front Row have all provided detailed financial information to each other as part of the discovery process. Kaulig Racing produced a five-page financial disclosure that NASCAR said met its needs.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR is also in a legal battle with INDYCAR over whether it should be allowed to depose INDYCAR President Doug Boles. His deposition is scheduled for Friday. INDYCAR\u2019s court filings indicate it has already produced more than 650 pages of documents and argues that deposing Boles is unnecessary and burdensome on him during the busiest time of the year.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Bell has urged NASCAR, 23XI and Front Row to try to settle the case, given the cost of litigation. He lamented the situation at the end of the hearing on Tuesday.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;I am amazed at the efforts of burning this house down over everybody\u2019s heads,&#8221; he said. &#8220;I am a fire marshal and I will be here in December [for trial] if need be.&#8221;\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">June 20 update<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">As expected, 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports asked the U.S. Appeals Court for a rehearing on the injunction decision issued June 5. They ask for either the original three-judge panel or all the judges of the Fourth Circuit to rehear the case.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The request, which was due June 20 (typically it would have been due June 19 but courts were closed that day for Juneteenth), automatically delays when the teams would potentially lose their chartered status.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The original injunction in December forced NASCAR to approve the transfer of the charters (one apiece) that each team bought from Stewart-Haas Racing \u2014 giving them three charters apiece \u2014 and forced NASCAR to allow them to race as chartered teams while also suing NASCAR.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">A three-judge panel reversed that decision June 5, which would have gone into effect June 27 if the teams did not ask for a rehearing in the U.S. Court of Appeals or made a request for the U.S. Supreme Court to consider the injunction issue.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;The panel\u2019s decision does not address the merits of our case,&#8221; said Jeffrey Kessler, attorney for 23XI and FRM, in a statement. &#8220;It was based solely on a narrow question: Whether the release of claims in the charter agreement could be considered anticompetitive.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;If upheld, the ruling would set a dangerous precedent, allowing monopolists to shield themselves from legal challenges simply by requiring release language as a\u00a0condition of doing business with the monopoly.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">There is no timeline for a decision on whether the appeals court will rehear the case. If the case is not reheard, the vacating of the injunction would go into effect seven days after that decision. If the case is reheard, the teams would remain chartered until a decision by the judges is made.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR has not said how it would handle guaranteed spots and how long it would take if the injunction is vacated for 23XI and Front Row to be moved to open status, which would require them to qualify on speed for each race and receive considerably less purse money each week.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">June 17 update<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">One of the biggest questions from fans since the lawsuit was filed is what do 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports want if they win.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">They aren\u2019t alone. That was the first question asked by U.S. District Court Judge Kenneth Bell during a hearing Tuesday.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Jeffrey Kessler, attorney for 23XI and FRM, said they possibly will seek:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;NASCAR to divest itself of racetracks it owns (20 of the 38 Cup events).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;NASCAR to no longer prohibit Cup tracks from hosting similar stock-car races.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;NASCAR to no longer prohibit teams from using Next Gen cars in non-NASCAR events.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;Insure the ability to compete as charter teams going forward (indicating possibly longer than the maximum 14 years of the current deal).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;Any financial damages to be tripled.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;We really won&#8217;t decide on the injunctive relief until after the jury verdict because you have to tailor your relief to what the jury finds to what issues come out,&#8221; Kessler said afterward.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The hearing focused on the 23XI\/FRM motion to throw out NASCAR\u2019s counterclaim, which alleges the Cup teams illegally conspired to get better charter terms in the 2025-31 agreement.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR attorneys argued that all the teams boycotted a team council meeting in February 2024, which indicated they had the power to boycott a race. The teams discussed a boycott of 2024 Daytona 500 qualifying races but never went through with it.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Kessler argued that because the teams did negotiate individually with NASCAR and because NASCAR negotiated with the Race Team Alliance and its Team Negotiating Committee, that there was nothing illegal about the teams trying to be aligned in their stance.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Bell indicated he would rule soon.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">In other significant developments:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;Because NASCAR said it would not go after other teams for damages as part of its counterclaim (also indicating they would not drop the charter system), Bell ruled the other teams do not need to be part of the case.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;The judge set a June 24 hearing on discovery disputes between NASCAR and the other race teams (except Kaulig) as NASCAR seeks financial information.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;Judge Bell also urged a settlement before the scheduled Dec. 1 trial, saying: &#8220;It\u2019s hard to picture a real winner out of this if this goes to the mat, or the flag in this case.&#8221;\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Kessler also said afterward that 23XI\/FRM will ask for a hearing in front of all of the Richmond-based U.S. appeals court judges to reinstate the injunction requiring NASCAR to allow 23XI and FRM to race as chartered teams in 2025. The injunction was granted on the basis that a clause in the charter agreement prohibits teams from suing NASCAR violates antitrust law. A three-judge appeals panel disagreed and threw out the injunction June 5.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;Under their decision, Google could go to all their customers and say, \u2018If you want to be on my app store, you have to waive your antitrust right\u2019 so we never get a Google case,&#8221; Kessler said. &#8220;Apple could do the same. &#8230; We think we should have a rehearing.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">If that request, which must be made by Thursday, is denied, the teams possibly would lose their charters as early as seven days after that decision.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">June 5 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The U.S. Court of Appeals vacated the injunction requiring NASCAR to treat 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports as chartered organizations for the 2025 season.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams have 14 days to ask for a rehearing by the three-judge panel or for all the appeals court judges to hear the case. The ruling goes into effect seven days after that deadline ends or, if a request for rehearing is pending, seven days after any denial by the appeals court on those requests.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">So 23XI and FRM likely have at least until June 26 before they potentially have to field cars as open teams, which would not guarantee them spots in the field each week.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">If the teams have to race as open cars, there is the possibility \u2014 if there are more open cars than spots available for them in a 40-car field \u2014 that they could fail to qualify for a race. Open teams also make significantly less money (less than a third) per race than a chartered team.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR has not said what it would do with the six charters that those teams currently have (they each have three apiece).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The appeals court ruling came about four weeks after the May 9 hearing, where the three judges expressed skepticism about the original injunction issued in December.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams had argued they needed an injunction to be charter teams because they couldn\u2019t continue with the lawsuit and sign the 2025-31 charter agreement since the charter agreement contained a provision that the teams would not sue NASCAR.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">U.S. District Court Judge Kenneth Bell ruled in December that the release-of-claims provision likely violated antitrust law and therefore the teams would be successful on the merits of the case in that aspect. The three-judge appeals panel unanimously disagreed, with their opinion stating &#8220;that theory of antitrust law is not supported by any case of which we are aware.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">With no indication of the likelihood of success on the merits of the case, the judges vacated the injunction.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;Because we have found no support for the proposition that a business entity or person violates the antitrust laws by requiring a prospective participant to give a release for past conduct as a condition for doing business, we cannot conclude that the plaintiffs made a clear showing that they were likely to succeed on the merits of that theory.&#8221; the appeals court opinion said.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;And without satisfaction of the likelihood-of-success element, the plaintiffs were not entitled to a preliminary injunction.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams and NASCAR are scheduled to be in district court June 17 for a hearing on motions to dismiss NASCAR&#8217;s counterclaim against the teams.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;We are disappointed by today&#8217;s ruling by the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals and are reviewing the decision to determine our next steps,&#8221; 23XI\/FRM attorney Jeffrey Kessler said in a statement. &#8220;This ruling is based on a very narrow consideration of whether a release of claims in the charter agreements is anti-competitive and does not impact our chances of winning at trial scheduled for December 1.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;We remain confident in our case and committed to racing for the entirety of this season as we continue our fight to create a fair and just economic system for stock car racing that is free of anticompetitive, monopolistic conduct.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">May 9 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR\u2019s appeal to the injunction ruling from December was heard by a three-judge panel in the U.S. Court of Appeals in Richmond, Va.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The judges typically take at least a couple of weeks, and sometimes a couple of months, to render a decision.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The injunction requires NASCAR to allow 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports to race as chartered teams for the 2025 season. It also required the approval of transfers of the Stewart-Haas Racing charters (one apiece) to each of those teams, who had previously agreed to purchase charters from SHR.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">If the judges rule in NASCAR\u2019s favor, the teams could ask for the entire appeals court panel to hear the case, a request occasionally but not normally granted but also a request that could delay implementation of the ruling.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Judge Kenneth Bell\u2019s ruling in December weighed heavily on the fact that NASCAR\u2019s charter agreement has a provision where the teams can\u2019t sue NASCAR, which would be applied to this case, and such a provision would be illegal. The teams felt they couldn\u2019t sign the agreement and still pursue the lawsuit \u2014 therefore the need for the injunction to race as a chartered team.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The appeals judges heavily questioned 23XI\/FRM attorney Jeffrey Kessler on why the teams should be allowed to be chartered and sue, that it was a case of the teams wanting to have their cake (be chartered) and eat it too (sue for damages). They implied that the teams could sue for damages and race open.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;It was found it is not economically viable to have to qualify each week \u2014 you may not get in, you lose your sponsors, you lose your drivers,&#8221; Kessler told the judges. &#8220;It&#8217;s in the record that our drivers have contracts. If we are not chartered teams, they can abandon us and go to different teams.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The judges questioned NASCAR attorney Chris Yates on what happens if they rule in favor of NASCAR. Yates indicated the other chartered teams would receive more money because they wouldn\u2019t be paying 23XI and FRM as chartered teams. Yates didn\u2019t indicate what would happen to the two charters transferred from SHR to those teams as well as the teams\u2019 other four charters and whether NASCAR would try to sell those or hold them until the litigation is finished (and therefore have potentially up to 10 open spots in each race).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;The point is that two-thirds of this season remains, and other racing teams would receive more money if NASCAR was not making guaranteed payments under a court-mandated contract to these plaintiffs,&#8221; NASCAR attorney Chris Yates told the judges. &#8220;And that is a real harm, not just to NASCAR, but to other racing teams.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The case has been fast-tracked for trial in December. In preparation for the trial, 23XI and FRM have sought financial information from other sports leagues and is currently in litigation with INDYCAR, the NHL, NBA and NFL to obtain that information. It has received information from Major League Baseball and recently settled its litigation with Liberty Media, owners of Formula 1.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">April 9 update:\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Front Row and 23XI, in trying to show how other motorsports and sports leagues operate, have gone to court to enforce subpoenas they have issued to the <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nfl\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\">NFL<\/a>, <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nba\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\">NBA<\/a>, <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nhl\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\">NHL<\/a> and <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/motor\/formula-1\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\">Formula 1<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">In the last two weeks, the teams have filed motions to compel compliance with subpoenas in New York (NFL, NBA, NHL) and Colorado (Formula 1 owner Liberty Media).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;Plaintiffs seek four categories of information \u2026 showing team and league revenues and how those revenues are split between the league and its teams,&#8221; the teams write in their brief to compel the NFL, NBA and NHL. &#8220;That information will enable Plaintiffs to perform a yardstick comparison between the other major professional sports leagues (where competition is not precluded) and NASCAR (where exclusionary conduct has been used to unlawfully maintain a monopoly).&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">In its opposition, the NFL wrote that it would be handing over financial data to a league that it competes against in the sports industry and the teams&#8217; attorney Jeffrey Kessler, who often represents players against the league.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;The Subpoena is based on the flimsiest of premises: that because Plaintiffs are suing NASCAR, they can obtain \u2014 by way of federal process \u2014 financials, financial projections, research, studies, analyses, and other highly confidential, proprietary, and commercially sensitive information belonging to almost every other major sports league in the United States,&#8221; the NFL wrote in its opposition.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;To be clear, there is no legitimate basis for any assertion that the information sought has any direct connection to the substantive dispute between the parties. &#8230; Put simply, not only does the Subpoena seek the NFL&#8217;s most confidential information, it would put that information into the hands of some of the NFL&#8217;s most consistent legal opponents and a participant in the broader sports and entertainment marketplace.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">There is no timeline for rulings on the motions.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">March 26 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">In response to the counterclaim filed by NASCAR against 23XI and Front Row Motorsports, the two race teams filed a motion to dismiss the counterclaim.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR alleges the teams colluded to get better terms in the charter agreement and that Curtis Polk, longtime business partner of Michael Jordan and co-owner along with Jordan and Denny Hamlin in 23XI Racing, illegally tried to organize a boycott of a qualifying race at Daytona through his role as one of the principals of the team negotiating committee.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;NASCAR\u2019s retaliatory counterclaim is an act of desperation that cannot withstand a motion to dismiss,&#8221; 23XI Racing states in its response. &#8220;It does not allege the facts necessary to state a claim. Instead, NASCAR is using the counterclaim to engage in litigation gamesmanship, with the transparent objective of intimidating the other racing teams by threatening them with severe consequences if they support Plaintiffs\u2019 challenge to the unlawful NASCAR monopoly.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The motion argues that the teams working together in negotiations is the way sports organizations&#8217; negotiations work with those who participate. That, because they have to compete under the same set of rules and policies, it is only natural for them to negotiate as a unit (although NASCAR also met with the teams one-on-one after negotiations stalled with the team\u2019s negotiating committee).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams also argue that, with no details about what Polk did and no boycott ever happening, no laws were violated.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;NASCAR nowhere alleges facts plausibly showing that any of the Counterclaim-Defendants\u2019 conduct resulted in reduced output, increased prices, decreased quality, or any other anticompetitive effects in the alleged market for the entry of cars into NASCAR races,&#8221; the 23XI filing states.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">No date for a hearing has been set. A trial in the case is scheduled for December.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">March 14 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">FRM and 23XI filed their response to NASCAR\u2019s appeal of the December injunction ruling that requires NASCAR to allow FRM and 23XI to race as chartered teams in 2025, with each having three charters that includes one each of them purchased in the offseason from Stewart-Haas Racing.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">A hearing on the appeal is set for May 9 in the U.S. Court of Appeals in Richmond. A decision would likely come weeks later. A trial in the case is set for Dec. 1, so the hope is that any disputes won&#8217;t extend into 2026.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;The injunction maintains the status quo for the 2025 season, with minimum disruption to both sides, for just enough time to allow a jury to decide the antitrust claims,&#8221; the teams&#8217; brief states.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">A key part of the appeal is the district court judge&#8217;s interpretation that NASCAR Cup Series racing is its own market and for those who want to participate in an elite stock-car series, this is their only avenue. NASCAR argues that too narrowly defines a market, that it needs to be more encompassing, such as all of motorsports or even the broader sports landscape.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams argue that they deserve the injunction because they will likely win the case \u2014 that the Cup Series requires elite teams \u2014 and 2025 charter agreement doesn\u2019t provide them with the economic model to be elite.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;The charters provide the teams with much less revenue and less favorable terms than would prevail in a market unrestrained by NASCAR\u2019s unlawful monopsony,&#8221; the teams\u2019 brief states.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;Teams do not have a fair opportunity to earn a return on their investments \u2014 tens of millions of dollars each year.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">March 5 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR filed a counterclaim alleging that during the negotiations for a new charter agreement, 23XI co-owner Curtis Polk (long-time business manager for Michael Jordan) and the 23XI and FRM teams conspired to use tactics that violated antitrust law.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR cited Polk organizing a boycott of a charter-required team meeting with owners and trying to organize a boycott of a qualifying event (a boycott that didn&#8217;t happen). NASCAR alleges the teams colluded to get better terms in the charter agreement, that they &#8220;obtained Charter Agreements that contained more beneficial terms for race teams than would have been obtained in the absence of collusion, including terms relating to duration of the Charters and financial floors.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Filing of counterclaims in lawsuits is not unusual. NASCAR used the filing of the counterclaim to also make its first public comments outside the courtroom with lead attorney Chris Yates taking questions on a conference call with reporters.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;We think 23XI and Front Row are misusing the antitrust laws and alleging baseless monopolization claims in order to try to force a renegotiation,&#8221; Yates said. &#8220;NASCAR has no intent and no interest in renegotiating the terms of the 2025 charter.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Yates reiterated that the new charter agreement for 2025-31 (that has a possible seven-year extension) provides teams with 49 percent of the revenue from the new seven-year, $1.1 billion average per year media rights deal. NASCAR says teams received 38 to 40 percent in the previous deal (25 percent through the purse with additional money through NASCAR and track contributions).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The filing asks for an injunction removing the guaranteed starting spot provision for charter teams if the lawsuit proceeds, but Yates indicated that would be decided either through summary judgment or trial, not by an injunction filing.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;Although it believes that the charter system has strengthened the sport and benefited racing teams, it doesn&#8217;t need the charter system. &#8230; NASCAR&#8217;s history, including in the Cup Series is one in which all teams raced for entry into NASCAR races,&#8221; Yates said.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;But NASCAR does believe that the most recent charter agreement, which was signed by 13 of 15 race teams representing 32 of 36 charters, is fair [and] equitable.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">As far as any possible settlement, Yates said: &#8220;We&#8217;re not going to let 23XI and Front Row misuse the antitrust laws to try to renegotiate the terms of the charter. That&#8217;s not going to happen. So I don&#8217;t see a great path to settlement, but we will participate in the court-ordered mediation process.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">23XI\/FRM attorney Jeffrey Kessler said the counterclaim is a &#8220;meritless distraction&#8221; and that NASCAR agreed to the negotiations it now attacks.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;My clients&#8217; lawsuit has always been about transforming NASCAR into a more competitive and fair sport for the benefit of drivers, fans, sponsors and teams because of their love of the sport,&#8221; Kessler said in a statement. &#8220;Every major sport goes through a transition to competition when antitrust claims are asserted, and that moment has come for NASCAR.\u00a0\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;Today&#8217;s baseless filing changes nothing. We are confident in the strength of our case and look forward to presenting it at trial.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Feb. 12 update:\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR filed its appeal brief to the injunction that allows 23XI and Front Row to operate as charter teams while suing NASCAR for antitrust violations.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR\u2019s main argument is that the teams won&#8217;t likely succeed on the merits of the case in that they have other racing options if they don\u2019t like the terms of the NASCAR charter agreement \u2013 that NASCAR Cup Series racing can&#8217;t be the defined &#8220;market&#8221; when it comes to antitrust issues.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The sanctioning body also reiterates that 13 of the 15 organizations signed the charter agreement that runs from 2025-31 (with a possible extension), an agreement that includes teams now getting approximately 50 percent of the media revenues, an increase from about 37 percent from the previous deal \u2013 which shows that they do have an economically viable business model.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR also was critical of U.S. District court judge Kenneth Bell&#8217;s ruling that the clause in the charter agreement that releases NASCAR from legal claims violates antitrust law.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;These injunctions misuse the judicial power to force NASCAR to treat its litigation adversaries as its business partners and confidants, undermining the mutual trust that has fueled NASCAR\u2019s growth and success,&#8221; NASCAR says in its brief.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;Worse, the district court conjured from thin air a categorical ban on sports leagues including releases broad enough to encompass antitrust claims in their agreements \u2013 eliminating the need to prove anticompetitive conduct, a crucial element.&#8221;\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams&#8217; response is due March 14. NASCAR&#8217;s reply is due April 12. A likely hearing on the appeal will be May 9 or May 15 in the U.S. Court of Appeals Fourth Circuit (Richmond, Va.) with a decision likely by the end of June.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Jan. 10 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR&#8217;s motion to dismiss the case was denied by U.S. District Court judge Kenneth Bell. The judge also declined to require the teams to post a bond for any earnings they receive this year that could be paid back if they lose the case.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Bell&#8217;s ruling was not a surprise, coming just two days after the hearing where he indicated he would expect the case to proceed. He wrote that whether NASCAR has violated antitrust law is not clear at this point in the lawsuit. He has set a Dec. 1 date for a jury trial.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;The answers must be found when the parties have a full opportunity to pursue discovery of the relevant facts and then at trial, where the jury will be able to weigh the evidence and assess the credibility of the witnesses,&#8221; the judge wrote in his opinion.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The next major step in the case will come in the U.S. Court of Appeals, where NASCAR is appealing injunctions that require NASCAR to allow 23XI and Front Row to compete in 2025 with three chartered cars apiece. Both teams were initially offered two charters apiece (they didn&#8217;t sign those agreements because of a clause in the agreements that released NASCAR of legal claims) and each has purchased a charter from Stewart-Haas Racing. The injunction requires NASCAR to approve the transfers of those charters.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Jan. 8 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">A hearing was conducted in U.S. District Court on NASCAR\u2019s motion to dismiss the case. Judge Kenneth Bell heard arguments from both sides but did not rule. He also heard arguments on whether the teams should have to post a bond to cover any charter payouts they receive this year but possibly would have to return if they lose the case.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">According to the Associated Press, Bell promised a fast ruling but indicated he was unlikely to dismiss the suit when he closed the 90-minute hearing by saying &#8220;this case is going to be tried this year, and deserves to be tried this year.&#8221;\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">For NASCAR to prevail in having the case dismissed, it must show that even when taking the facts that the teams present are true, that no laws have been broken and the case should be thrown out. For that to happen at this stage is considered unlikely, considering Judge Bell\u2019s previous rulings.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR argues that\u00a0defining the market as Cup racing is too narrow for antitrust claims, that its actions show it is not anticompetitive as it has increased in the percent of television revenues given to the team as part of the 2025 charter agreement (signed by 13 of 15 Cup organizations) and that 23XI and FRM have already invested in the system so they can\u2019t invest and then claim antitrust violations.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Bell has issued an injunction (technically two injunctions) requiring NASCAR to allow 23XI and FRM to race as charter organizations in 2025 using three charters apiece. Both 23XI and FRM were two-car organizations in 2024 and purchased a charter from Stewart Haas-Racing, and the injunction requires NASCAR to approve the transfers of those charters.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">23XI technically had to request a separate injunction, and NASCAR agreed to it without giving up the defense on appeal in order to speed up the appeals process. NASCAR is currently appealing the injunctions in the U.S. Court of Appeals but no timetable has been set for a hearing and\/or when a decision would come. NASCAR\u2019s preseason exhibition Clash event is scheduled for Feb. 2 and the season-opening Daytona 500 is set for Feb. 16.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Dec. 23, 2024 update<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR must approve the transfer of one Stewart-Haas Racing charter to Front Row Motorsports, but as part of procedure, 23XI Racing must ask the court specifically for its charter purchase from SHR to be approved by NASCAR, a U.S. District Court judge ruled Monday.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Judge Kenneth Bell issued an injunction last week that NASCAR must allow, while the lawsuit continues, for 23XI and Front Row to have their two existing cars continue as chartered teams in 2025 and that NASCAR approve the transfers of the SHR charters to those teams (which would be a third car for each).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR filed an emergency motion in district court to halt the teams from closing on those purchases until an appeal can be heard on the injunction ruling. The teams had indicated they planned on closing on the sales last week, and Judge Bell ruled Dec. 20 that if they had not closed yet, to wait until he ruled Dec. 23.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The judge issued his opinion and opted to tweak the injunction, ruling that because 23XI had not asked for its charter transfer to be approved as part of its initial injunction request (23XI had not gotten a formal denial at that time), he would remove that from the injunction order he issued last week \u2013 but the judge will allow 23XI to ask for the court-ordered approval in a separate motion. The judge also ruled he would not delay enforcement of the SHR charter to FRM because that was clearly asked for as part of the injunction request.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR argued that approving the SHR transfers would commit it to guaranteeing a charter to 23XI and FRM for seven-to-14 years (the length of the charter agreement that goes into effect in 2025). The judge stated that if the teams don\u2019t prevail in the case, he can order them to sell or lease the charters to someone else.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams argued that NASCAR had indicated it would approve the transfers but then reversed course once the teams filed the lawsuit, an example of its anticompetitive conduct. They also argued that SHR, recently rebranded into Haas Factory Team with plans to field one Cup car, did not have the personnel nor ability to filed two additional cars.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">It is expected that 23XI will file for a preliminary injunction with respect to the charter it wants from SHR, and it is expected that NASCAR will appeal the ruling that denied its ability to delay approval of an SHR charter transfer to Front Row until the appeal is heard.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Dec. 18, 2024 update<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">In a big victory for 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports, their request for a preliminary injunction was granted.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Judge Kenneth Bell&#8217;s ruling requires NASCAR to allow 23XI and FRM to sign the charter agreements they were offered in early September (NASCAR had said those offers were off the table) and approve the transfer of a charter each team plans to purchase from Stewart-Haas Racing. The injunction is only good for 2025 as the judge plans to have a trial completed before the start of the 2026 season.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams didn&#8217;t initially sign the charter agreement because they wanted to pursue the antitrust lawsuit, but the charters included a clause releasing NASCAR of legal claims. So they pursued the injunction, which was initially denied by Judge Frank Whitney in mid-November with the caveat he would reconsider it if circumstances changed. The teams submitted new circumstances, and Judge Bell \u2013 who was assigned the case last week (no reason for the change was given) \u2013 ruled in the teams&#8217; favor. NASCAR can appeal the ruling.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">To obtain the injunction, the teams needed to prevail on four factors:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;Likelihood of success: The judge ruled that the clause in the charter agreement that released NASCAR of legal claims would likely be considered unlawful, that the &#8220;release is not a model of clarity (inscrutable would be a fairer description).&#8221; The judge noted that &#8220;the Court emphasizes that it does not reach and expresses no opinion as to Plaintiffs\u2019 likelihood of success on their other [antitrust claims].&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The judge did opine that NASCAR&#8217;s claim that premier stock-car racing is too narrow of a definition of a market when it comes to antitrust claims was not persuasive: &#8220;The availability of multiple sports in the United States says nothing about NASCAR\u2019s control of a major one of them in the same way that the availability of professional basketball and football did not lead to a finding that the NCAA was not a monopolist with respect to the highest levels of college basketball and football.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;Irreparable harm: The judge ruled that because drivers notified their teams of potential breach of contract and sponsors said they are reviewing their financial commitments was enough to show irreparable harm. Tyler Reddick, who won the regular season title for 23XI, would have become a free agent Dec. 19 because the team is required to provide him a chartered car. The judge ruled that the ability (whether it would happen or not) for Reddick to negotiate and potentially leave was enough \u2013 and his leaving is not something that could be compensated by financial damages if the teams ultimately won the lawsuit.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;Balancing of equities: The judge ruled that NASCAR would not be harmed by the injunction as it initially had plans for 36 charters and a corresponding payout structure while the teams would have possibly missed races as an open team.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;Public interest: The judge ruled that the public interest is for the teams to continue racing as chartered teams.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;NASCAR fans (and members of the public who may become fans) have an interest in watching all the teams compete with their best drivers and most competitive teams,&#8221; the judge wrote. &#8220;Further, the public has an interest in preserving the rights of litigants to pursue legal claims in good faith, particularly antitrust claims that aim to preserve the process of commercial competition.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the ruling.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Dec 12, 2024 update<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">In a flurry of filings in the last four days, NASCAR and the teams argued their sides on the renewed motion for preliminary injunction. And they now are making them before a different judge.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">On late Wednesday afternoon, the court reassigned the case to Judge Kenneth Bell. There was no reason given on why Judge Frank Whitney, who issued the initial preliminary junction ruling, is no longer handling the case.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Whitney had ruled a month earlier that the teams had to show more than speculative irreparable harm to get an injunction and for them to re-file if circumstances changed. Irreparable harm is harm that without the injunction, even if the teams eventually win the case, the damage they suffer cannot be adequately addressed monetarily.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports claim circumstances have changed and indicated there are deadlines next week as far as the purchases of a charter each plan to buy from Stewart-Haas Racing. They are asking to be allowed to sign the charter agreements, and for NASCAR to approve the transfer of the SHR charters, without giving up the right to pursue the antitrust lawsuit. They say they couldn&#8217;t sign the charter agreements by the deadline because there is a clause in the charter agreement that can be interpreted that they are giving up the right to sue.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">As proof of new circumstances that would result in irreparable harm, Front Row Motorsports general manager Jerry Freeze, in court documents, claims the charter transfer from SHR was approved by NASCAR in September but after they recently filed the official paperwork, NASCAR said the team would have to drop the antitrust lawsuit to have the transfer approved.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams argued they could lose drivers and sponsors and potentially miss races if they must race as an open team. Much of the evidence they cite \u2014 emails from drivers and sponsors \u2014 have been redacted from public court documents.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR, in its filing Dec. 9, reiterated many of its previous arguments from the first hearing as well as its recent motion to dismiss.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR argues that no 23XI nor FRM driver says he will leave the teams if they are not chartered and even if a driver would leave, the teams were the ones who put in contracts that drivers could leave if they didn\u2019t have a chartered car. NASCAR also alleged that there appeared to be a coordinated effort by the teams to have the drivers send emails, an allegation denied by 23XI President Steve Lauletta in court filings.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR reiterated its plan to have 32 chartered teams, which would give them eight open spots for each race. NASCAR argues that both 23XI and FRM, which plan to field three cars apiece, most likely would not miss a race with eight open spots available (instead of four).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">As far as the SHR charters, NASCAR indicated FRM will argue that the release of legal claims clause is unenforceable so it plans on signing that transfer paperwork. As far as whether any parts of the charter agreement are enforceable, NASCAR claimed that the charter agreement terms require those issues to be decided through arbitration rather than decided through the courts.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams have another filing due Monday, Dec. 16, where they will respond to NASCAR\u2019s recent motion to dismiss. No hearing dates have been set by Judge Bell.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Dec. 2, 2024 update<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR filed its motion to dismiss and general answer to the lawsuit. A motion to dismiss, at this stage of litigation, argues that even if the facts presented by the teams are true, that no laws were broken and therefore the case must be thrown out.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR argues that the teams just didn&#8217;t get what they wanted in the 2025 charter agreement, and that is not an antitrust issue \u2013 and even if it is, that most of the conduct that the teams allege violates antitrust law occurred beyond the statute of limitations of four years. It argues that the teams can\u2019t already have invested and competed in NASCAR and then claim NASCAR operations are anticompetitive. And they say the 2025 charter agreement \u2013 signed by 13 of 15 organizations but not by 23XI and FRM \u2013 show they don\u2019t operate in the monopolistic fashion claimed by the teams as NASCAR increased the percentage of television revenues awarded to the teams.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">\u00a0&#8220;Plaintiffs concede the Charters are &#8220;worth millions of dollars&#8221; and NASCAR increased the revenues available to teams. &#8230; If NASCAR truly had market power, it would be decreasing its demand for Plaintiffs\u2019 services and lowering the amount by which it compensates them,&#8221; NASCAR argues.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR indicated in its filings it would not approve transfers for Stewart-Haas Racing charters (23XI and FRM each plan on purchasing one) without the teams accepting the clause in the charter agreements that release NASCAR of antitrust claims.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams have asked for an injunction to force NASCAR to allow 23XI and FRM to sign the charter agreements (they each would have three with the purchase of an additional one from SHR) but continue the antitrust litigation.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">No hearing date has been set for the judge to consider that injunction motion nor the motion to dismiss.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Nov. 26, 2024 update<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports teams filed a renewed motion for preliminary injunction, citing new circumstances that they claim show they face more than just a risk of irreparable harm, which the judge told them they must show if they want the motion reconsidered.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The new circumstances cited are redacted from the court filing, where the teams ask to be allowed to sign the charter agreement while not having to abide by the clause that releases NASCAR from antitrust violations. The teams claim that sponsors are making decisions for 2025 and they indicate sponsors want assurances the teams will race as charter teams.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Each of the teams have agreements to purchase a charter each from Stewart-Haas Racing and they indicate they must decide to close within three weeks. They ask the judge, even if the request to be charter teams is not granted, that he allow them to purchase the SHR charters without giving up their rights to sue.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR is expected to respond to the lawsuit by Dec. 9. A hearing has not yet been scheduled.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Nov. 20, 2024 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">23XI and Front Row Motorsports have dropped their appeal to the denial of their motion for a preliminary injunction.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">They want the courts to force NASCAR to allow them to sign the charter agreement without giving up their right to sue on antitrust grounds, which is prohibited by one of the clauses in the charter agreement.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">U.S. District Court judge Frank Whitney denied that request Nov. 8, stating that the teams couldn&#8217;t prove irreparable harm, they only showed they might suffer harm if they can&#8217;t race as chartered teams. In his ruling, he stated that if the facts change and they could show more of a likelihood of irreparable harm, the teams could refile the preliminary injunction motion.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams had appealed the decision but dropped the appeal Nov. 20, stating: &#8220;Circumstances have changed in the underlying case, removing the need for this appeal and necessitating Appellants to seek new relief from the district court.&#8221;\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">While it is not specific and there could be other extenuating circumstances that have occurred, the wording in that statement indicates the possible refiling of the preliminary injunction in district court. There was no immediate comment from the teams beyond what was stated in the filing.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Nov. 16, 2024 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">After receiving 2025 open team agreement paperwork, 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports can race as an open team while pursuing the lawsuit. According to the teams, the current paperwork doesn&#8217;t include the clause in the open agreement that releases NASCAR of certain legal claims.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The clause remains in the 2025 charter team agreement, and the teams will continue to appeal the denial of their request for a preliminary injunction for the clause to be waived to allow them to sign the charter agreement (which NASCAR says is now off the table). The ruling on the preliminary injunction denial included both the charter and open agreements.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">This means that 23XI and Front Row will at least field teams as open cars. Under previous open agreement provisions, the teams would have had to sign the open agreement and risk that the legal claims release clause would be considered valid, which would dismiss the case in favor of NASCAR.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Denny Hamlin said a week ago after the denial of the preliminary injunction that their entire 2025 plans were to be determined. Now 23XI and FRM, as stated in previous court documents, will plan to proceed as three-car teams in 2025, even if they are open cars (meaning they aren\u2019t guaranteed a spot in every race and receive significantly less revenue for racing).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams have asked the U.S. Court of Appeals to expedite the timeline to rule on the denial of the preliminary injunction. They have asked that all briefs be filed in the next few weeks and for a hearing during the court\u2019s Dec. 10-13 session for oral arguments. The teams argue that waiting until the court\u2019s Jan. 28-31 session is too close to the start of the season, and a normal briefing schedule would put it on the calendar for the March 18-21 session.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The appeals court can also rule without a hearing, although the teams are requesting one. NASCAR, which opposes the accelerated timeline, has until Nov. 18 to respond to the teams\u2019 request.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Nov. 8, 2024 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Preliminary injunction denied. Because the charter and open agreements contain a release clause waiving the ability to sue NASCAR, the 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports organizations had sought an injunction to allow them to sign the agreement (preferably a charter agreement) while pursuing the lawsuit.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">To be granted a preliminary injunction, one must prove irreparable harm without the injunction. The teams argued that drivers and sponsors could be allowed to leave and if they compete only as an open team, which earns significantly less money than a chartered team and is not guaranteed a spot in the field each week, that they eventually might have to shut down.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">U.S. District Court Judge Frank Whtney determined that those harms were speculative impacts, not definitive ones that would require an injunction.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;Plaintiffs have alleged that they will face a risk of irreparable harm, they have not sufficiently alleged present, immediate, urgent irreparable harm, but rather only speculative, possible harm,&#8221; the judge wrote.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;That is, although Plaintiffs allege they are on the brink of irreparable harm, the 2025 racing season is months away \u2014 the stock cars remain in the garage.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The judge ruled that should facts change, the teams could file the preliminary injunction motion again. The teams can appeal the ruling to the U.S. Court of Appeals.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The ruling came out during NASCAR&#8217;s annual &#8220;state of the sport&#8221; address and news conference at the season-finale weekend in Phoenix. NASCAR President Steve Phelps said he had no comment.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">What happens next? The teams could sign the open agreement (NASCAR currently says the charter agreement is off the table for those organizations) but then would have to argue that the clause releasing NASCAR of claims is not enforceable.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">23XI and FRM will appeal the decision. Attorney Jeffrey Kessler said he was pleased the judge decided to fast track discovery and other deadlines as part of his decision but obviously they wanted more.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;Although we are disappointed that the preliminary injunction\u00a0was denied without prejudice and\u00a0as premature, which we intend to appeal, this denial has no bearing on the merits of our case,&#8221; Kessler said in a statement.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;My clients will move forward to race in 2025 and continue to fight for a more fair and equitable system in NASCAR that complies with antitrust law.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">November 4, 2024 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Attorneys for both sides sparred during the 70-minute preliminary injunction hearing. The judge said he hoped to rule by Friday, Nov. 8.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Jeffrey Kessler argued that 23XI Racing driver Tyler Reddick, who is in the hunt for the Cup championship, and the team&#8217;s sponsors could leave if they are not allowed to run as a charter team while pursuing the lawsuit.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Even if they are an open team, they need an injunction, Kessler said, because the open agreement teams must sign releases NASCAR of antitrust claims. Although they have signed the agreements in the past, which NASCAR argued implies their consent, Kessler argued that the injunction focuses on the stipulation in a contract they have not signed (the 2025 charter and\/or open agreements).<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR attorney Chris Yates said 23XI has sophisticated ownership with Michael Jordan as a co-owner and by competing in NASCAR, the teams can&#8217;t enjoy the benefits of being a charter team \u2014 which he said includes about 50 percent of NASCAR&#8217;s television revenues going to Cup teams \u2014 while making antitrust claims. And if the teams prevail, Yates said monetary damages can be calculated, so therefore an injunction is not needed.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;They make bold announcements that ignore the evidence,&#8221; Yates told the court, later adding &#8220;The real problem is plaintiffs claim that they are saying something is anticompetitive for something they joined.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Yates noted that &#8220;they could invest in NASCAR, they could invest in IndyCar, they could buy an NBA team.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The last part, obviously, was a reference to Jordan&#8217;s former ownership of the Charlotte NBA team.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Kessler argued that the teams have put all their resources into stock cars and the injunction merely maintains the status quo while the litigation proceeds.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;They have no place else to practice their profession \u2014 you can&#8217;t go to a football player and say you can be a basketball player,&#8221; Kessler told the court.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Any decision is likely to be appealed, Kessler said following the hearing.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Outside the courtroom, Michael Jordan commented on being in court six days before Reddick competes for the Cup title.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;I&#8217;ve been in situations of disparity \u2014 the race team is going to focus on what they have to do this weekend, which I expect them to,&#8221; Jordan said. &#8220;I think Jeffrey did an unbelievable job today.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;I put all my cards on the table. I think we did a good job of that. But I&#8217;m looking forward to winning a championship this weekend.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">October 31, 2024 update:\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The judge has denied an expedited discovery request from 23XI and FRM for NASCAR to produce documents prior to the Nov. 4 preliminary injunction hearing.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8220;While the proposed discovery requests may help Plaintiffs show a likelihood of success on the merits, they are not sufficiently narrowly tailored and \u2026 Plaintiffs argue the record is sufficient to support their motion for preliminary injunction as it stands,&#8221; the judge wrote in his ruling.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">October 30, 2024 update:\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">In their reply to NASCAR&#8217;s response to their injunction request, 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports reiterated many of their previous arguments but with a couple of new points they hope can help them land the preliminary injunction:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;The teams argue that if they race as open teams, they still have to sign the NASCAR open team agreement, which includes the same clause that would release NASCAR of any claims the teams make in the lawsuit. So to even proceed fielding open, non-chartered cars, the teams would need an injunction to pursue the lawsuit.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">&#8211;The teams also argue that NASCAR would not be harmed by the injunction because NASCAR already had planned, up until mid-September, to have 36 chartered teams, and therefore by allowing them to compete as chartered teams and pursuing the lawsuit, it is merely continuing the status quo.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">October 23, 2024 update:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Both NASCAR and the teams had filings due Oct. 23 as part of the preliminary injunction process where 23XI Racing and Front Row Motorsports are asked to compete as chartered teams while pursuing the lawsuit (they cite a clause in the charter agreement that would prohibit them from suing). A hearing on the preliminary injunction motion is scheduled for Nov. 4.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR filed its response to 23XI\/Front Row&#8217;s preliminary injunction motion, and obviously NASCAR doesn&#8217;t want to give them that benefit to run as a chartered team, considering 13 of the 15 Cup organizations have signed charter agreements.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR says it plans to run in 2025 with 32 chartered teams (instead of 36 this year) and eight open cars (instead of four) in its 40-car field \u2014 23XI and Front Row currently have two charters apiece that they have yet to sign for.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR argues that the teams don&#8217;t meet the requirements for an injunction because they can still compete as open teams and that any damages that they suffer if they prevail in the case can be covered monetarily.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR also argues that 23XI and FRM won&#8217;t win the case because NASCAR Cup racing is not the market when it comes to antitrust law, that there are other racing and entertainment options. They argue the exclusivity provisions the teams cite as violating antitrust laws are common across sports and pro-competitive because they make the product more appealing to broadcasters, fans and sponsors when compared to other entertainment options.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams, who have until Oct. 30 to reply to NASCAR&#8217;s filing from Oct. 23, filed a reply to NASCAR&#8217;s response to the teams&#8217; request for expedited discovery. The teams primarily argue that documents they want prior to the preliminary injunction hearing Nov. 4 will not be difficult for NASCAR to gather\/produce and courts regularly grant expedited discovery to provide a more fulsome record for a preliminary injunction motion. The judge is expected to rule on this in the coming days.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Previous updates:<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">23XI and Front Row filed a motion Oct. 9 for a preliminary injunction to allow them to race in 2025 as chartered teams \u2014 they have refused to sign the charter agreement, which was signed Sept. 6 by the 13 other Cup organizations \u2014 while the lawsuit proceeds.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">To get a preliminary injunction, 23XI and Front Row primarily must show a likelihood of success on the merits of the case and irreparable harm if the injunction is not issued. They also must show that a preliminary injunction is in the public interest.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams claim that the guaranteed spot in every race (which a charter team gets) is critical to their business. The Daytona 500 alone is worth about 15% of the entire season&#8217;s purse, according to the teams&#8217; court filings, and &#8220;there is a risk that irreplaceable sponsors and drivers could abandon [the teams] if they have to compete as open teams and do not qualify for all their races.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Front Row owner Bob Jenkins in court filings stated: &#8220;Because of our love for the sport and our determination to maintain the race team we have built, we are determined to race next year even if we have to do so on an \u2018open&#8217; basis, but at some point, the losses may become so severe that we simply cannot continue \u2014 causing irreparable harm to our business, our employees, and the communities and fans we are associated with.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR indicated in an Oct. 9 court filing on the scheduling for the hearing on the injunction request, why it opposes the motion. NASCAR says the case is more a contract case and not an antitrust case and the teams&#8217; motion doesn&#8217;t meet the criteria for a preliminary injunction.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR argues that an injunction is not a necessary measure because if it ultimately loses the case, the court could determine monetary damages that would compensate the teams.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">On Oct. 16, NASCAR filed its response to the teams&#8217; request for expedited production of documents and files. In that filing, NASCAR states that it is &#8220;planning a 2025 season with 32 instead of 36 Charters. NASCAR carries contractual obligations to the 13 teams that accepted its offers of 2025 Charters, and consistent with the terms of the 2025 Charters, NASCAR is working on reallocating funds that Plaintiffs would have received to increase prize money and other special awards for the 2025 season for the benefit of teams that timely executed 2025 Charters, as well as Open teams who can compete to win the increased prize money and other special awards.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">What is next?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR must file a response to that preliminary injunction motion by Oct. 23. The judge initially scheduled the hearing for Oct. 16 but NASCAR, with its offices in Daytona Beach, asked for it to be postponed because their offices were shut down for at least a couple of days because of Hurricane Milton. The hearing was moved to Nov. 4 with each side getting 30 minutes. The judge wouldn&#8217;t necessarily have to rule on the day of the hearing but typically would in the days following.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">As far as the teams&#8217; request that NASCAR produce documents in the next few weeks, the teams must reply to NASCAR&#8217;s response by Oct. 23. The judge would then rule on that motion between then and the Nov. 4 hearing.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Who are the parties of the suit?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The 23XI Racing team is owned by driver <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nascar\/denny-hamlin-driver\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">Denny Hamlin<\/a> (who drives for Joe Gibbs Racing), basketball icon Michael Jordan and Jordan business associate Curtis Polk. They field cars for <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nascar\/darrell-wallace-jr-driver\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">Bubba Wallace<\/a> and <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nascar\/tyler-reddick-driver\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">Tyler Reddick<\/a>, and plan to add a third car next year regardless of the lawsuit status.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The Front Row Motorsports team is owned by restaurant franchisee Bob Jenkins. It fields cars for <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nascar\/michael-mcdowell-driver\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">Michael McDowell<\/a> (who will be replaced by <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nascar\/noah-gragson-driver\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">Noah Gragson<\/a> next year) and <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nascar\/todd-gilliland-driver\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">Todd Gilliland<\/a>. It plans to add a third car next year regardless of the lawsuit status.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR is owned by the France family, primarily Jim France and France&#8217;s niece, Lesa France Kennedy. Jim&#8217;s father, Bill France Sr., founded NASCAR in 1948.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">What are the basics of the suit?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams say that a premier stock-car racing series must have premier stock-car racing teams to have a premier stock-car racing product. They argue that because NASCAR owns the series and the majority of the tracks while also requiring the teams to purchase parts and pieces for their cars from a NASCAR-approved supplier, as well as prohibiting teams and tracks from participating in other racing (primarily stock-car racing) series without NASCAR&#8217;s approval, that they violate antitrust law by controlling the market where premier stock-car racing teams can compete. They view the new 2025 charter agreement as unfair when it comes to revenue distribution to the teams in combination with the restrictions.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">What is the charter agreement?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The 2025 charter agreement is designed to be an extension of the charter system that was formed in 2016 as NASCAR attempted to address the team business model by defining the guaranteed revenues teams would get and guaranteeing a spot in every Cup race. It in many ways acts as a franchise but differs from other sports leagues in that the teams do not have ownership in the league itself. The teams and NASCAR had been negotiating a new agreement for a couple of years to replace the one that expires at the end of the 2024 season. On the late afternoon\/early evening of Sept. 6, the teams were sent a final NASCAR proposed agreement and given until midnight to sign it.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">What are the teams asking for?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The lawsuit isn&#8217;t too specific about what the teams are asking for. They are asking for any relief necessary to restore competition and unspecified monetary damages.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">What does Michael Jordan say?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The basketball icon told FOX Sports on Oct. 6 prior to the Talladega race: &#8220;I did it for the smaller teams as well. It&#8217;s not just me. I think everybody should have an opportunity to be successful in any business. My voice is saying that it hasn&#8217;t been happening. &#8230; Hopefully we [at both sides] can come to our senses and figure out something that can make sense for everybody.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Michael Jordan says he hopes for a quick resolution to the lawsuit with NASCAR  <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/watch\/fmc-o20t5qtspox687xk\" class=\"pointer video\" data-v-63c9d14b=\"\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">    <img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/07\/mrw5kwtxzgf5dvts.jpg\" alt=\"Michael Jordan says he hopes for a quick resolution to the lawsuit with NASCAR\" loading=\"eager\" width=\"175\" height=\"175\" class=\"thumbnail\" data-v-63c9d14b=\"\"\/><\/a>  <\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">What does NASCAR say?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Jim France and NASCAR President Steve Phelps, when approached by FOX Sports during the Talladega race weekend on Oct. 6, declined comment on the lawsuit. The sanctioning body has yet to issue a statement other than what is in public court filings.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">In a Sept. 18 letter to 23XI Racing, an exhibit in the court filings, Phelps wrote: &#8220;It appears after 2+ years of negotiations with Teams, both collectively and individually, compromise and concession on both sides up until the last minute, we firmly believe that we have come up with a document that is fair and equitable to the industry. &#8230; You suggest that NASCAR somehow has \u2018monopoly power&#8217; and that 23XI and other Teams \u2018depend on [NASCAR] for a competitive opportunity&#8217; and have been presented with a \u2018take-it-or-leave-it offer.&#8217; We feel \u2014 and our attorneys have confirmed \u2014 that this contention is misplaced \u2014 and similar types of claims have already been rejected by courts.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">In its Oct. 16 filing, NASCAR sums up the suit by stating: &#8220;Plaintiffs have filed a meritless suit against NASCAR alleging baseless antitrust claims in order to obtain commercial agreements they previously rejected, and to attempt to extort more favorable contract terms.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">What do other team owners say?\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">RCR owner Richard Childress: &#8220;I didn&#8217;t have a choice. We had to sign. I have over 400 employees, OEM [manufacturer] contracts, contracts with sponsors. I&#8217;ve got to take care of my team.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Trackhouse owner Justin Marks: &#8220;It&#8217;s a wait-and-see game. It&#8217;s going to take a long time to take to get to any sort of point where we know what the future looks like. &#8230; For us, we just have to focus on Trackhouse. Ultimately, we got to a place where I was comfortable signing the contract. We did a great job the last couple of years building a viable business under the current arrangement and the new one will continue that in our standpoint.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">RFK Racing owner (and driver) <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nascar\/brad-keselowski-driver\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">Brad Keselowski<\/a>: &#8220;We&#8217;re always going to be fighting over a piece of the pie. &#8230; I just want peace. I want our entire industry to become laser-focused on growing the sport and creating incentives where we all win when that happens.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">What do drivers say?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\"><a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nascar\/kyle-larson-driver\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">Kyle Larson<\/a> (Hendrick Motorsports):\u00a0&#8220;We&#8217;re probably one of the only sports, if not the only sport, that athlete salary has gone down in the last couple of decades. Where you look at, clearly, most athletes&#8217; salaries are going up \u2014 not just athletes but coaches, staff members, everybody. Obviously we would love to see it trend upward instead of the opposite, which it&#8217;s been, but I think with that, the teams probably have to make a lot more money to make it viable to pay the people that are working for the organizations.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\"><a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/nascar\/joey-logano-driver\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">Joey Logano<\/a> (Team Penske):\u00a0&#8220;Does it affect me? I&#8217;m sure someway, somehow, someday, it probably will. But at the moment, there&#8217;s nothing I can do either way. So I&#8217;m just kind of letting it roll and see how the cards fall and see what happens.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Michael McDowell (Front Row): &#8220;Bob Jenkins is so dedicated to this sport.\u00a0&#8230; He has spent millions and millions and millions and millions and millions of his own dollars to be in this sport and to be competitive.\u00a0Nobody does that unless they&#8217;re insane or super passionate.\u00a0Bob is very passionate.&#8221;<\/p>\n<p>Kevin Harvick says Kyle Larson is a better all-around driver than Max Verstappen!  <a href=\"https:\/\/www.foxsports.com\/watch\/fmc-55i5lxk95zp6p8wx\" class=\"pointer video\" data-v-63c9d14b=\"\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">    <img decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/07\/iknkx1bnqjbr62yd.jpg\" alt=\"Kevin Harvick says Kyle Larson is a better all-around driver than Max Verstappen!\" loading=\"eager\" width=\"175\" height=\"175\" class=\"thumbnail\" data-v-63c9d14b=\"\"\/><\/a>  <\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Who are the lawyers?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The teams&#8217; main attorney is Jeffrey Kessler, who is known for representing NCAA athletes in their quest to earn money from their name, image and likeness. He also has represented U.S. women&#8217;s national team players in their quest for equal pay. He also represented Tom Brady during &#8220;<a href=\"https:\/\/en.wikipedia.org\/wiki\/Deflategate\" target=\"_blank\" rel=\"noopener nofollow\">Deflategate<\/a>.&#8221;\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR is represented by Chris Yates, a noted attorney who has represented the U.S. Soccer Federation, the UFC, World Aquatics, Fanatics, the Atlantic Coast Conference and the Hollywood Foreign Press Association.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Who is the judge?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">The judge was Frank Whitney, who was appointed to the bench in 2006. He is a former Army reservist, a military intelligence officer, and spent 15 years as a federal prosecutor in North Carolina.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">On Dec. 11, the case was reassigned to Judge Kenneth Bell. He is a former federal prosecutor who also served in private practice from 2003 until his appointment by President Trump in 2019. He is a 1983 graduate of Wake Forest University&#8217;s law school.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">How long could this take?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">This case could settle at any time. But it could take two years or more if it went to trial. And then any appeal could take a year or more. And if there are decisions that could merit an appeal before the case continues toward trial, it could take even longer.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Will the teams win?\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">There is no question NASCAR controls many aspects of the sport. It has faced antitrust actions twice over the last 25 years, but those complaints came from racetracks that wanted Cup races (NASCAR prevailed in one, settled the other). The key for the teams is to get past what most likely will be a motion to dismiss (where NASCAR would ask the judge to rule that it didn&#8217;t violate the law even if everything the race teams allege is true) before discovery occurs. If NASCAR fails to persuade the judge to throw out the case, the teams would get to look at NASCAR&#8217;s books and emails, which would then give them the opportunity to find any egregious acts that discourage competition. It is possible that alone would push NASCAR to settle.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Will NASCAR win?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">NASCAR leadership could argue that they gave teams a charter agreement to help them and were under no obligation to do so \u2014 and that there could be more competition if there was no charter agreement whatsoever because no one would be guaranteed a spot in the field. They could argue that they don&#8217;t stifle competition because there are other stock-car series, albeit on a smaller scale (such as the CARS tour), or other racing series that teams could compete in. And they could argue against the premise that they are legally required to have premier racing teams competing in their events.\u00a0<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">And what would be the potential outcomes?<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">That is the biggest question. The teams appear to want their preferred terms of the charter deal \u2014 they would like to see permanent charters, more of a say in the governance of the sport and more control of their intellectual property than what is in the 2025 charter agreement. But there could be other\/different changes that address the antitrust issues. Could NASCAR be required to sell the tracks, and if so, who would buy them, and how would that address the teams&#8217; issues? \u00a0Could NASCAR change clauses in the charter agreement that don&#8217;t necessarily deal with revenue awarded to the teams but which satisfy the legal issues and would then force the teams to potentially see if another major stock-car series could be developed? That is what gives this case the potential to have a major impact on the future of the sport.<\/p>\n<p class=\"ff-h fs-16 lh-1pt6 mg-b-15 article-content\" data-v-dd2a400b=\"\">Bob Pockrass covers NASCAR for FOX Sports. He has spent decades covering motorsports, including over 30 Daytona 500s, with stints at ESPN, Sporting News, NASCAR Scene magazine and The (Daytona Beach) News-Journal. Follow him on Twitter @<a href=\"https:\/\/twitter.com\/bobpockrass\" rel=\"nofollow noopener\" target=\"_blank\">bobpockrass<\/a>.<\/p>\n<p>\n        recommended\n      <\/p>\n<p> Arrow pointing to the leftArrow pointing to the right <\/p>\n<p>Item 1 of 2<\/p>\n<p>   <img loading=\"lazy\" decoding=\"async\" src=\"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-content\/uploads\/2025\/07\/NASCARCup.vresize.160.160.medium.0.png\" alt=\"NASCAR Cup Series\" class=\"team-logo\" width=\"80\" height=\"80\"\/> Get more from the NASCAR Cup Series Follow your favorites to get information about games, news and more     <script async src=\"https:\/\/platform.twitter.com\/widgets.js\" charset=\"utf-8\"><\/script><\/p>\n","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":"Bob Pockrass FOX Motorsports Insider In hopes of trying to increase the revenues and influence of NASCAR Cup&hellip;\n","protected":false},"author":2,"featured_media":4540,"comment_status":"","ping_status":"","sticky":false,"template":"","format":"standard","meta":{"footnotes":""},"categories":[446],"tags":[49,48,634,82],"class_list":["post-4539","post","type-post","status-publish","format-standard","has-post-thumbnail","category-nascar","tag-ca","tag-canada","tag-nascar","tag-sports"],"_links":{"self":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4539","targetHints":{"allow":["GET"]}}],"collection":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts"}],"about":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/types\/post"}],"author":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/users\/2"}],"replies":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/comments?post=4539"}],"version-history":[{"count":0,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/posts\/4539\/revisions"}],"wp:featuredmedia":[{"embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media\/4540"}],"wp:attachment":[{"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/media?parent=4539"}],"wp:term":[{"taxonomy":"category","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/categories?post=4539"},{"taxonomy":"post_tag","embeddable":true,"href":"https:\/\/www.newsbeep.com\/ca\/wp-json\/wp\/v2\/tags?post=4539"}],"curies":[{"name":"wp","href":"https:\/\/api.w.org\/{rel}","templated":true}]}}