Acting early could lock in today’s generous rules. But it could also mean missing out if future changes turn out to be more favourable

Uncertainty over future pension rules is growing, and savers are increasingly questioning how best to plan for retirement.

With speculation mounting about what changes Chancellor Rachel Reeves might introduce, concerns are rising that the current tax advantages for pension withdrawals may not last forever.

That has left many people weighing a crucial decision: whether to take their 25 per cent tax-free lump sum now or wait for more clarity from Reeves?

New FeatureIn ShortQuick Stories. Same trusted journalism.

Acting early could lock in today’s generous rules. But it could also mean missing out if future changes turn out to be more favourable.

To help you decide, we asked financial experts for the best – and worst – reasons to take your tax-free cash before 26 November.

How much of your pension can you take tax-free?

From age 55 – rising to 57 from April 2028 – you can normally withdraw up to 25 per cent of your pension savings tax-free. This can be taken as one or more lump sums, rather than regular income.

However, there is a cap on how much you can take overall. The current lump sum allowance (LSA) is £268,275, which applies across all your pensions combined, not to each one individually. In practice, you’ll only hit this limit if your total pension savings exceed £1,073,100.

Any withdrawals beyond your tax-free entitlement are treated as income and taxed at your marginal rate, which could be as high as 45 per cent.

The good reasons to take your tax-free lump sum now

1. Locking in today’s generous rules

For some savers, the case for acting before the Budget is strong. Tax expert Eamon Shahir said: “With political uncertainty looming, it’s tempting to grab your tax-free cash now as a defensive move.

“If you have an immediate plan of what you would do with that money, such as pay off your mortgages or give money to children, it can make sense.

“Also, the tax-free cash is in place now, but it is not a guarantee forever; HMRC can always make changes at their discretion.”

His view echoes a growing concern among those who fear the current allowances may be cut. For anyone with a clear goal, such as clearing debt or passing wealth to family, securing the lump sum now may bring peace of mind.

Acting while the rules remain favourable can allow you to put the money to productive or family-focused use straight away.

2. Planning ahead for inheritance tax

Rowan Morrow-McDade, tax director at Alexander & Co Chartered Accountants, says there are strategic inheritance tax (IHT) benefits to moving early.

If the cash remains in a pension and the individual dies after 6 April 2027, it could form part of the estate and be subject to IHT at up to 40 per cent.

Extracting the money and using it wisely can help shield it from such charges.

He said: “Cash taken from a pension can then be put into a business relief qualifying investment, which qualifies for 100 per cent IHT exemption after two years (subject to a £1m cap).

“This can lead to substantial IHT savings. Cash can also be gifted to sons and/or daughters, if not needed. This means that if the donor survives for seven years, the gift is exempt from IHT.”

He added that there is an element of “control” that is often overlooked. Once the cash is in your bank account, you have full control of it, and it cannot be affected by future changes in pension rules – a point that resonates with savers wary of shifting Government policy.

3. Bringing plans forward with minimal impact

For those who were already intending to draw on their pension soon, acting a little earlier may not make much difference.

It may be that you want to retire a bit earlier but are not yet eligible to claim the state pension, in which case, looking to access your pension funds earlier helps manage retirement plans.

Rachel Vahey, head of public policy at AJ Bell, said: “If someone is already planning on taking their tax-free cash out soon as part of a strategy to start spending or gifting their pension to reduce any future IHT bill for their family, then bringing this forward a few months may not significantly damage their pension savings.”

4. To maximise unused ISA allowances

If you have not used your ISA allowance, you might want to take some tax-free cash and put it in an ISA, says Marianna Hunt at Fidelity.

“That way, the money will still be able to grow tax-free and you have the added benefit that withdrawals from an ISA are not taxable. Between a couple, you could potentially shelter up to £40,000 a year tax-free in ISAs.”

You do not need to take the full 25 per cent tax-free lump sum. If you only need to take £40,000, you can do so.

The bad reasons to take your tax-free lump sum now

1. Acting out of fear, not strategy

Experts warn against making hasty decisions. Mr Shahir cautioned savers that it is easy to overreact to rumours about tax changes, saying it is easy to get caught up on taxes but “ultimately it could be a lot worse if the money is lost or wasted.”

He reminded that pensions remain highly efficient, offering valuable tax-free growth within the wrapper.

Before making any move, investors should stop to ask what the cash is really for. “For short-term saving, you don’t want to potentially hinder your long-term retirement savings,” he said.

2. Losing valuable tax-free growth

Money taken out of a pension loses its privileged tax-free growth. As Mr Morrow-McDade noted, “Cash outside a pension will not grow free from capital gains, dividend and income tax as it does in a pension.

“Taking 25 per cent of the pension out now might therefore severely reduce the total amount in the pension a few years down the line.”

Over time, this could significantly erode the overall value of your retirement pot.

He added: “If the individual passes away before 6 April 2027, they would have brought into their estate cash which would have otherwise been exempt from IHT.”

3. A cut may never come

Ms Vahey also argues that fears of an imminent cut may be overblown.
She said: “It’s very likely those who have already built up large amounts of tax-free cash will be protected from an immediate cut.”

Moreover, the political optics of such a move would be poor. She added: “Tax-free cash is the one part of pension saving most people understand and value.

“Cutting it would cause an outcry, especially amongst public sector workers. The last thing this Government needs is yet another U-turn.”

4. The value of patience

Finally, Ms Vahey stresses that patience can pay off, as leaving money invested means it can continue to grow tax-free.

If your pension is worth £400,000 today, your maximum tax-free cash will be £100,000, she explained.

Waiting until it hits half a million, which may only take a few years with a decent rate of contribution and strong market growth, would give you an extra £25,000 tax-free.

Although markets can be volatile, holding your nerve is often recommended. Seeking financial advice if you are not sure what to do can be a sensible route.