Analysis: Psychiatrists, psychologists and psychotherapists may work with similar problems but they do in vastly different ways
A 2023 episode of RTÉ Investigates highlighted inconsistencies in the regulation of mental health professionals in Ireland. Psychiatrists, psychologists and psychotherapists may work with similar problems but they do in different ways. This article aims to explain the differences and similarities between each, as well as highlight the grey areas that make accessing the right kind of support even more challenging for those in distress.
What is psychiatry?
Psychiatry is a branch of medicine concerned with the understanding, assessment, diagnosis and treatment of disorders of the mind. Psychiatrists are medical doctors who undertake specialist training in psychiatry having completed their degree and internship in medicine. They typically work in, or are attached to, hospitals and are concerned with the diagnosis and treatment of mental illness.
We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences
From RTÉ Radio 1’s Today show, Dr Emma Farrell explains the difference between psychiatry, psychology and psychotherapy
This treatment can include referral to a psychologist or psychotherapist or to another professional in a multi-disciplinary team such as an occupational therapist or social worker. Psychiatrists are distinct from psychologists and psychotherapists in that they can prescribe medication.
What is psychology?
Psychology is a scientific discipline concerned with the human mind and behaviour. Psychologists study people: how they think, how they act, react and interact. They can diagnose mental disorders using a diagnostic system such as the DSM or ICD and treat these disorders using a range of psychological approaches – many of which overlap with psychotherapy.
Psychologists are not usually medically qualified and only a small proportion of people studying psychology degrees will go on to work with people in distress. Psychologists can specialise in a number of areas, such as clinical, counselling, forensic, educational and occupational psychology.
From RTÉ Investigates, reporter Barry O’Kelly shows how easy it is to set yourself up as a psychologist in Ireland today
What is psychotherapy?
Sometimes referred to as talk therapy, psychotherapy is concerned with helping people identify and change troubling emotions, thoughts and behaviours. Psychologist and psychotherapist Dr Lucie Ehiwe is well positioned to describe the difference between psychology and psychotherapy.
“Psychology traditionally strives for an objective, scientific, generalisable perspective on human thought and behaviour whereby the correct intervention can be identified and implemented in response to a person’s specific “disorder” and distress. Psychotherapy provides a space for exploration of one’s self and experiences, often without the promise of a neatly packaged “cure” in the form of a pre-designed intervention or interpretation.”
Psychotherapists can draw on many different approaches, some of which will also be used by psychologists. These include:
Cognitive behavioural therapy
psychodynamic therapies
systemic and family psychotherapy
arts and play therapies
humanistic and integrative psychotherapies
We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences
From RTÉ Radio 1’s Brendan O’Connor Show, Clinical Psychologist Dr Tony Bates on cognitive behavioural therapy
Regardless of the selected approach, the therapeutic relationship, or the relationship between psychotherapist and client, is central to psychotherapy. A psychotherapist may be a psychiatrist or a psychologist who has had further specialist training or they may be specialists in psychotherapy alone.
The grey areas
Each professional will have their own strengths, approaches and preferences
While psychiatrists, psychologists and psychotherapists will all have completed initial training and accreditation in their disciplinary area, each professional will likely have their own approach, area of interest and advanced training which will result in diverse clinical encounters. A person in distress attending one clinical psychologist, for example, might experience a very different clinical encounter than if they had attended another.
Each psychiatrist, psychologist or psychotherapist will have their own perspectives and preferences. In a recent interview clinical psychologist Dr Cian Aherne described how he is drawn to the Power Threat Meaning Framework, which was developed as an alternative to more traditional diagnosis-based psychology.
We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences
From RTÉ Radio 1’s Morning Ireland, lack of regulation of psychology sector highlighted by investigation
Another clinical psychologist, with the same qualification and training, might instead prefer the traditional diagnostic approach particularly when working with those who need a diagnosis to access additional services. While each professional must adhere to the standards and ethical requirements of their professional body, they will also draw on their strengths, preferences to provide the best care possible.
Not every person will respond to the same approach
We each have our own preferences and ways of making sense of the world and our experiences within it. As a result, there is no ‘one size fits all’ when it comes to mental health treatment and support. For example, Marie* described working with her psychiatrist as “brilliant […] She’s tough on me but it’s what I need”. On the other hand, Adrianna* said that her psychiatrist “was just feeding me medication…I was like, ‘you’re not helping because you don’t care if I feel fine or not. You’re just upping my medication every time I see you'”.
Equally, Claire* described how psychotherapy “wasn’t proactive enough” for her while working with a psychologist was more helpful to her “I felt like it was a medical thing like a clinical thing that I need to sort out as opposed to just a situational [thing that] needed to be talked out”.
We can sometimes feel there must be something wrong with us if the therapy isn’t working, but often it’s just not the right therapy for us
How do I know which one is for me?
The mental health landscape can be difficult to navigate. If you are struggling with your mental health, it can be really helpful to have an ally who can journey alongside you in finding the best form of support for you. This may take some time, with lots of trial and error, but the most important thing is to find somebody you can build a good relationship with – be they a psychiatrist, psychologist or psychotherapist.
If the discipline or professional you are working with does not work for you, don’t worry. We can sometimes feel there must be something wrong with us if the therapy isn’t working, but often it’s just not the right therapy for us. Don’t be afraid to speak to your psychiatrist, psychologist or psychotherapist about the therapy itself and to try different approaches if that feels right to you.
*These accounts are taken from Making Sense of Mental Health: A Practical Approach Through Lived Experience. All participants names have been changed to protect their anonymity.
Follow RTÉ Brainstorm on WhatsApp and Instagram for more stories and updates
The views expressed here are those of the author and do not represent or reflect the views of RTÉ. If you have been affected by issues raised in this article, support information is available online