If Jimmy Fallon ever decides to record a pirate-themed album and is looking for someone to contribute guest vocals, one star has already passed the test.

How to Watch

Watch The Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallon on NBC weeknights at 11:35/10:35c and next day on Peacock.

Priyanka Chopra Jonas’ February 26 appearance on The Tonight Show featured a side-splitting version of karaoke that the audience loved. The two played a game called, suitably, “Arrrrr!!” — and immediately, Fallon’s description of the rules set the stage for an utterly hilarious and memorable segment.

“We’re gonna take turns being given a song, and we have to get the other person to guess the name of the song by singing it — and we can only say ‘Arrrrr!!'” he said, getting fully into pirate mode.

Sounds simple enough, right?

Well, tell that to Chopra Jonas. Fallon’s first song, sung to her in a pirate style, was “Golden” by the KPop Demon Hunters. And the look on Chopra Jonas’ face as she listened was pure confusion. It wasn’t until Fallon’s live audience started clapping along with a beat that Chopra Jonas figured out that she “knew this song” — even if she couldn’t correctly name it.

RELATED: Nick Jonas & Priyanka Chopra Share Romantic Video Walking on the Beach Hand-in-Hand

Chopra Jonas then sang an Arrrrr-some version of the Backstreet Boys’ classic “I Want It That Way” that had an enthusiastic Fallon joining in within seconds.

At that point, the two stars settled in to their groove, with pirate-ized versions of “All the Small Things” by Blink-182 and “Apt” by Rosé & Bruno Mars being easy tracks for the other to identify.

Chopra Jonas’ husband, Nick Jonas, would be proud!

RELATED: Nick Jonas Shared a Romantic Photo for His Wife Priyanka Chopra’s 41st B-Day

For the final challenge, Chopra Jonas and Fallon were tasked with singing a duet of their choice, with QuestLove recruited to guess the song. The duo chose “Who Let the Dogs Out?” by Baha Men, and QuestLove — with a parrot on his shoulder and all — came through with the correct answer. 

Priyanka Chopra Jonas reveals what her daughter calls the Jonas Brothers

Fans are always treated to memorable moments whenever Chopra Jonas stops by The Tonight Show. During her June 2025 visit, she revealed that their 3 1/2 year-old daughter, Malti, has the funniest name for the Jonas Brothers.

“She doesn’t identify them, but she calls them the Donut Brothers,” Chopra Jonas explained. “Isn’t it amazing? We should merch that. Let’s make that into the new Labubu.”

She went one step further, doing a great impression of little Malti saying “The Donut Brudders” — and you know what? The Jonas Brothers may have to trademark that adorable nickname at some point.