There’s something very different about Married At First Sight (MAFS) this year. Sure, we’re used to the Dinner Party drama, explosive fights between couples, and Daddy John Aiken sternly lecturing everyone on the couch every Sunday. But this year, there’s an undeniable bitterness to the whole experiment.
The arguments are particularly nasty and vicious. The division between the cast feels uncomfortable. The girls piling on each other is nasty and awful to watch. As viewers, we’re missing huge chunks of storylines and context as to why people are turning on each other. If watching the show is starting to feel confusing and emotionally draining, you’re not alone.
The chaotic social experiment has become less about the genuine drama that comes when strangers are looking to find love, friendship and, yes, social media followers, and more like a very transparent audition reel to try to get famous, no matter the cost.
MAFS 2026 has become more like a transparent audition reel to try to get famous, no matter the cost. (Credit: Channel 9)
Why is this season of MAFS so hard to watch?
Reality TV has always been a fast track to viral fame, and each season of MAFS has had standout stars. From Jules Robinson and Cam Merchant’s love story in 2019, to Lucinda Light winning over our hearts with her endearing and kind nature in 2024, there’s no particular rhyme or rhythm to who gets the most famous: most of the time, it’s based on chance, if the audience thinks you’re authentic, and how you show up when the season ends.
In latter years, however, contestants have started to take things into their own hands. Last year, once-matched contestants Jacqui Burfoot and Ryan Donnelly used backup Instagram accounts to debunk the show’s narrative and talk to the media (and fight with each other). Fans also knew early on in the season that Jacqui and intruder groom Clint Rice ended up together, way before they officially announced their romance at the reunion.
Spoiled storylines are one thing, but the 2026 cast feels different once again. They’re not regular people stumbling into accidental fame and trying to correct the audience’s perception of them. They’re people who have watched the show, studied the format, memorised the archetypes, and arrived ready to perform.
I feel like Gia and her people set up this whole storyline just to get some more air time #MAFS #MAFSAU
— 𝐃𝐲𝐥𝐚𝐧 𝐌𝐚𝐭𝐭𝐡𝐞𝐰𝐬 (@DylanMatthews91) March 2, 2026
MAFS participants are going to greater lengths to try to create their own narratives
Josh Fox, host of the MAFS Funny podcast, has been following the shows for years, both as a pap and content creator. He recently uploaded a video that shows 2026 participants Gia Fleur and Scott McCristal setting up a staged photo shoot during filming, and they pretended not to engage with him in a bid to look like they were getting media attention.
Josh has been closely following the show for years, and basically confirmed what we were thinking: this year’s cast is so thirsty for fame or notoriety that some of them went in trying to manufacture their storylines.
“Every year, the show has to become more extreme to keep beating itself and maintain the ratings and shock factor that people expect from MAFS. A byproduct of that is the participants themselves now know they need to do more than anyone previously if they want to gain notoriety that they can leverage into post-show media careers,” he told PEDESTRIAN.TV.
“The problem with that, though, is that what we’re watching [this year] isn’t natural events unfolding. It’s completely manufactured moments and confusing storylines that they’ve all been secretly plotting on the side, thinking they can ‘cheat the system’ and create their own narratives. It’s just sad to see the lengths cast members are now going to with leaking fake stories to the press to take each other down.”
Josh says there’s one key character who came in with a masterplan, and there’s no prizes for guessing who.
“In all of my years covering the show, I haven’t witnessed anyone as calculated as Gia. She had a big master plan of how she thought she could play puppeteer with the producers, the fellow participants and the press to create this fictional narrative that she thought would make her the female hero,” he said.
“As we’re now seeing, unfolding in real time, it’s backfiring and blowing up in her face in ways I don’t think she ever expected.”
“In all of my years covering the show, I haven’t witnessed anyone as calculated as Gia.” (Credit: Channel 9)
How the MAFS 2026 cast tried to influence their narratives
If you’re keeping up with the exhausting media cycle of MAFS, you may know that Gia and Bec Zacharia — two of the most infamous feuding brides of this season — have been slinging mud at each other in interviews as the show continues to air.
Gia went as far as to claim that Bec came on the show with her own publicist to create a “feuding to friends” storyline with Gia, an allegation Bec has denied.
Another common theme interwoven through this season now is participants showing up with “receipts” to call each other out, revealing text messages from private group chats. Leaked texts show Gia, Bec and fellow bride Brook Crompton b*tching about Alissa Fay and David Momoh, with Bec labelling Alissa a “rat b*tch with a rat husband” and a c-bomb.
Juliette Fava became the one to try to air the receipts in Sunday night’s Commitment Ceremony, with Gia failing to back her up, before Juliette shared them with Alissa directly.
However, Josh alleges in one of his MAFS Funny episodes that he also has his own damn receipts, with Gia apparently texting him in August last year when she was doing the most to get the media on-side by leaking storylines that were being filmed.
“All Alissa’s followers are fake. She bought them, she’s not an influencer,” Gia allegedly told Josh. “She’s the most hated girl on the show, by the way. NO ONE likes her. Her relationship is as fake as her followers.”
Gia (right) reportedly called Alissa (left) “the most hated girl on the show”. (Credit: Channel 9)
Let’s remember the bottom line for MAFS success
The real magic of early reality TV was that nobody quite knew what they were doing yet. Participants made terrible decisions because they were genuinely overwhelmed, not because they were calculating how the edit might play online.
There’s a big difference between messy people accidentally becoming famous and people who are very clearly trying to become famous by being messy, which is why the current season feels so exhausting. Not because the drama is fake, but because the motivation behind it feels disingenuous.
Reality TV fans have spent years learning the language of shows like MAFS. We can spot a strategic villain arc and a choppy edit. We know when someone is angling for screen time. We can usually tell who’s authentic. And we definitely know when someone seems more committed to building their personal brand than their actual relationship.
“No matter how much you think you can cheat the system to come out on top, this show isn’t a game and the producers making it, the press covering it, and the audiences watching it see through most things,” Josh said. “Don’t be deluded into thinking you’ll be ‘the exception’ and come out on top. Trust me, you won’t.”
Obsessed with reality TV? Check out PEDESTRIAN.TV‘s new podcast Villain Edit, where we unpack all the wild, chaotic and messy moments from your favourite shows. Listen now on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube and wherever you get your podcasts.