MasterChef returned this week with a major shake-up, as Anna Haugh and Grace Dent stepped in to front the 2026 series of the hit BBC One competition. But while the latest batch of amateur chefs were eager to impress the new judges, the same warm reception wasn’t mirrored online.
The duo made their joint debut this Tuesday (21 April), taking over from long-standing judges John Torode and Gregg Wallace as six new contestants entered the BBC kitchen in the hopes of securing an apron – their first step in the competition. As ever, the opening challenge saw the amateurs present their signature dishes, offering an early glimpse into their skills under pressure.
On screen, the transition felt notably smooth. Anna and Grace struck an easy balance between encouragement and critique, creating a lighter, more relaxed atmosphere that allowed contestants to settle into the format. Their feedback is measured and clear, while the tone of the episode leaned into warmth without losing the tension that defines the show.
BBC
Related: Best streaming services
Yet, for some viewers, the change proved harder to accept. Social media focus quickly turned its focus towards the new line-up, with a number of fans expressing nostalgia for the previous era. “Nothing against Grace & Anna but bring back Greg & John, they can’t be replaced,” one of them shared.
Another wrote: “I miss John particularly and Gregg. They were #MasterChefUK.” And a third tweeted: “Miss Greg and John on Masterchef. It’s gone very flat. They don’t need to both be experts in food. We need some personality and wit.”
Some of the criticism even centred on minor details, with viewers scrutinizing the judges’ on-screen mannerisms, proving how quickly the attention shifted away from the food itself and onto the personalities delivering the critique. “Anna & Grace seem great but their face pulling is odd! When the contestants told them what they were cooking, they hardly spoke…just gurned!!!” one tweet read.
Photographer://BBC
At the same time, not all responses were negative. Other viewers welcomed the changes, praising the pair’s dynamic and fresh energy. “Loving the two ladies,Grace and Alice running the masterchef kitchen,” an X user wrote. “Great start to the new series. Anna and Grace make a good team . I’m sure their over-exuberance will calm down #masterchef,” commented another.
The divide in reaction is perhaps unsurprising. MasterChef has been anchored by familiar faces for years, and any significant shift in its presenting line-up was always likely to prompt comparison. But the nature of the criticism raises a broader question about how audiences respond to change.
Anna and Grace’s credentials are difficult to dispute. Grace is a respected restaurant critic and journalist, as well as the author of several books and her own memoir, Hungry: The Highly Anticipated Memoir from One of the Greatest Food Writers of All Time. She has long been included in the MasterChef universe, appearing as a guest judge across both Celebrity MasterChef and MasterChef: The Professionals, and she previously stepped in to replace Gregg Wallace in the show’s celebrity series.
Photographer://BBC
Related: Best LEGO sets
Meanwhile, Anna brings extensive professional kitchen experience. After training in Dublin, she worked in some of the industry’s most demanding environments, including alongside chefs such as Gordon Ramsay and Philip Howard. She’s since opened up her own restaurant, Myrtle, in Chelsea, and has become an increasingly familiar face on the small screen after appearing on programmes like Saturday Kitchen and Morning Live, as well as within the MasterChef franchise itself.
In other words, both judges arrive with established expertise and a clear understanding of the standards the competition demands. The refreshed line-up has subtly shifted the tone of the show, bringing a slightly softer, more contemporary feel without losing its core identity.
For some viewers, that shift in tone may take time to settle. But for others, the new line-up offers something the show hasn’t always managed – a fresh point of entry. Where MasterChef may once have felt familiar to the point of predictability, Anna and Grace’s arrivals bring a new sense of curiosity, making the competition more accessible and, crucially, more worth tuning in for.
MasterChef airs on BBC One and streams on BBC iPlayer.
Read more MasterChef news on our dedicated homepage
The new edition of Living Legends, a 100-page all-colour celebration of Sir David Attenborough, is here! Buy Sir David Attenborough in newsagents or online.