A 43-year old man has been sentenced to 12 years in jail with two years suspended for the manslaughter of his brother’s girlfriend, three days before her 32nd birthday in January, last year.

The Central Criminal Court was told that Joseph Butler, of the Belfry, Bridewell Lane, Mallow, Co Cork, stabbed Paula Canty with a kitchen knife and left her to die, after an argument between the two at her apartment in Mallow.

Ms Canty was a 31-year-old mother-of-two, a daughter and a sister. She was originally from Kinsale.

She spent the night of 2 January last year at her apartment in Mallow, drinking with her boyfriend, his brother and another woman.

A row broke out between Butler and Ms Canty.

Butler took a kitchen knife and stabbed her once in the chest, leaving her with a wound that was 11 and a half centimetres deep. Ms Canty collapsed and died.


Joseph Butler was sentenced to 12 years in jail

Butler, who is originally from Midleton, was initially charged with Ms Canty’s murder, insisting he was not guilty. Later, though, he pleaded guilty to her manslaughter.

The Central Criminal Court heard Butler had told gardaí he had stabbed Ms Canty by accident, that she was family, and that she was “grand” when he left the apartment, still carrying the kitchen knife, which he dumped in a nearby laneway.

He has more than 50 previous convictions, including three for assault, two for assault causing harm and one for possession of a knife.

His counsel, Ray Boland, said he had had many difficulties, including growing up in an environment of violence and addiction. He said he was genuinely remorseful.

At sentencing today, Ms Justice Eileen Creedon said Butler had displayed a callousness by leaving the apartment after stabbing Ms Canty and not calling the emergency services.

She dismissed the version of events he gave to gardaí in relation to the struggle and said some of his previous convictions displayed a history of violence.

She imposed a sentence of 12 years on Butler, suspending the final two years on condition that he be of good behaviour.

Ms Justice Creedon described Ms Canty as vulnerable and physically smaller than Butler who, she said, was a bigger, stronger man.

Ms Justice Creedon said the appropriate headline sentence was one of 14 years, but she reduced this to 12 years because of his background, his apology and because of his plea of guilty.

“The accused’s versions of events were inconsistent with the post-mortem and the blood spatter analysis by forensic scientists,” Ms Justice Creedon said. “The blood pooling indicates that the deceased bled heavily at that location.”

She said: “Paula Canty was a vulnerable person, and was much smaller and physically weaker that Joseph Butler. It is not credible that she posed a danger to him that required him to plunge a knife 11.5 centimetres into her chest. He left the apartment and there was no call to the emergency services. This demonstrates a callousness.”

The judge referred to the powerful victim impact evidence from Ms Canty’s family members. She said she could only imagine their grief and the hole left in their lives left by her absence.

‘My family will never recover from having Paula robbed from us’

Ms Canty’s family described in victim impact statements how her death had changed their lives forever.

Ms Canty’s mother Sinéad, said that her firstborn’s death has been “gut-wrenching”, and has affected her physically, mentally, and emotionally.

She described her daughter as having a soft and pleasant nature and a creative and artistic personality.

“Paula and I had a very close bond, and she was like a best friend to me. My heart breaks, but I will never receive just one phone call from her again,” her statement added.

Ms Canty’s younger brother Darragh said that her “brutal death” had shattered their lives forever.

“I never thought I would have to sit down and write a letter on how I feel about her being viciously snatched from us. I replay it in my mind constantly, and I struggle with anger, grief, anxiety, and disbelief that someone would take her life this violently.

“Paula had a future. She had dreams, plans, relationships, years of life ahead of her that were stolen.

“There will always be an empty seat at every Christmas, every birthday, every important moment for the rest of our lives.

“My family will never recover from having Paula robbed from us,” he said.

Ms Canty’s younger sister Rianna said she now mourns both the loss of a sibling and the moments they should have shared together.

She said: “One of the hardest things for me was going through my pregnancy and becoming a mother without my sister beside me.

“I needed her support, advice and comfort during one of the biggest moments of my life and knowing she was not there has caused me immense pain.

“And when my son was born it broke my heart knowing my sister would never get to meet him or be part of his life.

“She was not there to encourage me or celebrate important milestones or support me through difficult times.

“There have been so many moments where I wanted to call her to talk to her or share something with her only to remember she was no longer there,” she added.