On February 12, 1989, Belfast solicitor Pat Finucane, who was known for challenging the British government in human rights cases, sat down to dinner with his wife and three children. During the meal, three gunmen entered the family home and shot Finucane fourteen times. His wife, Geraldine, was wounded in the attack. Finucane was thirty-nine when he was killed by a pro-British loyalist paramilitary group.

The killing might have been another entry in the grim catalog of Troubles murders were it not for what happened afterward. One of his killers, Ken Barrett, was eventually convicted. Successive investigations uncovered extensive evidence of collusion between loyalist paramilitaries responsible for killings like this and British state agents.

In 2012, then–Prime Minister David Cameron apologized to the Finucane family for what he described as ‘shocking levels of state collusion.’

In 2012, then–Prime Minister David Cameron apologized to the Finucane family for what he described as “shocking levels of state collusion.” A review by Sir Desmond de Silva concluded that there had been a “wilful and abject failure” by successive governments to establish a proper legal framework for the handling of state agents.

In 2019, the UK Supreme Court ruled that previous investigations into Finucane’s murder had failed to meet the state’s obligations under Article 2 of the European Convention on Human Rights. The family had spent decades asking for an independent inquiry into the circumstances of his death. This year, they finally got one. The Patrick Finucane Inquiry held its preliminary hearing in Belfast on June 10.

In Westminster, this has opened up an argument over what should happen to the remaining open cases from the Troubles. The Northern Ireland Troubles Bill is supposed to replace the Conservative government’s deeply controversial 2023 Legacy Act.

The latter bill attempted to draw a line under the past by ending new inquests and civil actions. Many saw this as a way of giving immunity to British soldiers for crimes they committed during the conflict. The immunity provisions were condemned by victims’ organizations and Northern Ireland’s political parties, both nationalist and unionist.

The Labour government that took office in 2024 eventually scrapped the Legacy Act and introduced the new Troubles bill in its place. While it does contain some improvements, it is still seriously flawed.

Last month, the Westminster Joint Committee on Human Rights stated that the bill needs further changes if it is to secure public confidence and address the legacy of the conflict properly. It raised concerns about the independence of the proposed Legacy Commission, the handling of sensitive information, the role of families, and the legal framework surrounding investigations.