The family of a 60-year-old man who was murdered in a violent attack at his home in Donegal last year has said they believe his kind and caring nature led to his death.
Eddie Friel was killed by a man he had known for years in what was described as an unexplained and frenzied attack at his home at Harbour View Drive in Killybegs on 12 April 2025.
Today 59-year-old James Spendley of St Cummin’s Hill, Killybegs was jailed for life after he pleaded guilty to murder shortly before his trial date earlier this month.
The Central Criminal Court heard that Spendley, who had a history of bipolar affective disorder, had been acting erratically before the killing and that a family member had expressed concerns to Gardai and was trying to get advice from doctors about his medication.
Prosecuting Counsel James Dwyer SC told the court that a local man had observed Spendley on 12 April 2025 picking up cigarette butts at the pier in Killybegs and had spent some time drinking with him.
He had later attended the Garda station and was described as “ranting erratically” and asking for a piece of paper on which he wrote a prayer. The following day a neighbour of Eddie Friel noticed his door open and alerted his family who found him lying dead on his couch.
He had been severely injured and his home was extensively blood stained in a number of rooms. A baseball bat was found at the scene. A post mortem found Mr Friel had suffered multiple bruises, lacerations and 35 sharp injuries including three stab wounds. He died from blunt force trauma to the head and lower limbs.
James Spendley was identified as a suspect and was found asleep at his home later that morning with blood stained hands and a number of blood stained items in his home.
He admitted being in Mr Friel’s home but denied any wrongdoing. He was interviewed five times by Gardai but denied killing Mr Friel and suggested he was responsible for his own death as he “did not look after himself”.
Further evidence was uncovered including the deceased’s DNA on Spendley’s bloodied hands and CCTV showing him wearing a sweatshirt found at the murder scene. He was arrested a second time and in three further interviews he continued to deny killing Mr Friel. He later pleaded guilty shortly before a trial date in October this year.
In a victim impact statement Eddie Friel’s family said he was the second eldest of ten children who all lived beside each other. His siblings described him as a “character with a quirky sense of humour” adding that he was “kind hearted and caring and would give you the shirt off his back, His only fault was that he was too generous and did not like to say no. In some ways we wish he was not so kind as he would still be here with us.”
They described how there was an empty seat at the table during Christmas 2025 and that time was “not a healer”. One sister described how she can’t sleep at night as she “plays over what he went through when brutally murdered a few doors down the road” and how she could never get the image of his body out of her head.
“How anyone could be so brutal to another human being is beyond me,” she said.
The family said all they wanted was justice for their brother Eddie. They also thanked the people of Killybegs and the Gardai for their support.
The court was told Spendley had lived in Scotland until his teens and had moved to Donegal and sat his leaving cert here. He had studied at third-level and was a musician. He had a problem with alcohol and bipolar disorder.
Defence Counsel Desmond Dockery said his client’s sister had alerted GardaĆ that his behaviour had deteriorated and she had been in touch with his GP and Donegal Mental Health Services in an effort to get him into sheltered accommodation.
Det Sgt Grainne McClune agreed with Mr Dockery that James Spendley had never given any explanation for the killing but could not offer a view as to whether or not it was a frenzied attack as suggested by Mr Dockery.
Sgt McClune agreed that Spendley had been polite and cooperative in all his Garda interviews.
Mr Dockery said nothing he could say could undo the tragedy or restore the life lost. He said the case was “all the more tragic” because both men had known each other for many years.
He said he was not putting forward an explanation for what occurred and none had emerged from the investigation but the court had heard evidence of his client’s erratic behaviour. Mr Dockery said his client had instructed him to offer an apology for what happened and wanted to say he was “deeply sorry and may God be with them”.
Mr Justice Paul McDermott said it was clear this was a violent and prolonged attack and hearings of this kind were upsetting and distressing for those who had lost a loved one.
He said it was clear that Eddie Friel was a valued member of the community and the damage done was not only to him but to those who had to live with the loss of him. He imposed the mandatory term of life in prison.