Superman star Rachel Brosnahan is taking over the leading role in Apple TV+’s legal drama Presumed Innocent. The series, which debuted in 2024, is set to return for its second season in 2026.

Joining Brosnahan will be former Perry Mason star Matthew Rhys, who, per Variety, has been cast in a leading role in Presumed Innocent Season 2. The second season of the Apple TV+ series will focus on the book Dissection of a Murder by Jo Murray, which will be published next year.

While plot and character details are scarce for Presumed Innocent Season 2, a description of the book from publisher Pan Macmillan reads: “When Leila Reynolds (Brosnahan) is handed her first murder case, she’s shocked at how high-profile it is: the murder of a well-respected, well-known judge. This shouldn’t be the kind of case she’s leading; it’s way beyond her expertise. But the defendant, Jack Millman, is clear. He wants her, and only her.”

Rhys, in addition to starring in HBO’s Perry Mason for two seasons, also starred in FX’s Cold War drama The Americans, a role for which he won an Emmy in 2018. He is also set to star in Apple TV+’s upcoming series Widow’s Bay and opposite John Krasinski in Prime Video’s upcoming Silent River. In November, Rhys will be seen in Netflix’s The Beast In Me.

Presumed Innocent’s First Season Was a Hit for Apple TV+

Rusty is led out of court while Raymond stands next to him.

Will Raymond still betray Rusty in Presumed Innocent?
Image via Apple TV+

Presumed Innocent was developed for television by David E. Kelley, who serves as executive producer and co-showrunner under his David E. Kelley Productions banner. Erica Lipez is co-showrunner and executive producer on Season 2.

J.J. Abrams and Rachel Rusch Rich are executive producers under Bad Robot Productions, along with Matthew Tinker of David E. Kelley Productions. Presumed Innocent Season 1 star Jake Gyllenhaal is also executive producing via Nine Stories. Dustin Thomason and Brosnahan also executive produce. Scott Turow co-executive produces with Murray. Season 1 of the show was based on Turow’s book of the same name. The series is produced by Warner Bros. Television.

Presumed Innocent Season 1 launched in June 2024 and received critical and audience acclaim. The first season has a 79% Rotten Tomatoes critic score and a 77% audience score. Its first season garnered four Emmy nominations, including best lead actor in a limited or anthology series for Gyllenhaal and best supporting actor in a limited or anthology series for both Bill Camp and Peter Sarsgaard. Ruth Negga was also nominated for an Emmy for best supporting actress in a limited or anthology series.

Brosnahan was announced to be playing attorney Lelia Reynolds in Presumed Innocent Season 2 back in June 2025. She most recently starred in James Gunn’s Superman and earned an Emmy nomination for her role in Netflix’s House of Cards.

Presumed Innocent Season 1 is streaming on Apple TV+. Season 2 is set to premiere in September 2026.

presumed-innocent-key-art.jpeg


Presumed Innocent

Release Date

2024 – 2023

Directors

Greg Yaitanes, Anne Sewitsky

Writers

David E. Kelley

appletvplus_logo-1-1.jpg