
The case originated in 2022 when An Taisce initiated a judicial review of Ireland’s Fifth NAP, alleging the government built a “flawed system” of policy that prioritises intensive farming over the legal requirement to protect water and soil.
The European Court of Justice (CJEU) has been formally advised that Ireland may only legally approve increased nitrogen limits for farms after scientifically determining that water quality objectives will not be prejudiced.
Advocate General (AG) Juliane Kokott, a legal advisor whose role is to provide the Court with an independent and impartial analysis of the law, delivered her formal opinion today regarding the ongoing challenge to Ireland’s nitrates policy.