Researchers have found that children’s selective attention predicts how well they understand texts over time, while some forms of school-related screen reading are linked to weaker comprehension.
The finding reframes concerns about reading habits by showing that focus, not format alone, shapes how effectively children make sense of written material.
Across classrooms tracking students over a full school year, reading ability rose and fell alongside measurable differences in how well children sustained attention to relevant information.
By following the same students, Ladislao Salmerón at the University of Valencia (UV) documented how stronger attention skills aligned with better comprehension outcomes in later assessments.
That pattern held even as reading habits themselves showed limited long-term influence on attention development across the same period.
The result sets a clear boundary: improving comprehension depends less on medium alone and more on how well students can maintain focus while reading.
Focus showed limits
For these readers, selective attention, the skill of choosing useful information while ignoring distractions, gave children a clearer path through demanding text.
Children with stronger attention scores understood more on paper tests, because they could hold main ideas while filtering side details.
Yet print and digital habits from the earlier year did not explain attention gains one year later in the data.
That finding weakens the simple claim that screens alone stole focus from this age group.
Screens had timing
The sharper warning came from fourth graders who used screens for school reading outside class during homework and study.
Their academic digital reading predicted lower comprehension in fifth grade even after researchers accounted for earlier ability.
Older students moving from fifth to sixth grade did not show the same pattern after the same checks.
Age may matter because children are still learning how to use digital text for study without support.
Paper still matters
The paper did not prove its power in this one-year test, but older evidence still gives it weight for schoolwork.
A large meta-analysis involving 171,055 participants found paper reading produced better comprehension than screen reading.
That advantage was strongest for informational texts and time-limited reading, both common in school assignments.
For students, paper may help most when they slow down and connect ideas without other digital nudges nearby.
Old habits fade
Leisure print reading was not frequent in the Spanish classrooms, averaging only once or twice a month at the first measurement.
That matters because print exposure, regular contact with books and print, has long tracked vocabulary and comprehension growth across 99 studies.
One year may also be too short to show how steady book reading changes skill in children this age.
For families, the practical point is regular reading time at home, not a single perfect format choice.
Reading needs control
Comprehension depends on more than recognizing words, because readers must decide which ideas deserve attention through a long passage.
A review of 96 findings involving 6,673 participants found a moderate link between mental control skills and reading comprehension.
During reading, executive functions, mental control skills that manage attention and choices, help readers suppress stray details.
Those skills do not replace reading practice, but they help practice turn into durable understanding.
Digital reading differs
Digital reading can mean a textbook page, a search result, a message, or several tabs competing.
That variety makes screen effects harder to measure than simple time spent with a device across classrooms.
In Salmerón’s study, academic screen use mattered more than leisure screen reading for younger children.
Schools therefore need clearer rules for digital work, especially when students are just beginning independent study.
Classrooms need care
Teachers face a harder choice in primary grades than banning screens or handing every child a classroom tablet.
In a 2024 interview, Salmerón argued that paper still gave readers a stronger route into meaning.
“It has been shown that reading on paper increases reading comprehension, oral expression, and the learning of new vocabulary,” said Salmerón.
The newer results narrow that claim, pointing to timing, task design, and children’s readiness for screens.
Children reading printed books
At home, the strongest reading habit may be the one a child can repeat daily without a fight.
Printed books remove notifications by design, which helps children stay with a page longer than apps.
Shared reading also gives adults a chance to ask children what changed in a story in their own words.
Device reading can work better when adults set a purpose before the screen turns on and close other apps afterward.
Salmerón’s study leaves parents and schools with a tighter message: reading tools work only when attention and guidance come first.
Print books remain a smart default for sustained reading, while digital assignments need timing, guidance, and clear reasons.
The study is published in The Journal of Research in Reading.
—–
Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.
Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.
—–