A new study has found that a small predatory fossil fish from Scotland’s old coal waste, can now be reconstructed in new skull detail.

The finding gives a Victorian-era species named Megalichthys pygmaeus a firmer shape, while keeping one stubborn family puzzle from Scotland’s coalfields unresolved.

Finding Megalichthys pygmaeus

EarthSnap

Across five coal waste tips in Lanarkshire, a Scottish mining region, scattered skull bones now fit into a more coherent head.

By comparing those pieces, Francis M. Elliott at Scottish Universities Environmental Research Centre (SUERC), a Scottish research center, tied the fragments to one fish.

The pattern clarifies material that had long rested on isolated jaws, scales, and plates from old mining collections.

That reconstruction gives the species a stronger identity, but it still leaves open whether the fish was separate or a juvenile form of a larger relative called Megalichthys hibberti.

A name gets rebuilt

Since the 1800s, the name had rested on scattered jaws, scales, and plates from the Carboniferous Period, the coal-forming age more than 315 million years ago.

Elliott designated a neotype, a replacement reference specimen, from a matching Scottish coal layer because the original specimens were lost.

The chosen lower jaw measured about 0.35 inches, small enough to keep the species question alive.

That replacement specimen gave later comparisons a fixed specimen, rather than another loose label from old mining collections.

Skull clues matter

Under the rebuilt roof, the fish’s outer skull showed surface bones that were small but sharply patterned.

These dermal bones, hard pieces forming the skull surface, carried tiny pits and grooves that marked sensory pathways.

A coating called cosmine, hard enamel-like tissue, often covered sutures, so missing seams did not mean missing structure.

Those details let Elliott compare skull shape, not just bone size, with close fossil relatives that may have shared ancestors.

A nursery in shale

Most useful material came from thin shale near Wester Bracco and Dewshill, two coal sites in North Lanarkshire, Scotland.

There, a fossil-rich strip only about 1.6 inches thick preserved abundant fish bones in fine layers.

A 0.6-inch band of hard, shiny coal that marked the right layer helped collectors find the richest fossils.

Such shallow deposits support the idea that young or small fish gathered where deeper-water predators were less common than in open channels.

Small jaws, big debate

Four lower jaws traced a size range from about 0.35 inches to 1.7 inches in length.

As jaw size increased, the outline became straighter and more like Megalichthys hibberti, the larger related fish.

That pattern supports a juvenile link, yet one small jaw could simply belong to a tiny Megalichthys hibberti.

Size alone cannot settle the case because growth stages from the same deposits rarely fossilize in tidy, complete sequences.

Scottish fossil fish Megalichthys pygmaeus. Palatoquadrate complex. Credit: Lyell CollectionScottish fossil fish Megalichthys pygmaeus. Palatoquadrate complex. Credit: Lyell Collection. Click image to enlarge.Breathing hints remain

One cheek bone fitted near a small opening behind the jaw, giving the skull another evolutionary clue.

That opening, the spiracle, a passage tied to breathing and hearing history, has a complex record in early vertebrates.

In some fish near the land-vertebrate line, similar openings likely helped move air into the throat. Here, the Scottish fossil only hints at that function because soft tissues did not survive with the bone.

A family problem

The skull also tested whether the fish belongs inside Megalichthyidae, a family of extinct fishes close to the land-vertebrate line.

Older work treated that family as real, but the exact rules for membership have stayed difficult because many traits change as animals grow.

A later Pennsylvania fossil sharpened the issue by tightening which skull traits define Megalichthys, the naming group above species.

Against those rules, Megalichthys pygmaeus looks close to the family but not securely placed in that naming group.

Museum pieces help

SUERC’s comparison worked because Elliott matched new fragments against Megalichthys hibberti bones held in the Hunterian Museum, a Glasgow university museum in Scotland.

Lower jaws, shields, cheek bones, and shoulder bones each added one part of the missing head plan.

Some pieces appeared often, while upper-jaw and cheek bones remained rare and left gaps in the reconstruction.

That uneven record made the new head useful, but still partly tentative around the cheek and upper jaw.

What remains uncertain

Even with the reconstruction, the fish still sits near a phylogenetic boundary, a family-tree line that species naming cannot easily draw.

Shared skull features connect it to Megalichthys hibberti, but shared features can mark family kinship rather than youth.

“Until now, no other cranial material has been assigned to Megalichthys pygmaeus and, consequently, the phylogenetic position of the taxon has remained uncertain,” Elliott wrote.

That uncertainty means the safest name remains Megalichthys pygmaeus until stronger growth evidence appears from connected fossils.

Why it matters

Rebuilt from waste-tip fragments, the fish now gives scientists a clearer small predator from Scotland’s coal-forming wetlands that once held shallow water.

Future finds must connect age, growth, and skull shape before the juvenile-species question can be closed.

The study is published in the Scottish Journal of Geology.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–