Analysis: A scathing or glowing review from a restaurant critic still has influence, even if the internet means everyone can now be a critic

Food critic and restaurant reviewer of the Irish Times Corinna Hardgrave recently died. One of her final reviews made frontpage news as it questioned the provenance of ingredients served in a restaurant co-owned by the chairman of Bord Bia.

The title of the review “I’m in Shock – €35 for chicken supreme using non-free-range Dutch chicken” seemed scathing—which may have been down to the copy editor—yet a close reading of the review of Sole Seafood & Grill restaurant was quite balanced. It praised several elements of the meal experience (‘sweet and creamy oysters’, ‘succulent brown crab’, ‘deliciously moist beer-battered cod’) while questioning the geographical origin of various other ingredients. Do most readers look past the headline?

We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences

From RTÉ Radio 1’s Morning Ireland in 2025, the late Corinna Hardgrave discusses three new Irish restaurants who have received Michelin stars

Another recent review in All the Food about Sano Pasta on Millenium Walkway led to the restaurant dropping its surcharge on adding parmesan to their dishes. A previous review on the same website contributed to the closure of Entrecôte after only three weeks trading. So, what power do food critics wield? Can they make or break a restaurant? Can they be sued?

For many years I taught a theory of food and beverage module in TU Dublin, Cathal Brugha Street. I had a dream relationship with our close neighbour—Chapter One Restaurant—who for a reduced fixed price would welcome our students for lunch, a glass of wine, a tour of the kitchen and a demonstration of how to make their classic Irish coffee on the gueridon trolley. The students would have to write a review, which accounted for 30% of the module’s assessment marks.

The week before, I would discuss the factors they should consider in their reviews, ranging from the welcome, the food offering, the temperature, aroma, flavour of the food, to the choice of beverages, the décor, music, ambience and facilities. I’d discuss the procedural side and the convivial side of service. “Don’t forget the importance of the goodbye,” I would remind them, as this is the last chance a restaurant has to check in with their customers and to fix any problems that may have arisen.

We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences

From RTÉ 2fm’s Jennifer Zamparelli Show in 2020, Stephen Gibbons gives a rundown of some of the worst restaurant reviews of all time

I would end my lecture by showing them a video of the world’s most famous food critic. The familiar soundtrack as the clip began always surprised them. The Simpsons’ episode Guess Who’s Coming to Criticize Dinner first aired on the Fox Network in America in October 1999. Homer becomes the food critic for The Springfield Shopper and initially gives everything stellar “five thumbs up” reviews, leading to obesity in Springfield—even Mr Burns has put on weight. His fellow critics tell him that he needs to be more critical, leading to a series of negative reviews that result in the local restaurateurs hiring a hitman to kill him using a giant poisoned éclair.

Naturally, Homer’s daughter Lisa saves the day by telling her dad that the éclair is ‘low-fat’ causing him to discard the deadly dessert. Marge Simpson concludes the episode by noting that only Homer could take a job as a local food critic and end up the target of an international assassin. Does a restaurant review really matter that much? What power do Irish food critics wield? Did the Restaurants Association of Ireland ever think of hiring a hitman?

From The Simpsons, clip from Guess Who’s Coming to Criticize Dinner

Restaurant reviews only became a regular feature in Irish newspapers during the 1980s. It was during the years of the Celtic Tiger (1994–2007) that dining out moved from being a special occasion to a regular pastime. A Master’s thesis in TU Dublin by Claire O’Mahony explored the history of Irish restaurant criticism from 1988 to 2008 and a subsequent journal publication by O’Mahony and TU Dublin lecturer Diarmuid Cawley highlighted the Dublin-centric middle-class nature of dining reflected in critics’ reviews in three national newspapers.

In 1997, award-winning chef and critic Paolo Tullio recalled how the gastronomic landscape in Ireland had transformed from his first experiences in the 1960s. “When I first started eating in Dublin restaurants in the late sixties, menus had a uniformity: you could always find prawn cocktail, steak Diane and crêpes Suzette. All wine lists contained Barsac and Graves and not much else. Good restaurants like Jammet’s tried for a French feel, others simply offered steak and chips. How times change!”

Tullio had run Armstrong’s Barn in Wicklow, and won a Michelin star in 1978, which gave his criticism some credibility among chefs and restaurateurs. Countless other critics have never worked in hospitality, leading to questions in relation to what credentials a critic should possess. A forthcoming PhD by Diarmuid Cawley on the history of wine criticism in Ireland stops at 2008, since, with the rise of the internet, everyone then seemed to be a food and wine critic. Cawley also notes that journalists could sometimes be better wine writers than actual wine experts, as they knew whom to consult and had the ability to clearly communicate the key message to a general audience.

We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences

From RTÉ Radio 1’s Countrywide in 2015, Tom Doorley remembers chef and food critic Paolo Tullio

In 2007, the owner of the Goodfellas restaurant in Belfast city successfully claimed that criticisms by a respected food writer published in the Irish News were defamatory and damaging to his business and won £25,000 in damages. In a newspaper report on the case, Myrtle Allen noted the subjective nature of restaurant reviewing and veteran reviewer Helen Lucy Burke outlined that she didn’t believe restaurants suffered long-term damage from a negative review. The libel award was overturned on appeal in 2008.

For nearly two decades, Burke was the most famous – and feared – critic in Ireland. She began writing for the Sunday Tribune and her acerbic, uncompromising and satirical style during the 1980s made her column ‘box office’; it was the first part of the paper I would open every week to discover who she was skewering or praising. This critic’s pen could potentially make or break a restaurant. The late Colin O’Daly informed me in an oral history interview that a positive review by Burke in the Sunday Tribune resulted in his newly opened The Park Restaurant in Blackrock being booked out six weeks in advance.

A scathing review by Burke of Tá sé Mahogony Gaspipes restaurant in Stoneybatter could have been extremely damaging, but the owners Roy and Drina Kinsley managed to turn the negative publicity in a Sunday paper into positive publicity on Monday and Tuesday. They released supportive messages from loyal customers left on their phone’s answering machine to the media and did a round of the radio talk shows discussing the issue. As any good PR guru notes, all publicity is potentially good publicity and today’s news wraps tomorrow’s fish.

We need your consent to load this rte-player contentWe use rte-player to manage extra content that can set cookies on your device and collect data about your activity. Please review their details and accept them to load the content.Manage Preferences

From RTÉ Radio 1’s Drivetime, food and travel writer Dee Laffan on how penny-pinching restaurants manage

Two of Corinna Hardgrave’s most glowing reviews in the last year were of Chapter One Restaurant and also the newly opened Ómós restaurant in Laois, run by one of my former students, Cuán Greene. I must see if I can dig out Cuán’s review of the Chapter One from his student days!

For an undergraduate thesis on restaurant criticism in Ireland in 2003, Trish Berry interviewed several of the leading critics of the day, including Burke, who claimed that the Restaurants Association of Ireland had offered significant cash incentives to her editor to remove her from her role. Thankfully, that did not happen. It is also worth noting that, to date, no Irish food critic has been the target of a hitman.

Follow RTÉ Brainstorm on WhatsApp and Instagram for more stories and updates

The views expressed here are those of the author and do not represent or reflect the views of RTÉ