Athletes who enjoyed their sport reported fewer signs of depression than those who felt they had to continue.
Elite athletes spend years pushing their bodies to the limit, but the pressures they face can extend far beyond training and competition.
From the stands or on a TV screen, a young athlete on the way to the top can look like someone living the dream.
Yet most of the elite athletes in a new Australian study were also holding down a job outside their sport, and many were studying too.
Athletes who played because they enjoyed it reported fewer signs of depression. Those who felt they had to keep playing reported more. How many hours they trained was not linked to these signs.
The pressures athletes face beyond sport
Jamie Wilson, an occupational therapist and PhD candidate at Flinders University’s Caring Futures Institute, led the study. Two of Wilson’s co-authors are based at Adelaide University.
“The elite pathway of a young athlete is packed with soaring highs and brutal lows, but the real secret to sustainable success could lie in the life they build outside of sport,” Wilson said.
In 2023, the International Olympic Committee called young elite athletes a “neglected population” and asked for more research on their well-being.
This study was small. Thirty-nine athletes answered an online survey, and eight took part in longer interviews. The results show patterns, not proof of cause and effect.
Balancing sport with everyday life
Occupational therapists help people manage the everyday activities that fill their lives, from work and school to sleep.
When one activity takes up so much of a person’s week that the arrangement can’t last, they call it occupational imbalance. Earlier research has linked it to poorer health.
Wilson’s team looked at that balance in young people becoming elite athletes.
Most of the athletes they surveyed were 17 to 24, the ages when athletes usually move into elite sport. All competed at state level or higher, in sports ranging from rugby and swimming to judo and archery.
The athletes trained about 13 hours a week on average, and the busiest put in 45. Thirty-three of the 39 also had a job. Twenty-four were studying, mostly at university.
For most of them, sport was one demand among several. Unpaid athletes in the interviews often used their off-season to pick up extra shifts at work.
Enjoyment was linked to less depression
The survey measured two kinds of commitment: how much each athlete wanted to stay in their sport, and how much they felt they had to.
It also measured grit, a mix of passion and persistence, along with symptoms of depression and anxiety in the past week.
Athletes who wanted to stay tended to have more grit and fewer signs of depression.
Athletes who felt obliged to stay tended to report more depression. Both links with depression were stronger among the athletes aged 24 and under.
Playing for personal enjoyment
Ivanka Prichard, a Flinders professor and co-author, emphasized the importance of enjoying sports.
She explained that young athletes who play for personal enjoyment rather than external pressure tend to be more persistent and psychologically healthier.
Their commitment and enthusiasm may help support their mental well-being.
Because each athlete filled in the survey once, the study can’t tell whether loving a sport protects against depression or whether depression makes a sport harder to love.
Women reported more anxiety than men
Women scored about twice as high as men on anxiety. Athletes in individual sports, such as swimming and judo, scored nearly twice as high as athletes in team sports.
Whether someone competed at state, national or international level made no measurable difference.
In interviews, women said it was harder to count as elite in sports that pay women little, so some held jobs on the side.
The authors suggest that solo athletes may get less social support than team players. None of the interviewees played an individual sport, so that idea is still untested.
Some athletes felt treated like commodities
Of the eight interviewees, seven played rugby and one sailed. Every one of them had moved away from home to compete at the top level.
One experienced rugby player, 34 when interviewed, said he hadn’t lived in the same city as his family since he was 18.
He noted that living away from his family had made it harder to maintain close relationships with them.
The same player said athletes are “pieces of meat at the end of the day, but you know the quality of those pieces of meat obviously affect how things go.”
Elite programs gave athletes access to nutritionists, medical care and psychologists.
However, some athletes worried that poor results could put that support at risk.
A young sailor said her scholarship relied on top results, but without a sailing partner, she wasn’t racing internationally to earn them.
Asking for help felt risky
Several athletes said people outside sport assumed they were living the dream, and that could make it hard to find support there.
“They’re just humans as well, and we just expect them to be superhuman because maybe their physical performance is in a way superhuman to what the average person knows, but that doesn’t mean that they’re immune to all the other strains of life,” said a young rugby player.
Inside their teams, some worried that asking for help would look like weakness.
One young player feared that if she sought extra help, “my spot on the team might be compromised because you know, they might not think that I’m psychologically ready.”
Why this matters beyond elite sport
The authors argue that the habits young people form while becoming elite may shape how they cope with later changes in their careers.
Earlier research they cite found that barriers to seeking help show up in community sport too, not only at the elite level. A recent paper had already called early action critical for young athletes’ mental health.
“Supporting young athletes beyond sport is not a distraction from victory, it is the vital foundation for developing healthier, stronger and more resilient athletes,” Prichard said.
The study can’t yet say whether an unbalanced life harms mental health, or whether struggling athletes find balance harder to keep.
Answering that will take studies that follow the same young athletes for several years, including solo athletes and teenagers under 17.
The full study was published in the journal Scandinavian Journal of Occupational Therapy.
—–
Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.
Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.
—–