Believe it or not, the Marvel Cinematic Universe has been going for nearly 20 years now. For those who were around then, it’s not at all hard to remember buying a ticket for Iron Man that opening weekend and realizing it was something special. But, as with any big franchise running for multiple decades, some members of the expansive cast list get swapped out somewhere down the line. Sometimes it’s because they’re not a team player, other times they get too busy, and then there is, sadly, the passing of some cast members. Those are the situations we’re looking at today, the passing of the character from one pair of hands to another, and not always by the first pair of hands’ choice. However, they had to start out in an MCU movie, so nothing like how Kelly Hu’s Lady Deathstrike and various other Fox era X-Men characters who were recast for Deadpool & Wolverine (the same goes for you, Chris Evans’ Human Torch).
Furthermore, an actor being replaced for Marvel Zombies didn’t count. We’re talking about stars who, for whatever reason, went from inhabiting the role in live action to another actor inhabiting that same role in live action. Just because a voice actor stepped in for Marvel Zombies or What If…? doesn’t mean that role has been well and truly recast. Lastly, if aging is a factor, that’s not a recast. For instance, Abby Ryder Fortson played Cassie Lang in Ant-Man and Ant-Man and the Wasp. Her being replaced by Emma Fuhrmann for a five-years-older Cassie in Avengers: Endgame didn’t count. Fuhrmann’s replacement, however….
11) Cassie Lang
image courtesy of walt disney studios motion pictures
Emma Fuhrmann taking over the role of Cassie Lang in Avengers: Endgame makes total sense. After all, she was supposed to be 16 years old, five years older than she was when Abby Ryder Fortson played her the previous year in Ant-Man and the Wasp. Even still, when Ant-Man and the Wasp: Quantumania came along a few years later, Fuhrmann was swapped out for bigger name Kathryn Newton, who had been in Freaky, Blockers, and Pokémon Detective Pikachu.
10) Reed Richards
image courtesy of walt disney studios motion pictures
Maybe a bit of a cheat entry, because this was more of a fan service casting than a genuine establishment of the MCU’s Reed Richards. No, for years many folks online imagined The Office‘s John Krasinski as Ms. Fantastic and Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness obliged them, and it worked. Never mind why Patrick Stewart looks like his Earth-10005 counterpart and Hayley Atwell, Lashana Lynch, and Anson Mount look like their Earth-616 counterparts while Krasinski does not.
9) Mainframe
image courtesy of walt disney studios motion pictures
Mainframe is a little talking robot head (without a body) that finds herself one of Stakar Ogord’s (Sylvester Stallone) Ravager gang. And, if her voice in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 sounded familiar while she was speaking her few lines, that’s because she was voiced by mega star Miley Cyrus. For Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3, however, she was replaced by Tara Strong, who also lent her voice to Loki as Miss Minutes. The reason Cyrus was recast simply came down to her lack of availability.
8) Howard Stark
image courtesy of walt disney studios motion pictures
The first time we see Howard Stark is in a black and white image during the opening of Iron Man, where he’s played by Gerard Sanders. Then, in Captain America: The First Avenger, he was aged down and played by Dominic Cooper. Thusly we’re counting the character’s main portrayer, John Slattery, as a replacement of Sanders, not Cooper.
7) Hulk
Image courtesy of Marvel Studios
Edward Norton’s Bruce Banner feels so different from Mark Ruffalo’s that they barely play as the same character. But they are indeed, and the reason why Norton was relegated to just The Incredible Hulk was because of that team player factor mentioned in the intro. Marvel Studios President Kevin Feige sought an actor who worked well as a part of a team (implying Norton wasn’t that, without outright attacking him). On Norton’s side of things, he stated he didn’t want to play the same character for too long, preferring instead to bounce from role to role.
6) Fandral
image courtesy of walt disney studios motion pictures
When casting was underway for the original Thor film, Zachary Levi was considered for the role of Fandral, but had to withdraw due to commitments on his show Chuck. Josh Dallas took over the role at that point, but history more or less repeated itself when it came time to make Thor: The Dark World, though this time it was Dallas backing out because of a too-packed schedule, as he was committed to Once Upon a Time. At that point Levi stepped in and played the role in both The Dark World and briefly in Thor: Ragnarok.
5) Wiccan
image courtesy of disney+
Technically this is an example of an age-related recasting, but it’s a bit more complicated. We saw Julian Hillard play Billy Maximoff in WandaVision and Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, but then Joe Locke took over the character in Agatha All Along.
This thing is, the Billy of Agatha is only two years older than the Billy of Multiverse, so if anything, Hillard would have made more sense. But then Agatha dropped the bomb that the “new” Billy is really the corpse of a young man who died in a car crash. His body was taken over by the soul of the Billy who was unmade alongside Westview at the end of WandaVision.
4) Red Skull
image courtesy of walt disney studios motion pictures
Hugo Weaving was a note-perfect choice for Red Skull in Captain America: The First Avenger, but by the end of the movie it seemed as though he wouldn’t ever be seen again. However, we ended up seeing him again on Vormir in Avengers: Endgame. And, while his face mostly looks the same and the voice isn’t far off, it’s not Weaving but rather Ross Marquand. Weaving said no due to the relatively low financial offer and a lack of overwhelming affinity for the character and the makeup process required to play him.
3) Thanos
image courtesy of walt disney studios motion pictures
The first time we see Thanos’ face in the MCU it’s not Josh Brolin’s, but rather Damion Poitier’s. Poitier was never intended to be the permanent Thanos. He’s the biggest villain of the universe, it’s only natural that the part would end up going to a bigger name in the business. Thus, you have Brolin taking over the role in Guardians of the Galaxy.
2) Thaddeus Ross
image courtesy of walt disney studios motion pictures
For a while it sure did seem like the late William Hurt’s General Thaddeus Ross was going to be a one-and-done, just like many other elements of The Incredible Hulk. But, as time and projects like She-Hulk: Attorney at Law and Captain America: Brave New World have shown, the MCU has embraced that film with open arms. At least, in hindsight.
The first sign that was happening, though, was with the return of Hurt as Ross. It was a bit of a surprise to see him in Captain America: Civil War, eight years after his first and then most recent appearance. Hurt continued to play the role in Avengers: Infinity War, Avengers: Endgame, and Black Widow. However, he then passed in March of 2022, so he could not play the role in the movie where Ross is actually the villain, the aforementioned Brave New World. Harrison Ford stepped in for what is likely a genuine one-and-done appearance.
1) War Machine
image courtesy of walt disney studios motion pictures
Given how Terrence Howard’s James Rhodes basically looks right into the camera and says, “I’ll suit up next time,” it’s clear that the intention was to have him join the fight. And he did end up joining the fight against Whiplash and his army of drones in the third act of Iron Man 2, but it was Don Cheadle wearing the suit.
When the first Iron Man was made, Howard’s clout in the industry was rising. And, given how Robert Downey Jr. was seen as a liability at the time, Howard was the highest paid actor of the film. Usually, when it’s time to come back for a sequel, a returning actor’s pay is raised. However, it was clear immediately that Downey Jr. was the number one draw for this franchise, so his pay skyrocketed while Howard’s pay not only didn’t go up but was actually going to go down. Don Cheadle came in and has remained a steady presence ever since 2010. Most would say it was an improvement of a recast.