Nitsan Darshan-Leitner, founder of Shurat HaDin: “Whereas the state cannot bring a civil lawsuit, they can bring a criminal indictment. There was pure libel against Israel, and it should be discussed in court.”
The Israeli government is unlikely to win a defamation lawsuit against The New York Times, but that does not mean there is nothing Israel can do in response to the malicious column published earlier this month by journalist Nicholas Kristof, which accused Israeli forces of sexually abusing Palestinian detainees.
The Foreign Ministry quickly accused the paper of publishing unverified claims, and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar instructed their legal teams to initiate a defamation lawsuit against the Times.
The lawsuit’s critics are missing the actual legal architecture that could put The New York Times in a tough position
However, according to Mark Goldfeder, CEO of the National Jewish Advocacy Center and a law professor at Touro Law Center, “a standard defamation suit would fail,” but that does not mean “there is nothing here.” He said in a column for the National Review, “the lawsuit’s critics are missing the actual legal architecture that could put The New York Times in a tough position.”
According to Goldfeder, a defamation lawsuit is a civil claim over a false statement of fact that harms a person’s reputation. In written form, it is usually called libel. Broadly speaking, a plaintiff must show that the defendant published a false factual statement “of and concerning” the plaintiff, that the statement injured the plaintiff’s reputation, and that the defendant acted with the required level of fault.
In ordinary cases, that can already be difficult. In cases involving public officials, public figures, governments, military conduct, war reporting, and matters of public concern, it becomes far more challenging.
“The central US rule comes from New York Times Co. v. Sullivan, which held that public officials cannot recover for defamatory falsehoods about official conduct unless they prove ‘actual malice,’ meaning knowledge of falsity or reckless disregard for truth,” Goldfeder told The Media Line. “In terms of a sovereign state suing, American law has long been hostile to government defamation suits because such suits resemble punishment for criticism of the state.”
American law has long been hostile to government defamation suits because such suits resemble punishment for criticism of the state
Nitsana Darshan-Leitner, founder of Shurat HaDin, added that the New York Times article was very careful not to mention anyone by name or even to allow the public to identify any of the alleged individuals, whether soldiers, prison guards, or settlers. As such, no individual can bring this lawsuit. At the same time, no group, such as the Israel Defense Forces or the Prison Authority, can bring a lawsuit either.
“In New York, there are very tough standards that do not allow sovereign entities or political entities to bring lawsuits,” Darshan-Leitner told The Media Line. “It will be very hard to prove malicious intent.”
It will be very hard to prove malicious intent
Still, Goldfeder said it is possible that someone could step forward claiming harm caused by the article. In that case, legal action could potentially be taken in Israel. He recommended using the “tort of injurious falsehood” under Israeli civil law, codified in Section 58 of Israel’s Civil Wrongs Ordinance. This process does not require a sovereign plaintiff, but rather identifiable professional actors harmed by a false statement concerning their trade, occupation, or professional conduct.
“The members of a specific canine or detention unit … are not Israel in the abstract,” Goldfeder said. “They are professionals whose careers, assignments, and livelihoods are directly implicated by the allegation. If even a small, identifiable cohort of personnel can plausibly say ‘this is necessarily about us,’ then the plaintiff problem is solved.”
If even a small, identifiable cohort of personnel can plausibly say ‘this is necessarily about us,’ then the plaintiff problem is solved.
Another option, which Shurat HaDin is pushing the government to pursue, is to bring an indictment under Israel’s defamation law, which includes both civil and criminal components.
“Whereas the state cannot bring a civil lawsuit, they can bring a criminal indictment,” Darshan-Leitner explained. “There was pure libel against Israel, and it should be discussed in court.”
She said this could happen because the research for the article, the interviews, the people Kristof spoke to, and the events described all took place in Israel. In addition, Israel has jurisdiction to indict for crimes intended against the Jewish people and the Jewish state.
“There 100% should be a say here from the Israeli government and the Jewish state,” Darshan-Leitner said. “Israel should not take it lying down anymore. With this article, The New York Times crossed a very bright red line.”
Israel should not take it lying down anymore. With this article, The New York Times crossed a very bright red line.
Goldfeder agreed. As he wrote in the National Review, “a global newspaper owes some duty of care before printing a claim this specific and this inflammatory. The more serious the allegation, the heavier the verification burden. The Times cannot hide behind the general importance of reporting on detainee abuse.”