Malarndirri McCarthy says states should be penalised for Closing the Gap failures

The minister for Indigenous Australians, Malarndirri McCarthy, says she wants to introduce penalties for states and territories that fail to make progress on the Closing the Gap targets.

At Senate estimates this morning, McCarthy says federal funding was not a part of the agreement when it was signed in 2020.

She has been facing questioning from independent senator Lidia Thorpe, who has been pushing for the government to provide a figure on exactly how much money the government gives to the states and territories under the Closing the Gap agreement. We don’t have a figure as of yet.

McCarthy says it’s a “gap” in the agreement that the government can’t use funding levers to pressure states to do better on the targets.

[There’s] no penalty in agreement, I’m trying to look at federal funding arrangements with each state and territory over whatever the agreement might be as to how we can input into that so that there is some kind of penalty as to why you’re not achieving targets.

Closing the Gap funding is not actually a part of the agreement, this is what we’ve got to manoeuvre now in terms of the federal funding arrangements and that’s what I want to see happen going forward so there can be levers pulled to ensure targets are being met.

We don’t have any details yet of what those penalties would be or when they would be introduced.

Minister for Indigenous Australians, Malarndirri McCarthy.Minister for Indigenous Australians, Malarndirri McCarthy. Photograph: Mick Tsikas/AAPShare

Updated at 20.13 EDT

Key events

Show key events only

Please turn on JavaScript to use this feature

Israel’s ambassador to Australia Amir Maimon spoke to Sky News a littler earlier on the second anniversary of the 7 October massacre by Hamas.

Maimon, who was in Israel at the time, says he will never forget the atrocity of 7 October:

It’s one thing to see their [hostages] posters all over the world. It’s a totally different thing to visit their home, the home from which they were taken. To see the burnt rooms. To see the blood stains. This is so sad. I don’t believe I will ever be able to overcome the scenes and the tragedy that took place on October 7th.

ShareBenita KolovosBenita Kolovos

Victorian premier says pro-Hamas graffiti is ‘hateful’

Jacinta Allan has ended her briefing on Metro Tunnel and is holding a press conference.

Asked about the graffiti in Melbourne this morning that states “glory to Hamas”, she described it as “hateful”. Allan went on:

It has no place, and it’s even more hateful on a day where we stand in support of a Jewish community that is grieving the second anniversary of the single biggest loss of Jewish life in a single day since the Holocaust.

On any given day this hateful behaviour is wrong, it’s disgraceful. But particularly today, and I say to the Jewish community, we stand with you. We support you and I encourage all Victorians to reach out they know someone from the Jewish community who might be grieving, who might be finding today difficult to reach out to them, because this behaviour does not represent peace.

Share

Updated at 20.52 EDT

PM labels pro-Hamas graffiti in Melbourne ‘abhorrent’

Anthony Albanese has released a statement on graffiti praising Hamas seen in Melbourne this morning. The graffiti, on a building in Fitzory, states “glory to Hamas”.

The prime minister says:

“The terrorist propaganda defacing a Melbourne billboard on the anniversary of the October 7 murders is abhorrent.

“The people responsible must face the full force of the law. The AFP will work with Victorian police to bring them to justice.”

Pro-Hamas graffiti is seen on a billboard above a shop in Melbourne on Tuesday morning. Photograph: Joel Carrett/AAPShare

Updated at 20.24 EDT

10,000 government home care packages to be released this week

Half of the government’s extra 20,000 promised home care packages will be released by the end of this week, with the remaining packages on track to be allocated by 1 November.

You might remember the Coalition, Greens and crossbench forced the hand of the government to bring forward the extra home care packages.

The aged care legislation, passed in the last parliament, which had included extra home care packages, was delayed to 1 November this year. The government said the delay was to give industry more time to adjust before the major changes took effect.

But the opposition and crossbench said that delay should not have also resulted in the delay of releasing those home care packages.

In a statement, the aged care minister, Sam Rae, said:

Labor’s delivery of these packages means more older Australians will get the care they need, when they need it, taking pressure off our hospital system and giving so many the world-class care they deserve in the places they love.

Aged care minister, Sam Rae. Photograph: Lukas Coch/AAPShare

Updated at 20.30 EDT

Joe HinchliffeJoe Hinchliffe

Dfat providing consular assistance to seven Australians still detained in Israel

Seven Australians from the 171 activists captured from a flotilla carrying aid to Gaza remain incarcerated in Israel. Some members of the flotilla were released and deported on Monday.

The Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade (Dfat) confirmed at about 9:15am AEDT on Tuesday morning – which is 1:15am in Tel Aviv – that it was providing consular assistance to seven Australians detained in Israel, including in-person visits, but that privacy obligations prevented it from further comment.

At least several of those Australians have alleged they are receiving “degrading and humiliating treatment”, including physical violence and requests for needed medication not being met.

Guardian Australia understands that Dfat is aiming to facilitate the deportation of the Australians as a group via Jordan and is hopeful that may be achieved later on Tuesday.

The mother of detained Melbourne-based GP, Bianca Pullman-Webb, said she was feeling “pretty stressed” about her daughter’s continued incarceration in a high-security prison in the Negev desert.

But given Julie Webb-Pullman said she has not been provided the same level of detail as some of other next of kin of the captured Australians, she is deeply concerned her daughter may not be released as soon as her compatriots.

If Bianca isn’t released, I will be extremely concerned.

Bianca Webb-Pullman is one of seven Australians detained in Israel after she was sailing with a pro-Palestinian flotilla carrying aid to GazaShare

Updated at 20.09 EDT

Malarndirri McCarthy says states should be penalised for Closing the Gap failures

The minister for Indigenous Australians, Malarndirri McCarthy, says she wants to introduce penalties for states and territories that fail to make progress on the Closing the Gap targets.

At Senate estimates this morning, McCarthy says federal funding was not a part of the agreement when it was signed in 2020.

She has been facing questioning from independent senator Lidia Thorpe, who has been pushing for the government to provide a figure on exactly how much money the government gives to the states and territories under the Closing the Gap agreement. We don’t have a figure as of yet.

McCarthy says it’s a “gap” in the agreement that the government can’t use funding levers to pressure states to do better on the targets.

[There’s] no penalty in agreement, I’m trying to look at federal funding arrangements with each state and territory over whatever the agreement might be as to how we can input into that so that there is some kind of penalty as to why you’re not achieving targets.

Closing the Gap funding is not actually a part of the agreement, this is what we’ve got to manoeuvre now in terms of the federal funding arrangements and that’s what I want to see happen going forward so there can be levers pulled to ensure targets are being met.

We don’t have any details yet of what those penalties would be or when they would be introduced.

Minister for Indigenous Australians, Malarndirri McCarthy. Photograph: Mick Tsikas/AAPShare

Updated at 20.13 EDT

Jordyn BeazleyJordyn Beazley

‘I back the police,’ Minns says about proposed Palestinian protest march on Sydney Opera House

Returning to NSW news for a moment. The state’s premier, Chris Minns, appeared on 2GB with Ben Fordham earlier this morning where he was asked about the proposed plan to march on the Sydney Opera House this Sunday.

As we covered here in the blog a little earlier, the Palestine Action Group is facing court this morning in their fight against the NSW police after their application to hold the protest was knocked back. Minns said:

I back the police here. They’ve made a decision based on community safety. It’s an incredibly narrow peninsula, as everybody knows, that forecourt of the Opera House, and they’ve got a responsibility to keep the public safe.

They’re suggesting to the campaign organisers, can’t you choose another street? Can’t you choose another part of Sydney? We’ll facilitate the march, but stay away from that for a whole range of reasons.”

I’m hoping common sense prevails here. I’m also conscious of the fact that the organisers seem to use the notoriety and attention associated with comments from people like me to drive attendance and say that they’re being well, free speech is being stopped in a place like Sydney, but I back the police here. They’ve made a commonsense decision to keep Sydney safe.

After Fordham confirmed the decision was in the hands of the court, Minns said:

I realise some people would say, just ban protests, just move a bill and knock it off this afternoon. That [would be] subject to a high court challenge quicker than you can look at it, and I want to make sure that we’re not back to square one, where these protests are able to go ahead without any kind of regulation or oversight.

People attend a vigil for the Palestinians who have died in the two years of Israel’s offensive in Gaza, at Sydney Town Hall on Monday 6 October. Photograph: Sitthixay Ditthavong/AAPShare

Updated at 19.41 EDT

Benita KolovosBenita Kolovos

Metro Tunnel soft launch in December, opens fully from 1 February

The Victorian premier, Jacinta Allan, is about to hold a briefing for her MPs and journalists to announce the launch of the Metro Tunnel.

According to her media release, it will have a “summer launch” in early December with services every 20 minutes from 10am to 3pm between Westall, on the Cranbourne Pakenham line, and West Footscray, on the Sunbury line.

On weekends, services will run every 20 minutes from 10am to 7pm between Westall and West Footscray, every 40 minutes from East Pakenham and every 60 minutes from Sunbury.

The Metro Tunnel will have a ‘summer launch’ in early December. Photograph: Asanka Brendon Ratnayake/The Guardian

These services are an addition to existing services that will continue as normal through the City Loop.

It will then be fully integrated into the transport network on 1 February. On this date, the entire transport timetable will change and the Sunbury, Cranbourne and Pakenham lines will travel exclusively through the Metro Tunnel. During peak, the government says trains will run three to four minutes apart.

Frankston services will also return to the City Loop at that time.

The media release says this two-step launch follows “international best practice”:

The best way to make sure everything runs well is to open the tunnel and run services first, then make the big timetable switch afterwards – not attempt them simultaneously.

It also says it will allow tests of the new infrastructure and technology in real world conditions “so bugs can be ironed out without disrupting the rest of the train network”.

Share

Updated at 19.36 EDT

Marles says ‘no doubt’ Melbourne pro-Hamas graffiti will be looked into as possible terror offence

Richard Marles has labelled graffiti praising Hamas seen in Melbourne this morning “disgraceful”, in an interview on ABC radio Melbourne this morning. The graffiti, seen in Fitzroy, states “glory to Hamas”.

Marles has said across multiple interviews that today is a “day of commemoration and remembrance” and not a day of protest.

To have that message scrawled in that way, is obviously disgraceful and we need to be a society which is cohesive, which looks out for each other and that is obviously a message of division.

Asked whether the graffiti is a terrorism offence, Marles says he’s not sure but has “no doubt” this will be looked into.

Marles says there are people in the community today who do feel threatened, and that is “of enormous concern”.

I really think we have seen social cohesion put under as much pressure as I’ve seen in my lifetime over the course of the last couple of years. And it’s really therefore important that we are thinking about that in the context of our own nation and making sure that we are looking after each other as Australians.

On the actions of the Israeli government, Marles says international law will apply and the conduct of any military action will “ultimately be judged”.

Share

Updated at 19.34 EDT

Josh TaylorJosh Taylor

Government secretly assesses which platforms could be covered by under 16s social media ban

The federal communications department has conducted its own assessment of 30 different platforms, gaming apps, dating apps and messaging apps as to whether they might need to block under 16s from their services from 10 December, documents have revealed.

Guardian Australia reported last month the eSafety commissioner had written to several of these platforms including Facebook, Snap, TikTok, YouTube, Reddit, and Twitch asking them to conduct self-assessments on if the ban should apply to them.

However, documents published on the communications department’s disclosure log last week reveal public servants have already assessed 30 different platforms including BlueSky, LegoPlay, Mastodon, WeChat, and Discord on whether they are likely to meet the definition of social media under the ban and therefore would have to prevent access for under 16s from December.

The documents, however, are redacted, and the department’s verdict on each platform has been deemed “deliberative” content that was not released under freedom of information laws.

The eSafety commissioner will respond to the self-assessments on whether it agrees or disagrees with the platform’s views on whether they will be included in the ban. The platforms covered will need to then work to remove existing accounts of under 16s by 10 December, and put in place age checks to prevent those users registering new accounts.

Australia’s social media ban for under-16s is now law. There’s plenty we still don’t know – videoAustralia’s social media ban for under-16s is now law. There’s plenty we still don’t know – videoShare

Updated at 19.10 EDT

Ley and Spender condemn Melbourne graffiti praising Hamas

The opposition leader, Sussan Ley, says graffiti in the Melbourne suburb of Fitzroy is “deeply disturbing” and has called for those responsible to face the full force of the law.

The graffiti, painted on a billboard facing a busy road, reads “glory to Hamas”.

In a statement, Ley says:

Hamas is a listed terrorist organisation in Australia. Supporting them is not free speech, it is a crime. Those responsible must face the full force of the law.

Victorians deserve to feel safe in their own community. The AFP and ASIO should support Victorian police to track down those behind this disgraceful act and bring them to justice.

Pro-Hamas graffiti seen on a billboard above a shop in Melbourne. Photograph: Joel Carrett/AAP

Independent MP Allegra Spender called the graffiti “foul” in an interview with Sky News.

It just has no place in this country. Hamas is a terrorist organisation … We are at the moment where peace is possible, and you know, what I believe people want to see out of this process is actually long-term peace for Israeli people and for Palestinian people.

Share

Updated at 19.18 EDT

Jordyn BeazleyJordyn Beazley

Palestine Action Group to call for NSW supreme court to make finding of genocide in Gaza

The Palestine Action Group will this morning face court in their fight against the New South Wales police over a proposed plan to march on the Sydney Opera House this Sunday.

During the hearing the group also plans to call on the NSW supreme court “to make a formal finding that Israel’s onslaught in Gaza amounts to genocide”.

It comes after Justice Desmond Fagan, when hearing the matter for directions on Friday, said he thought the crowd could exceed 100,000 because of “what appears to be the sentiment in the community, and that has developed over two years of sort of real time broadcasting of genocide of too many people”. PAG spokesperson Amal Naser said:

We welcome Justice Fagan’s willingness to call out genocide, reflecting the undeniable reality on the ground.

We refuse to allow police, politicians, or state institutions to erase this truth. Our movement stands on the side of justice and international law. Our lawyers will argue for the supreme court to recognise both: Our right to protest under domestic and international law. That Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people.

Last Wednesday, the group announced its plan to diverge from the normal route of its near weekly rallies over the past two years, and march from Hyde Park to the Sydney Opera House on 12 October to mark two years since the start of Israel’s military campaign in Gaza.

But on Friday the NSW police announced it would knock back the group’s application to march to the Opera House, citing safety concerns such as crowd crush over limited exit points from the forecourt.

Two Jewish groups are also attempting to challenge in court the protest and its location. It’s the first time the Executive Council of Jewry and the Jewish Board of Deputies have sought to challenge a pro-Palestine protest.

The court is expected to decide this morning if their challenge will be allowed to be heard or not.

Share

Updated at 18.58 EDT

Adding a bit of context to the last post, Anthony Albanese had said before that 8 October 2023 protest that it should not go ahead.

Both he and foreign minister Penny Wong condemned footage appearing to show attenders at the rally chanting anti-Jewish sentiments (a claim police later walked back after independent analysis).

At the time, Albanese said images from the rally were “horrific”, and there were, “slogans which are antisemitic and just appalling, with no place”.

Share

Updated at 18.52 EDT

Tim Wilson claims Albanese lost ‘moral authority’ by not ‘standing up’ against pro-Palestine protests

Liberal MP Tim Wilson claims Hamas has “won a propaganda war every step of the way” in response to graffiti found this morning in Melbourne which states “glory to Hamas”.

Wilson told Sky News there are some who still are trying to “sow division”.

There [are] some sections, sadly, of the Australian community who want to sow division, to turn hatred towards, particularly the Jewish community, but to use as a basis to drive broader division within society and to inflame extremism.

Wilson also said he hopes planned protests at the Sydney Opera House over the weekend will not go ahead, and accused the prime minister of having lost “moral authority” for not “standing up” to previous protests.

[Albanese] lost his moral authority when he didn’t stand up against the protests on 8 October 2023 on the steps of the Sydney Opera House …

I hope it doesn’t go ahead, because think about the number of lives that have been lost. Think about the families have been separated. Think about the people who have had their children burned alive by Hamas.

Share

Updated at 18.22 EDT

It’s coming up to 9am which means Senate estimates is about to begin.

We have eyes on all the committees, so we’ll bring you the drama as it happens.

Share

Updated at 18.01 EDT