Decades from now, people are going to look back at the current crop of horror movies and say it was a high point for the genre. Movies like Sinners have brought positive attention to horror, and studios are backing original ideas done well, such as Good Boy, the supernatural flick told from a dog’s perspective. Current horror features smart scripts, special effects that have never looked better, and incredible acting evoking strong emotions from the audience.
It’s not even necessary to look back at the last decade, because even within the last five years, there have been multiple examples of breathtaking performances in horror. The following list covers the greatest horror performances of the last five years. This ranking will factor in the significance of the performance to the movie, the emotional range on display, and the complexity of the role.
10
Kyle Gallner in ‘The Passenger’ (2023)
Benson (Kyle Gallner) holding a shotgun and covered in blood spatter in ‘The Passenger’Image via MGM+
The indie psychological horror thriller The Passenger is elevated by a noteworthy Kyle Gallner as the spiralling killer Benson. The film follows Benson as he spontaneously guns down his co-workers and managers at a rundown fast food restaurant before taking the surviving co-worker, Randy (Johnny Berchtold), on an unpredictable day of confidence-building. In the brief moments before the consequences catch up to his actions, Benson tries to connect with the quiet and afraid Randy.
Gallner is magnetic in The Passenger, constantly brimming with a restless tension that makes him seem in motion even in moments of stillness. Gallner flips between charming and forceful in equal measure, relishing the control he’s taken and responding with fury in the moments it slips away. Benson is a character that many actors would mistakenly play overly theatrical, but Gallner keeps him grounded despite his volatility.
9
Lea Myren in ‘The Ugly Stepsister’ (2025)
Lea Myren as Elvira holds up a tapeworm egg and looks at it in The Ugly Stepsister Image via IFC Films
Writer and director Emilie Kristine Blichfeldt crafted a dark version of the Cinderella story written in acid with her feature film The Ugly Stepsister. In this rendition, Cinderella (Thea Sofie Loch Næss) takes a back seat with the camera shifting over to the plight of her new stepsister, Elvira (Lea Myren). Elvira and her family have just moved in when her new stepfather dies, and the discovery of no money between both families means an opportunity to marry the prince will require a medieval approach to plastic surgery.
Elvira begins the movie with a wide-eyed and naive understanding of love, innocent and hopeful. However, after an excruciating beauty boot camp that involves a nose job via a hammer, an ingested tapeworm for pre-Wegovy results, and eyelashes that are sewn into her eyelids, she becomes a battle-hardened survivor. We feel the physical pain second-hand thanks to scenes that are hard to watch, but we feel the emotional pain through Myren’s eyes, as the gentle person she is at heart becomes warped into an abused tool for financial gain.
8
David Dastmalchian in ‘Late Night with the Devil’ (2024)
Jack Delroy, played by actor David Dastmalchian, screaming in Late Night with the Devil.Image via IFC Films
After years of making small appearances in movies like The Dark Knight and Ant-Man, David Dastmalchian proved he was worthy of leading roles in Late Night with the Devil. Framed as the lost broadcast of the fictional late-night talk show Night Owls with Jack Delroy, Late Night with the Devil sees Dastmalchian assume the role of host Jack Delroy. In an attempt to boost sagging ratings, Jack stages a live Halloween broadcast that goes awry.
Late Night with the Devil premiered with a heavy amount of buzz, and a large portion of it was directed toward Dastmalchian’s performance. The career-making part gave Dastmalchian a complicated character to get lost in and display his acting chops. Jack’s desperation, hidden under a fake smile, becomes evident during behind-the-scenes segments that slowly hint at the depths the host will go to hold on to the spotlight.
7
Hugh Grant in ‘Heretic’ (2024)
Hugh Grant has firmly established himself as one of the most charming men to ever live, so everyone should be grateful he held off on using his powers for evil until the movie Heretic. The film follows two Mormon missionaries, Sister Barnes (Sophie Thatcher) and Sister Paxton (Chloe East), who arrive at the house of Mr. Reed (Grant) after he expressed interest in learning more about their religion. However, once the two young women are inside Reed’s house, it becomes clear he has ulterior motives for their visit.
The acting is outstanding across the board, and Thatcher continues to be an MVP in the genre with her work in Companion being noteworthy as well, but Grant commands every scene in Heretic. Reed is a thought-provoking villain who does his damndest to prove why he’s not a villain through logic and sound reasoning that is designed to confuse and breed doubt. Reed is a part that anyone would have been lucky to get their hands on, but few, if any, could have brought the same good-natured charisma to it that Grant did. Make this man play more villains.
6
Bill Skarsgård in ‘Nosferatu’ (2024)
Bill Skarsgård as Count Orlok waking up in Nosferatu.Image via Focus Features
A classic vampire story received a lush remake when Nosferatu was released just in time for some anti-Christmas cheer in 2024. Director Robert Eggers created a horror epic for the modern age, and at the heart of it was the hideous Count Orlok, played by an unrecognizable Bill Skarsgård. A huge amount of credit goes to David White, who designed the 62-piece prosthetic of the vampiric Orlok, but Skarsgård still had to bring the monster to life.
One of the best moves the updated Nosferatu did was change the visual appearance of Orlok, making him look more like a hulking cadaver than the demonic-esque appearance of the original. Skarsgård transformed himself for the part, all the way down to his vocal performance, where he modified his normal speaking intonation to a gravelly tone after training with an opera singer to modify his voice. The work paid off, because the modern Orlok became an otherworldly force that was a vampire unlike anything audiences had seen.
5
‘Rebecca Hall in ‘The Night House (2021)
Beth Parchin (Rebecca Hall) looking scared in ‘The Night House’Image via Searchlight Pictures
In The Night House, Rebecca Hall plays Beth Parchin, a woman who is left with questions and heartache after her husband Owen (Evan Jonigkeit) commits suicide. The questions continue to mount up when Beth finds photos of a woman who looks remarkably similar to herself. Concerned that Owen was possibly having an affair, she begins to look into Owen’s life, only to find he was doing something unbelievably more twisted.
Hall is unable to turn in a bad performance, but the measured restraint present in her portrayal of the grief-stricken Beth is masterful acting. The effort to control her emotions is as draining as the loss she’s endured, and this can all be read on Beth’s face through Hall’s choices. It’s painful to watch a person lose themselves to sorrow, but Hall makes watching someone push it all inside seem somehow more crushing.
4
David Jonsson in ‘The Long Walk’ (2025)
Cooper Hoffman and David Jonsson in The Long Walk Image Via Lionsgate
In The Long Walk, a group of young men enters a competition where they must continue to walk at a pace of three miles per hour or be executed. The last one walking wins. Cooper Hoffman stars as Ray, a contestant who bonds with the jovial and charismatic fellow participant Pete (David Jonsson). Even though they’re in direct competition with one another, the two young men grow to rely on one another as the numbers thin down and their bodies break down.
The Long Walk is a movie that rests on the performances, and the entire ensemble cast steps up to the challenge. The brief but meaningful friendship between Ray and Pete is built on the character work and chemistry of Hoffman and Jonsson, but much like in his turn in 2024’s Alien: Romulus, Jonsson turns in another star-making piece of acting. Pete is determined, wise beyond his years, and rightfully scared, but he bravely moves forward with the idea that he can make a change for the better.
3
Willa Fitzgerald in ‘Strange Darling’ (2023)
Willa Fitzgerald as the Lady running in Strange DarlingImage via Magenta Light Studios
The horror thriller Strange Darling may not have been a financial success, but the movie needs to be on more people’s radars for the fantastic performance from Willa Fitzgerald. Strange Darling follows two strangers, listed as “The Lady” (Fitzgerald) and “The Demon” (Kyle Gallner), as they engage in a one-night stand. The audience sees the two flirt, attempt to learn if the other is safe, but many secrets will be revealed before their time together is over.
If the description of the movie sounds vague, that’s on purpose, because Strange Darling is a movie that should be watched knowing as little as possible before going in. Here’s what is important to know, though: Fitzgerald does the best work of her career in a role that allows her to go through the full spectrum of emotions without leaving any unchecked by the credits. After watching Strange Darling, you’ll wonder why Fitzgerald isn’t being offered every role in Hollywood.
2
Sally Hawkins in ‘Bring Her Back’ (2025)
Laura sits in a purple outfit at a funeral in Bring Her Back.Image via A24
Bring Her Back is probably one of the most divisive movies to come out in recent years, horror or otherwise, but it’s not because of the acting. The death of their father leaves Andy (Billy Barratt) and his visually impaired stepsister Piper (Sora Wong) without a legal guardian. When the siblings are placed with Laura (Sally Hawkins), they assume it will only be temporary, but their new foster mother’s odd behavior hints at a dangerous future for them both.
Laura is so driven to her goal that any innocent lives that get destroyed are acceptable collateral damage. Yet somehow, despite being an unredeemable antagonist, two-time Oscar nominee Hawkins instills enough humanity into Laura that the audience can understand her pain. The way Laura manipulates everyone around her is monstrous, but the delusion is so clearly present in the performance, adding further tragedy to the horror.
1
Mia Goth in ‘Pearl’ (2022)
Mia Goth as Pearl smiling in the last scene of Pearl.Image via A24
Out of all the performances in the last five years, none come close to Mia Goth’s in Pearl. A prequel to the Ti West slasher throwback X, Pearl tells the story of Pearl (Goth) as a young woman waiting for her husband to return from war. When the possibility of stardom makes Pearl yearn for something more in her life, her impulsive nature will lead to tragic and bloody results.
If performances like Goth’s are going to be ignored by the Academy, then the process of nominating should be reevaluated. Goth is astounding as Pearl, making her a vulnerable figure who logically wants to be a good person but is unable to control naturally dark impulses. She has enough emotional intelligence to accept that she’s unable to change, and the fastest way to soothe her frustrations is to indulge in the darkness that scares people away.