A former leader of the Green Party has said that allegedly antisemitic statements by members require “immediate action” as criticism of Zack Polanski’s response continues.
Caroline Lucas’s statement came as it emerged a Green candidate who was suspended for suggesting that Israel may have paid Hamas to carry out the October 7 attacks had been allowed to run at the upcoming local elections.
Lucas, the former MP for Brighton Pavilion who led the party in three stints between 2003 and 2018, wrote on social media: “Statements that have now come to light from a handful of Green Party candidates are totally unacceptable and require immediate action.
“There’s no place for antisemitism or any hate speech in the party. This is a society-wide problem and needs to be rooted out wherever it’s found.”
Zack Polanski in September last year, when he became Green Party leaderBEN MONTGOMERY/GETTY IMAGES
Joe Belcher, the party’s candidate in Rushall-Shelfield in Walsall, who was suspended for suggesting that Israel may have paid Hamas to carry out the October 7 attacks, has been allowed to run at the forthcoming local elections.
Belcher was suspended by the party and blocked from running to be the MP for Aldridge-Brownhills in 2024 after a series of social media posts were uncovered.
Posts made by the Green candidate questioned why Hamas would have “sold their people down the river” by attacking Israel.
Joe Belcher
“Why would Hamas commanders order October 7 to then have their territory destroyed and their people killed or displaced from Gaza?” he said. “For money? If so, who offered them this money? The Israel government? If so, the Israel government also sold its own people down the river on Oct 7.”
He said it was “certainly convenient now that Israel can attempt to justify wiping out Palestinians from Gaza and to claim Gaza as Israel”, in an effort to claim rights over the oil and gas reserves and create a canal through Gaza.
In a separate post that month he condemned the October 7 attacks and the “occupation”.
He added: “My hunch is the leaders of Israel and Gaza conspired to carry out what happened on 7 Oct for financial gain. But I don’t have any proof. This is why it remains a hunch and nothing more.”
In response to Belcher’s reinstatement, the Green Party said: “These are old allegations which were investigated while Joe Belcher was serving a no-fault suspension from the party. We, of course, look at any new complaint seriously.”
Last month two Green council candidates were arrested on suspicion of stirring racial hatred over alleged antisemitic social media posts.
The development came as an audit of Green candidates revealed that prospective councillors had shared conspiracy theories and allegedly antisemitic views on social media.
Rajeev Kumar, a Green candidate in Newham, said on X last June that Jews “know they should be hated” in response to a post criticising antisemitism.
“I haven’t met a single person in my life who hates Jews, but I have met dozens of Jews continuously saying, ‘people hate us’,” he replied. “Now I think they know something about themselves that we don’t, and they fear hate because they know they should be hated for that.”
In 2015 he shared a blog post that claimed India was “deeply contaminated by Islam” and described the “abuse of women, active human slavery, rape waves [and] incest” as “traits found in Islamic culture”. The blog also provided a link to the website of the far-right British National Party.
Kumar also accused Steve Reed, the communities secretary, of overstating the issue of antisemitism during Jeremy Corbyn’s leadership of the party. “The dirty game you played with in [sic] the Labour Party with Corbyn will not work for Zack and the Green Party,” Kumar said.
Kumar is not the only Green candidate to have made controversial comments about Judaism. During a pro-Palestinian march Nosheen Majid, standing in Leeds, accused “the Jews” of recreating the Holocaust in Gaza.
“Do you know the injustice of why the Second World War happened, with the Nazis and everything [sic] and the Jews? Now the Jews are doing the same thing to the Palestinians,” Majid said. “Hamas are fighting and that’s because they don’t have their own army.”
Regarding Kumar and Majid, a Green Party spokesperson said: “Where there are examples brought to our attention that do not fit in with the views of the Green Party, we are looking into them.”
A spokesperson for the Leeds Green Party said that Majid’s comments were “a short clip from a longer interaction, recorded without her knowledge” and did not reflect the “full context”.
However, the spokesperson added that Majid had “reflected on the exchange and accepts that, in responding on the spot, she did not clearly distinguish between the actions of the Israeli government and Jewish people more broadly. She regrets this and is clear that this distinction matters .”
Last week Tina Ion, a Green candidate from Newcastle, was referred to the party’s disciplinary processes after she published posts on the platform Threads under the handle “thereal.anne.frank” calling for “every single Zionist” to be killed.
Ion told the BBC that the posts, which referred to “zionists” as “vermin” and “rats”, were “isolated fragments” of her statements. She rejected “any accusation of antisemitism” and said her criticism was not aimed at a religion but at “political ideology and a set of state actions”.
Tina Ion
In response to the revelations, Newcastle’s Green Party said it no longer supported her candidacy, adding that it was “appalled by the racist material written and shared by” her.
The party said: “This is a very serious situation. We are reviewing our vetting processes and will act on the national party’s findings. Robust action is needed.”
Other Green candidates have also expressed policy positions outside of the party line. They include George Grun, a candidate in Hackney, who called for the UK to leave Nato and said membership “stands in the way of the UK having an independent foreign policy”, in stark contrast to the Green Party’s official support for the alliance.
Regarding Grun, a party source said: “The Green Party is proud of the grassroots democratic way it decides policy and the debate that contributes to that.”
Several candidates have criminal records. Stephanie Golder, a Just Stop Oil activist who is standing in Tower Hamlets, was handed a six-month suspended sentence and ordered to do 200 hours of unpaid work in 2023 for smashing petrol pumps at Cobham services on the M25.
A Green Party spokesperson said: “Stephanie now focuses her care for the environment and local community in ways other than direct protest.”
Carlotta Allum, standing in Lambeth, spent nine months in an American prison after she was caught with 10,000 tablets of ecstasy strapped to her body at Los Angeles airport almost three decades ago. She later testified against the Leeds-based drug dealer who had paid her £5,000 for the journey.
Allum told The Times that she had “always been open” about her past and that her experiences had made her “passionate about the criminal justice system and the fight for equality”.
Regarding Allum, a party source said: “The Green Party supports restorative justice and those with lived experience who can contribute positively to our democracy.”
Polanski, the Green leader, launched what a Green Party source described as an attack unit to “fight back” against Labour cabinet ministers criticising the party.
The Greens have allocated staff members to work on preparing dossiers on Labour figures including Reed, who accused the Greens of appointing candidates with a history of antisemitic views, and the prospective leadership candidate Wes Streeting.
The party has also commissioned an external research agency to conduct focus groups, testing whether the attacks on Labour figures will “land” with the public.
A Green Party spokesperson said: “There is no new unit being formed and no staff have been hired for this purpose. A couple of existing staff were asked to compile briefings on Reed and Wes Streeting due to their links with Labour Together and [Lord] Mandelson. Unlike Labour, the Green Party doesn’t spend members’ money combing through the social media of rival candidates. Our resources are focused on developing and delivering plans to build social housing, renationalise utilities and transport, tax wealth, and bring down the cost of living.”
A source close to Reed said: “It tells you all you need to know about Polanski’s woeful response to tackling antisemitism in the Green Party, that his first reaction has been to set up a smear unit designed to target Steve, who has been the first politician to call out the hatred. To be attacked by moral cowards is a badge of honour.”