Tautari carried a tomahawk while one of his co-offenders was allegedly armed with a sawn-off shotgun.
The trio yelled at staff and customers to get on the ground and moved behind the counter.
A shot was fired into the air while Tautari smashed glass cabinets.
More than $12,000 of product, including 38 cellphones, and cash were taken from the store in the heist, and a staff member was also allegedly assaulted.
The group fled, sparking a police manhunt.
Tautari and two of his co-offenders were arrested more than two weeks later, on August 21.
The Noel Leeming store in Waipapa that was robbed by three males in 2024. Photo / Google Maps
Tautari was remanded into custody before being granted electronically monitored bail a year later, in September 2025.
But when police arrived at his address for a bail check in December 2025, he fled, triggering another manhunt. He was caught in late January.
At the sentencing hearing, Judge Brandt Shortland reflected on an earlier court hearing with Tautari at the end of last year.
“I can appreciate when we came originally to sentence, you would’ve got the wiri wiris [shakes],” the judge said.
“You were told to make sure you’re prepared, and you probably responded with your wae waes [legs]. But here we are – this is big boys’ stuff now, serious stuff.”
Tautari’s associates remain at various stages of the court, which Judge Shortland remarked, “Those other fullas will face their own music.”
Defence lawyer Chris Muston said the reality of the situation had finally hit his client.
“He’s not a very happy chap today … he’s selfishly tried to dodge the bullet but, nevertheless, here he is,” Muston said.
Judge Shortland said the robbery created a frightening situation that could easily have ended in tragedy.
“In New Zealand history, some people have died as a result of things that were planned like this.”
Tautari told pre-sentence report writers he acted because he was bored, angry and “sick of being pōhara [poor]”.
“You said you needed money for food and drugs and you were upfront about that,” the judge said.
“Since then, you’ve had time to think about things and you’ve realised – not a good choice.”
He noted Tautari was 21 at the time, “but not 21 in the head”.
“All I say to you now, Mr Tautari, is I really hope for you, your whānau, your aunties, your nans, that you absolutely learn from this.”
Tautari was sentenced to three years and one month in prison and will go before the Parole Board for release.
Shannon Pitman is a Whangārei-based reporter for Open Justice covering courts in the Te Tai Tokerau region. She is of Ngāpuhi/ Ngāti Pūkenga descent and has worked in digital media for the past five years. She joined NZME in 2023.