At a court in Newmarket, north of Toronto, prosecutors said they did not believe they had a viable path towards murder convictions.
Law stood in a semi-enclosed area reserved for defendants, flanked by his three defence lawyers, and said “I plead guilty” to aiding the suicide of 14 people in Canada.
Sentencing will be determined at a separate hearing, likely in September, when the court will hear victim impact statements.
Legal experts note that aiding suicide is a serious crime and Law could receive a sentence of 10 to 20 years’ imprisonment.
After the guilty pleas were entered, prosecutors began reading an “agreed statement of facts”, a roughly 60-page document that detailed how Law shipped material for suicide across Canada and abroad, often for about $80.
Prosecutors recounted how people, after taking their own lives, were often found by family members with an open package of Law’s near their body.
‘Angry’
News that he will not stand trial for murder in Canada came as a disappointment to some families.
David Parfett’s son Thomas was 22 when he ended his life in 2021 with materials supplied by Law.
Now an advocate for more rigorous legislation to confront online spaces that guide people toward harm, Parfett told AFP that Canadian authorities were missing an opportunity to establish the gravity of Law’s conduct.
“If [Law] hadn’t been offering detailed instructions about how to take your own life, then the chances are my son would still be here. So again, for me, it’s murder,” Parfett said.
David Parfett’s late son Tom committed suicide using materials supplied by Law. Photo / AFP
In the agreed statement of facts, Law took responsibility for 79 deaths in Britain.
Britain’s National Crime Agency confirmed in a statement that Law will not face additional prosecution, but that the British deaths will be considered during sentencing in Canada.
A joint statement by the NCA and Britain’s prosecution service said the agencies had explained their decision to not prosecute Law “in detail to the victims and their families.”
Parfett said: “I am angry, but I am not surprised”.
He reiterated the families rebuffed calls for a UK public inquiry. “If our own country will not put anyone on trial for these deaths, the very least it can do is hold a proper inquiry into how they were allowed to happen.”
‘Healing’
Kim Prosser’s son Ashtyn took his own life in 2023, weeks before Law’s arrest. Law pleaded guilty Friday to aiding Ashtyn’s suicide.
Prosser told AFP of the painful three years since her son’s death on March 30, 2023.
“To be at the courthouse on Friday and to sit there … it’s a beginning to another chapter of this process of healing,” she said.
A key issue facing prosecutors was whether the alleged conduct could amount to both counselling suicide and murder.
Dalhousie University law professor Robert Currie told AFP that Law’s prosecutors were watching a separate case before the Supreme Court, hoping Canada’s top judges would offer clarity on the issue.
But the Supreme Court left that question unanswered, and prosecutors doubted they could secure murder convictions against Law, Currie said.
– AFP