As I mention often on this blog, I have a great interest in the universe—astrophysics, quantum mechanics, cosmology, all that stuff. With that, I’m no expert in any of it. I just enjoy reading and watching videos about it. Recently, I’ve found myself being fed the same headlines over and over again—that the universe is actually a simulation—an idea that’s been around a while, but really seems to be getting a push in my algorithm. I’ve even seen a few pieces argue for the increased likelihood that we live in a simulation in light of how many “scientists”/”experts” now believe it themselves. As I also often argue here, if most experts agree on something, then we should probably give them the benefit of the doubt when we’re not experts in that field. However, as critical thinkers, it is still up to us to confirm the credibility of this expertise and determine whether the experts actually do agree and believe it themselves, and so, that’s what I did here.

Background on the Simulation Argument

To begin, a little background—the simulation argument first started to take off in the early 2000s, when philosopher Nick Bostrom made the point that if a civilisation were to develop to the point where it could create a conscious simulation, it could generate them over and over. The “first” reality, or base reality, might create a second, and the second eventually create a third, and the third eventually a fourth, and so on (like a Russian nesting doll scenario). Thus, from a potentially infinite series of simulations, if you were to randomly select a single “individual,” statistically speaking, it’s most likely that they were a part of a simulated reality, as opposed to the base reality.

Of course, consistent with a previous post, in which I mentioned that we as a society have a significant problem in terms of our familiarity with academics or their research, I imagine not many people have heard of Nick Bostrom. However, as part of pop culture, most people do know Elon Musk, who publicly shared his belief in the simulation argument about a decade ago and has since elaborated upon it a variety of times. Sure, Elon is a smart guy, but he’s not an expert in this field. Some might argue that Bostrom isn’t either.

In terms of understanding the universe and cosmology, the three experts that immediately pop into my head are also somewhat famous in the sense that anyone who has ever watched a credible documentary on these types of topics would be familiar with their work: Brian Cox, Neil deGrasse Tyson, and Michio Kaku. Their takes on the simulation argument are interesting.

Cox addresses it as a philosophical idea, rather than a testable hypothesis, and is thus sceptical of the concept in light of zero evidence to suggest simulation as a valid theory. DeGrasse Tyson entertains the idea in a diplomatic manner by saying, on his podcast “StatTalk,” that it’s more a 50/50 case than a statistical likelihood that we live in a simulation because of a number of ignored assumptions (i.e., Bostrom’s initial argument addresses that we might not live in a simulation, but if we ever have the capability and choose to engage it, then we likely are; see also David Kipping’s take on the argument)—primarily the case that it would require living in a reality where such simulation can be conducted. As we don’t have the capability to conduct such a simulation yet, we are either in the base reality where it hasn’t happened yet (i.e., not a simulation), or we are in the most recent iteration of simulation (regardless of being the second, fifth, or 1 trillion-and-ninth), where it also hasn’t happened yet; thus, 50/50. Kaku, on the other hand, like Cox, is highly sceptical. Kaku calls it speculative and argues the impossibility of such a concept, as the processing required would exceed the limitations of any machine existing within that reality. Kaku’s perspective is also supported by a body of research suggesting the same. So, all in all, it doesn’t seem very likely, from the perspective of the experts addressed here, that we’re living in a simulation.

Psychological Implications of the Simulation Argument

So, what? What’s this got to do with psychology? The answer is two-fold. First, some people find such reports to be alarming and scary. What if we really were living in a simulation? What would that mean for you as a person? What would it mean for your family? How do such thoughts make you feel? Does it create existential dread or cause you stress? If so, hopefully this endeavour into expert opinion has made you feel better about things. Don’t let fear or emotion override good thinking. The simulation argument simply represents a philosophical take on existence, with arguably as much strength as an absurdist approach (as discussed previously on this blog) or any other philosophical perspective might have. Sure, some experts do entertain it as “possible,” but just because something is a possibility doesn’t make it the case. So, I wouldn’t worry too much about it! If such discussion doesn’t elicit any stress, great! Then consider the second point: hopefully, this piece has represented a good example of reinforcing this blog’s ongoing message about expertise and credibility.

My handle on Twitter is @CogitoErgoDwyer, a play on Descartes’ Cogito Ergo Sum—”I think, therefore I am.” Indeed, we’ve dealt with this existential dilemma for centuries. The concept is not new. We exist—at least, that’s what the experts seem to suggest, as discussed above. Likewise, the handle reflects my area of research—this is a blog about human cognition, about thinking. Specifically, it is a blog about critical thinking, so let’s think critically… from what source are you getting your information? When it comes to the nature of the universe, I’m not listening to pseudo-intellectual businessmen with a BSc; I want to hear it from the experts. Despite finding them so entertaining to read, as a sci-fi fan, I certainly don’t want to hear about how an example of a “glitch in the matrix” represents evidence—that’s not evidence; that’s an anecdote marred by your bias. Again, understanding credibility is important.

My algorithm keeps feeding me sensationalist reports pertaining to cosmology, the universe, and philosophy because they reflect my interests. But the algorithm doesn’t decipher the credibility for me; that’s something I have to do myself, and likewise, what you have to do for yourselves. Thus, this piece isn’t just about the simulation argument; it’s also about using critical thinking to potentially put your mind at ease and/or (at the very least) a further example of the importance of obtaining expert perspectives before accepting a new idea as true.