Written by Clare Burns, Ph.D., and Melissa Wheeler, Ph.D.
Wouldn’t it be wonderful to work with good colleagues? For many, an ideal work environment is one where people are kind to each other, they make supportive comments, bring cupcakes to mark special occasions, and celebrate each other’s wins. But what if these nice acts are camouflaging something more sinister?
Recent research by Bond University’s Clare Burns (and one of the authors of this post) introduced a paradox lurking behind nice work cultures.
Modern workplaces that pride themselves on being nice can simultaneously sustain rigid hierarchies—speaking up feels risky and questioning authority is quietly but firmly discouraged. Entrenched hierarchies create cultures of high power distances, where there are big gaps between leaders and subordinates.
This paradox results in a culture that looks friendly on the surface but tacitly enforces silence and quiets employee voice.
Niceness as a Defensive Strategy
Many organizations proudly espouse egalitarian values, claiming all workers are valued and can speak up. Indeed, some have the words “courageous,” “brave,” and “collaborative” displayed in their meeting rooms. These words project virtue but often bear little resemblance to the day-to-day assumptions of the people who work in the organization.
This curated appearance looks good from the outside, but insiders experience a different reality. Normative niceness, or the pressure to be agreeable and non-confrontational, acts like a control mechanism. In such environments, challenging the status quo is often perceived as incivility, causing people to keep their opinions to themselves. This suppression hurts people, organizations, and their stakeholders.
In this new research, managers of a large financial organization admitted they had not fully grasped the depth of the normative niceness expectations. They described being sent to coaching to moderate their direct, and supposedly “not nice,” communication styles. Frontline staff are aware that it is not nice to speak up; one shared that they had witnessed their colleagues speak up, only to face informal excommunication, leaving departure from the organization as their only option.
The study revealed that in-house staff surveys showed that employees felt comfortable raising challenging issues, but this was likely untrue. When external research was conducted, employees changed their story, reflecting that they were “dead scared” of saying or doing the wrong thing.
Authentic conversations were not happening, as being nice meant staying quiet. In such high-power-distance cultures, niceness was used as a systematized tool to protect directors from an uncomfortable confrontation.
Smiling Through Silence and the Impact on Sustainability
When employees learn that speaking up is not an acceptable norm, they figure out it is better to smile and nod at a superior’s comments.
Normative niceness may be subtle but can be highly effective in shaping culture. Can creativity thrive in normatively nice cultures? Surrounded by performative niceness, employees do not feel safe to offer suggestions that fall outside their managers’ comfort zones, nor do they feel comfortable articulating risks. A systematic voice–silence loop is created that does not reward speaking up or initiating tough conversations.
Within this command-and-control culture, espoused commitments to sustainability were not actualized. Sustainability goals were only talk, because financial logic, based on short-term profit, was the dominant model. Sustainability initiatives suffered when employees felt unsafe to question heavy investment in fossil-fuel-producing assets or the disconnect between what was written in corporate sustainability reports and the day-to-day reality.
Within the study, some participants stated there was a dark side to cultures that enforced agreeableness. Employees were aware that if they questioned topics such as greenwashing, they would be ostracized. Therefore, they stayed quiet, and their organization continued to neglect sustainability.
How Can Organizations Support Sustainability?
Resolving this niceness-sustainability paradox takes moral courage from directors. This means they need to be ready to receive uncomfortable feedback from employees and other stakeholders. It requires breaking long-standing defensive mechanisms, which include creating a psychologically safe climate where:
The director’s role model is constructive dissent
There is an open dialogue about where the organization is failing in its decision-making processes
Everyday practices and structures are implemented so that environmental and social considerations are heard alongside economic ones.
Staff are incentivized to speak up on sustainability issues and opportunities as part of their remuneration package.
Nice behavior, where people smile and agree even though they know what is being said is untrue, does not create cultures of kindness. These cultures are not good for employees or the organization in the long run. But change is possible if the tone is set and remodeled from the top, making difficult conversations a part of everyday work.
Co-author Clare Burns is an assistant professor at Bond University in Australia.