However, the student, now an adult, was granted permanent name suppression.
At a hearing in March, which Matthews did not attend, the former student told the tribunal he felt he was “living a double life” when he was attending school and having a sexual relationship with Matthews.
The student told the tribunal his relationship with Matthews began in his final year at school when she kissed him on the lips in front of other students.
But a kiss on a teacher-only day, when he was 17, changed everything.
“This kiss was different,” he said.
After that, the relationship became sexual. The student said he engaged in oral sex with Matthews, including in her parked car at a beach. She also took him to motels on at least two occasions.
Sometimes, he said, she touched him sexually during class when no one else was looking.
He said Matthews told him not to tell anyone, as she did not want anything to happen to her.
When he ended the relationship and tried to cut contact, she told him she was suicidal, he said.
“I felt she was guilt-tripping me.”
Matthews also allowed him to drive her car and a van full of students when he did not have the correct licence, he said.
Most of their contact occurred outside school hours.
The former student, supported by his whaea, made a complaint to the school and provided screenshots of text messages between the pair.
The tribunal also heard that Matthews gave cigarettes to students, asked them to buy her food, yelled at students, allowed students with learner licences to drive the school van, and on occasion changed attendance records so students could miss class.
As well as cancelling Matthews’ registration, the tribunal is seeking costs of $16,000 and a further $1000.
“Given Ms Matthews’ lack of engagement, we are unsure of her financial position,” Mackenzie said.
“We would like to give Ms Matthews an opportunity to engage on that aspect if she wishes to, before finalising any costs decision.”
If Matthews does not engage, the costs orders will become final without further notice or decision.
Brianna McIlraith is a Queenstown-based reporter for Open Justice covering courts in the lower South Island. She has been a journalist since 2018 and has had a strong interest in business and financial journalism.
Join NZ Herald’s Open Justice team for Case by Case, a video and podcast series examining the disputes and decisions making headlines across New Zealand.