“My thinking was influenced by Chanel Contos, an Australian advocate who has challenged the culture of boys’ schools and the responsibility of the adults who lead them.
“Her writing followed disturbing allegations of sexual offending involving young students at The Scots College in Sydney. Contos makes an important point: entitlement and empathy are socialised traits. In other words, they are things we learn, and adults can encourage either.
“When schools recruit a 14-year-old because he can play rugby, offer him a scholarship and treat him differently because of his sporting ability, what is he learning? He learns that talent brings special treatment.”
Christchurch Boys High School Headmaster Nic Hill. Photo / George Heard
Hill says his challenge to fellow headmasters has not yet been met.
“The South Island boys’ schools have not yet committed to the position I have advocated, and I am disappointed by that,” he said.
“I understand that each school has its own circumstances and history, and I do not want to speak for other headmasters. My argument remains that we have an opportunity to establish a clearer moral purpose around the culture of school sport, rather than simply asking what existing rules allow.”
As it stands, “what rules allow” is for new-to-school players (those who have represented other school rugby First XV teams before joining a competing school) to play immediately if their previous school agrees to a waiver. If they don’t agree, there is a stand-down period of six games.
Online critics and insiders within schoolboy rugby circles have singled out St Andrew’s College in Christchurch, a co-educational school and current national First XV champions, for the number of scholarships they are believed to have awarded.
St Andrew’s College, national First XV champions.
Hill would not be drawn to comment on St Andrew’s College, though he does suspect “some of the stories have become exaggerated”.
“The relationship between CBHS and St Andrew’s College is strong. My interest is less in prosecuting individual schools than in asking what all of us are contributing to through recruitment, money, status and the power we give school sport. School sport reveals school character.”
The Herald has approached St Andrew’s for comment.
Hill says he is “privileged to be at a school that has an identity and heritage that allows me to lead with moral purpose”. He also says that his own school “has also not always got everything right, historically”.
Christchurch Boys’ High School players celebrate during the 2025 First XV rugby match between Christ’s College and Christchurch Boys’ High School. Credit / Christchurch Boys’ High School media team
But their rules are hard and fast.
“Christchurch Boys’ High School does not offer sporting scholarships. Our sports policy expressly prohibits recruiting students on the basis of sporting ability.”
He accepts that students, or their parents, choose to move their boys to his school, provided it meets regulations.
“The distinction is between enrolment and recruitment. In terms of developing entitlement, a student choosing to attend a school is different from a school identifying a talented athlete and approaching or inducing him to transfer because of his sporting ability,” Hill said.
“If CBHS loses games because we choose not to recruit players or spend increasingly large sums trying to keep pace with other schools, I am comfortable with that. First XV rugby should matter, but it should not matter so much that adults lose sight of what schools exist to do.
“I also want them to learn that status brings responsibility rather than entitlement.”
Mike Thorpe is a senior multimedia journalist for the Herald, based in Christchurch. He has been a broadcast journalist across television and radio for 20 years and joined the Herald in August 2024.