She reiterated the Greens’ longstanding call for an independent department that would cost party policies – something both National and Labour Governments have come close to achieving in the past nine years, but have never quite got over the line.
The biggest bill goes to NZ First’s policy of making KiwiSaver compulsory, a policy the party announced at its party conference last year.
NZ First leader Winston Peters has promised to make KiwiSaver compulsory, with contributions from employers and employees initially rising to 8%, and eventually to 10%.
Peters has promised tax cuts for both workers and employers to offset the additional contributions, but the party has not published a detailed explanation of how those tax cuts would work or how much they would cost.
The Greens have used the Parliamentary Library’s tax calculator to model a 4.5 percentage point cut to all personal income tax rates to compensate workers for higher KiwiSaver contributions. This is the Greens’ assumption about how the policy might operate, rather than a tax-cut package published by NZ First.
The calculator reckoned the scheme would cost the Crown $16.7b in lost revenue a year, or $66.7b over the four-year forecast period. For perspective, the Government will spend about $22b on education this year.
Concerns about the cost of this policy were raised when it was announced. NZ First has consistently refused to put a figure on how much it costs. Other estimates have placed it even higher than the Greens’ estimate.
The next item on the Greens’ list is NZ First’s promise to lower the company tax rate for small-to-medium enterprises (SMEs). Under the policy, firms with turnover of less than $30 million would have their company tax rate cut from 28% to 20%.
NZ First costed this at $1b a year, which is the figure the Greens included in the plan, noting it would cost $4b over the four-year forecast period.
The next policy, a Kiwi Kids Grant, a payment designed to give New Zealand families an incentive to have children, was costed at $400m a year once fully rolled out over three years. The Greens have taken that and assumed a ramping up over the previous three years to calculate the total cost at $1.2b over four years.
The next policy was a National Subsurface Development Survey, which NZ First itself costed at $1b over the next term of Government.
NZ First has promised a $1000 KiwiSaver grant to New Zealand-born infants to kick-start their KiwiSaver accounts. The Greens estimated this to cost $232m over four years, calculated by multiplying the number of grants by the citizen birth rate.
The final two policies on the list include the cost of sharing half of the Crown’s mining royalties with the local authorities in which the mines are located. NZ First did not cost this itself, so the Greens used the most recent Crown royalty revenue figure and calculated that half of this would be lost under the policy, estimating a four-year cost of $286m.
NZ First’s Working for Families policy, which would make permanent the current $50-a-week boost and increase it by an extra $70 a week, was costed by the Greens at $2.2b over four years, which is the midpoint of the $500m–$600m annual cost NZ First estimated.
The costings do not include one of NZ First’s most expensive policies, renationalising the BNZ. The party has put the cost of that at $7.5b, although other estimates have put it as high as $24b.
NZ First proposes funding the purchase through borrowing and investment funds rather than the operating budget. It argues the purchase would be a one-off expansion of the Crown’s balance sheet, rather than an ongoing operating expense. The purchase price is therefore not directly comparable with the four-year operating costings of the party’s other policies.
“The Greens are currently past $281b for their promises, and in just one item in their 2026 tax policy they were $800m out – so why on earth would we, or you, listen to them on economic matters?” the NZ First spokesman said.
The Greens’ spending promises have so far stayed within the envelope of just over $30b of revenue raised by the party’s wealth tax. NZ First would not provide evidence for its $281b figure, although it appears to draw on a Taxpayers’ Union calculation which includes the cost of longstanding Green Party policy positions, which the party is not explicitly campaigning on this election.
The NZ First spokesman said “everything is wrong” with the Greens’ assessment of the party’s numbers, despite the fact that two-thirds of the costings came from NZ First’s own figures.
The party said it would pay for things “with real growth targets”.
“[B]ecause we will be spending on wealth creation, added value before exports, import substitution, and will have reorganised New Zealand’s debt – first public, which will then affect private debt – to be paying much lower interest rates than currently.
“Which means we will be on our way to doubling New Zealand’s economy by 2050, have abandoned the measly 1.7% growth rates per annum etc, and begin our long climb back up the OECD economic ladder.
“We are the only party with a real GDP growth strategy,” the party said, noting NZ First was in the Government during the Asian Financial Crisis.
Swarbrick reiterated that her preferred version of an independent costing unit would be a Parliamentary Budget Office, which Labour’s Grant Robertson and the Greens’ James Shaw came close to achieving in their first term in Government.
“This is why the Greens tried so hard to work with the National Party to get the independent Parliamentary Budget Office across the line before the election. Only our two parties’ votes were necessary,” Swarbrick said.
“While we’re now left with the legacy parties locked into a circular debate serving no one, parties like New Zealand First have made uncosted policies worth at least $72b, seemingly flying under the radar.
“Our democracy works better on transparency than on guesswork and allegations.
“It’s past time for a Parliamentary Budget Office that can run the ruler across every party’s promises, ours included, so debates compare apples with apples and assumptions are transparent.
“At the moment, New Zealanders have no independent, consistent way to check whether any party’s numbers stack up. That’s the point of the Budget Office,” she said.