In 1867, a tooth pulled from a cave in Torquay, England was logged as a badger’s. A later researcher said wolf. Both were wrong.

The object is actually a seal tooth pendant – crafted 15,000 years ago, worn smooth by years of use, and found far inland from any coast.


EarthSnap

A new study has finally identified it, and the answer raises harder questions than the mislabeling ever did.

Lost for a century

William Pengelly excavated the tooth from Kents Cavern – a cave system in Torquay, Devon – in 1867, during one of Britain’s earliest systematic cave excavations. The mislabeling stuck, and no one came back to check it.

The object spent most of the next century in the museum’s anthropology collection, largely unexamined.

Simon Parfitt – an archaeologist at University College London’s Institute of Archaeology and a scientific associate at the Natural History Museum – came across the tooth in 2012. He was building a major exhibition on British prehistory and recognized immediately that both previous identifications were wrong.

There was no time to resolve the mystery before the exhibit opened. The display case label simply read “carnivore tooth.” More than a decade later, the tooth was still waiting for the right answer.

Matched to a seal

Parfitt returned to the problem recently with Dr. Silvia Bello – a human evolution specialist at the Natural History Museum – and Dr. Claire Lucas, a University College London honorary lecturer specializing in prehistoric Europe.

They worked through every land animal known to have lived in the region. Nothing matched.

The team broadened its search to the museum’s marine mammal collection. The tooth was a premolar from a gray seal, and based on root shape and wear, it came from a male roughly 12 years old.

To confirm the identification without damaging the artifact, the team used high-powered microscopes, 3D scans, and internal CT imaging. The tooth was too fragile to sample directly for dating or genetic analysis.

Made to be worn

A premolar’s root sits deep in the jaw, anchored by bone. Extracting it required breaking open the jawbone – a heavy, deliberate act. Whether the seal died naturally or was hunted remains unknown.

Once the tooth was free, the maker thinned and smoothed the root, then drilled through it using a sharp flint point. The tool was rotated slowly and deliberately until it broke through the other side. A single wrong move could have split the root.

The finished pendant hung from a cord and swung freely. Over time, the circular hole became oval – one side thinner than the other, consistent with the tooth swinging in one direction. The entire surface carries a smooth patina from years of wear.

First seal tooth pendant

During the Ice Age, Kents Cavern sat roughly 78 miles (126 kilometers) from the nearest shoreline, which lay far to the southeast. Sea levels were much lower then, and the coast was a long journey away. Something carried this pendant inland.

Similar perforated seal tooth pendants have appeared at Pyrenean sites in France and Spain.

All belong to the Magdalenian people – a western European culture best known for the cave paintings at Lascaux and Altamira, active across the continent during the same period.

This pendant is the first of its kind ever found in the British Isles. Magdalenian communities in Britain shared ornament traditions with groups across the Channel, and marine objects reached them far from any coast.

Connected across Europe

Magdalenian people crossed from mainland Europe into Britain around 15,500 years ago via a land bridge now submerged beneath the North Sea, according to a study of ancient DNA from Ice Age British remains. They were far more mobile than earlier assumptions suggested.

Marine objects moved with them across the continent. Shells, shark teeth, and fossil mollusks from coastal sites regularly turn up hundreds of miles inland at Magdalenian camps. The seal tooth fits comfortably within that established pattern.

Bello commented on the pendant’s possible significance.

“This seal tooth pendant might have had some formal purpose – perhaps to show the social identity of the pendant’s owner. It could be an indication that the person, or group they were part of, was familiar with the sea and maybe used to live near the coast,” said Bello.

What we know now

This seal tooth pendant places Ice Age Britain inside a wider Magdalenian network reaching from Devon to the Pyrenees.

The traditional image of isolated cave dwellers does not hold. These were connected people, and archaeologists can now begin asking how far those connections actually ran.

Lab analysis of the tooth’s chemistry and DNA could eventually trace where the seal originated. A separate study on Magdalenian settlement timing in Britain suggests the population was small and highly mobile – which makes long-distance cultural connections like this one all the more striking.

“We don’t know if the person who carved it was also the one who wore it all the way to Kents Cavern and what story it may have held about their travels or connections,” said Lucas. Future chemical analysis and DNA testing may provide answers.

The study is published in the journal Quaternary Science Reviews.

—–

Like what you read? Subscribe to our newsletter for engaging articles, exclusive content, and the latest updates.

Check us out on EarthSnap, a free app brought to you by Eric Ralls and Earth.com.

—–