Key events
53rd over: New Zealand 235-3 (Nicholls 109, Mitchell 25) Josh Tongue returns at the end of a sweltering day and has his first ball clipped for three by Mitchell. England haven’t wilted physically, they’ve just been outplayed.
52nd over: New Zealand 230-3 (Nicholls 108, Mitchell 21) Mitchell flicks Brook just wide of Gay. Four more.
New Zealand lead by 330.
51st over: New Zealand 221-3 (Nicholls 105, Mitchell 15) Mitchell launches Fisher over long-on for a spectacular six, New Zealand’s first of the match.
50th over: New Zealand 209-3 (Nicholls 104, Mitchell 5) It’s time for Harry Brook wrong-foot swingers (great band, etc). Mitchell must be desperate to launch him towards Tooting Broadway – “eeeee’s crap!” – but for now he defends watchfully. A maiden.
49th over: New Zealand 209-3 (Nicholls 104, Mitchell 5) A maiden from Fisher to Nicholls. Just under half an hour still to play. England’s bowlers would love to be hitting an ice bath right now.
“Obviously Bairstow could never continue smashing a ton every innings but it can’t be a coincidence that he wasn’t keeping in 2022,” writes Max Williams. “I kinda view Foakes as a holding midfielder in a great attacking side – he rarely makes the headlines but he allows other players to excel, batters and bowlers. Take him out and the team is unbalanced – see the Galácticos era of Real Madrid.
“The Brook thing is such a paradox. During the 2022-23 New Zealand tour, England discovered a player with the potential to become one of their greatest ever batsmen—yet, in the short term, it probably weakened the team. 2022-23 England didn’t need Harry Brook. Indeed if he had made way for the returning Bairstow – never gonna happen – England would’ve been a more rounded team, if a marginally less exciting one.
“(But you know what’s exciting? Winning the Ashes because your keeper hasn’t dropped Usman Khawaja yet again.)”
My biggest frustration is the ludicrous declaration on day one of the Ashes. That was the only time Stokes got high on his own supply, and it probably cost them the first Test. That said, even though they didn’t win that series, I remember it with so much affection both as an England fan and a cricket fan. In my IMO, it’s easily the best England Test series since 2005.
48th over: New Zealand 209-3 (Nicholls 104, Mitchell 5) At some stage New Zealand will have to think about a declaration, especially as modern over-rates are so pathetic. Ideally they would want around 140 overs to bowl England out, and yes I did type that with a straight face.
England have been terrible at batting for a draw, as we know, but on paper this line-up is more suited to batting time. At some stage in his Test career Jacob Bethell is going to make a match-saving 24 not out from 240 balls. I doubt it’ll be this weekend, but who knows.
47th over: New Zealand 208-3 (Nicholls 103, Mitchell 5) A mouthwatering series decider begins at Trent Bridge next Thursday. Right now, there’s more chance of guessing tomorrow’s lottery numbers than predicting the England XI. But since you asked so obsequiously, I’ll guess Duckett, Gay, Bethell, Root, Brook, Smith, Stokes (c), Atkinson, Robinson, Tongue, Bashir. In other words, the same team that played at Lord’s before it all went eff-up.
Updated at 12.55 EDT
Henry Nicholls’ 11th Test century!
46th over: New Zealand 208-3 (Nicholls 103, Mitchell 5) That’ll do! Nicholls jumps on a long hop for Bethell, smashing it through midwicket for four to bring up a superb century from only 136 balls. One or two have flown off the glove but for the rest of the innings he has played with such control.
Oh, and the first person to say ‘Kane Who? gets a slap.
45th over: New Zealand 199-3 (Nicholls 98, Mitchell 1) The umpire Nitin Menon is having a word with Joe Root; I’m not sure what it’s about but Root’s face is a picture of weary disagreement. After three days, he looks like he’s had his fill of this nonsense.
Fisher replaces Baker and makes Nicholls wait for his century with an accurate maiden. No need for Nicholls to force it, he can just wait for a bad ball.
44th over: New Zealand 199-3 (Nicholls 98, Mitchell 1) Bethell is worked for a couple of singles. On a day when there is plenty of talk about England’s spin options, Nottinghamshire’s Liam Patterson-White has taken a cheap six-for to dismiss Essex for 184.
43rd over: New Zealand 197-3 (Nicholls 97, Mitchell 0) Nicholls tries to pull a skiddy bumper from Baker and gloves it down the leg side for four. He flat-bats the next ball whence it came for another boundary, though on that occasion Baker probably should have stopped it in his follow-through. Nicholls is three away from his 11th Test century.
42nd over: New Zealand 189-3 (Nicholls 89, Mitchell 0) “I really hope NZ play enough Tests for Rachin to have the chance to score 7000-8000 Test runs,” writes Abhishek Chopra. “He is such a charmer with the bat. And also, such a breath of fresh air because he neatly avoids the lazy elegance box as well as the stodgy accumulation box.”
Ravindra missed a sweep at a good delivery from Bethell that turned to hit the pad somewhere around off stump. There’s no doubt it would have hit gone on to hit the stumps, tut there was a chance Ravindra got outside the line and that’s why he reviewed.
It was close, closer than closer closer than ever can imag umpire’s call on impact, so the on-field decision was decisive. Ravindra’s innings was a gem: 76 from 99 balls with 15 pristine boundaries.
ShareWICKET! New Zealand 189-3 (Ravindra LBW b Bethell 76)
Jacob Bethell takes his fourth wicket of the match.
England wicketkeeper James Rew of England appeals for lbw against Rachin Ravindra … Photograph: Ashley Western/Colorsport/ShutterstockAnd up goes the umpire’s finger which means that Jacob Bethell can start celebrating. Photograph: Tom Jenkins/The GuardianShare
Updated at 13.16 EDT
41st over: New Zealand 186-2 (Nicholls 87, Ravindra 75) Nicholls knows that Baker is going to dig it in short, so he backs away to swat another boundary over the off side. Lovely stuff.
“I’m also with you on rather discussing Max Williams/your views than watching this Test run away from us,” writes Guy Hornsby. “I’m fast coming to the position where those first two years were an exhilarating ride which I will always remember with pure happiness before the shortcomings of the McCullum regime began to fray with newer picks. It feels like we’re at the embers of this regime. And while the fallout may be brutal, I will always love what it gave us in those magical months.”
England, boring old England, had the most exciting batting line-up in the entire bloody history of Test cricket. That’s cold, hard, statistical fact. I suspect history will be a lot kinder to them than the present.
Updated at 12.34 EDT
40th over: New Zealand 180-2 (Nicholls 82, Ravindra 74) A delivery from Bethell bounces grotesquely at Nicholls, who fends it to safety on the leg side. Yikes.
“Easy to be wise after the event (although in fairness, I was saying this before the game!) but I’d have played Rehan ahead of Cox here,” writes Phil Harrison. “I guess his time will come but I think they’re underusing him slightly. I know everyone says he needs to establish himself as a batting allrounder. But he has 22 Test wickets at 31 which ain’t bad. They’d love a bit of him right now…”
Rehan at No7, with this particular bowling line-up, would have been way too long a tail I think. And those 22 wickets at 31 were all taken overseas. I do really like Rehan, I’m just not sure of his role (yet) and I think batting him at No7 in this particular team would be too risky. Then again, they’re going to lose anyway so what’s the worst that could have happened.
I guess the broader point is that, in the absence of Stokes, there’s no way of picking a balanced XI.
39th over: New Zealand 175-2 (Nicholls 79, Ravindra 72) Baker replaces Tongue and charges into Ravindra, who nails a pull round the corner. That’s Ravindra’s 15th four in a score of just 71.
New Zealand lead by 275 and it’s increasingly to see how England can win this game. On the plus side, after all the criticism of England’s fly-by-night batting, it’d be a helluva PR gesture if they bat 150 overs to a Test.
38th over: New Zealand 169-2 (Nicholls 78, Ravindra 67) Jacob Bethell is coming into the attack, although maybe ‘into the defence’ would be a better description given the balance of play.
Root spots Emilio Gay running towards the wrong fielding position and shouts angrily at him. That’s seriously out of character, and the chances of Root captaining England through to the Ashes – which was mooted before this game – are dwindling by the minute. He doesn’t need this flip.
Oh dear, that won’t improve Root’s humour. Ravindra inside-edged a defensive stroke off Bethell, with the looping up on the leg side. Gay, at short leg, tried to take a diving catch with one hand rather than two and failed to get anything on it. Tough chance, but a chance nonetheless.
37th over: New Zealand 168-2 (Nicholls 77, Ravindra 67) Tongue’s first ball is too short and waved for four by Ravindra. He ends the over with another boundary, pulling round the corner with superb placement.
Ravindra’s innings has felt routine, partly because he makes batting look so easy, but this has been a demonstration of character as well as style. Ravindra had a hideous game at Lord’s, then gave his wicket away in the first innings, so there was plenty of pressure when he came to the crease.
36th over: New Zealand 157-2 (Nicholls 75, Ravindra 58) Nicholas charges Root and lifts four more down the ground. England look flat and are missing Ben Stokes both as captain and bowler. This situation is perfect for one of Stokes’ mammoth spells.
35th over: New Zealand 151-2 (Nicholls 70, Ravindra 57) A lifter from Tongue hits Nicholls on the glove, prompting a break in play while he receives treatment. He’s fine.
“That 2022 summer really was an astonishing time, wasn’t it?” writes Max Williams. “Ever-escalating run-chases reeled off with ever-increasing ease. I’ll go to my grave insisting England win the 2023 Ashes – comfortably – if they pick Ben Foakes but I understand their determination to get in Jonny Bairstow after his miracles the year before.
“It’s funny that Stuart Broad is the only player from those 2022 Bazball series to have retired – yet Root and Stokes are the only survivors. Individually the batting lineup looks stronger (at least when everyone’s available), but as a collective it feels more fragile somehow. Maybe it’s a case of higher ceiling, lower floor.
“I know it’s important to evolve but England had something very special that 2022 summer, and they’ve lost it somewhere along the way these last couple of years. On a prosaic level, you point to the bowling attack, the absence of Broad, Anderson, Woakes and Wood. But it’s deeper than that. Spiritually, it just doesn’t seem fun anymore.
“I guess transforming the mindset of a beleaguered Test team reeling from record defeats and Covid restrictions is a bit like being 21. It’s fragile, it’s brief, it’s brilliant, and you only get to do it once.”
So many good points in there, and I wish we could just talk about them for the next two hours rather than watch New Zealand apply their foot to England’s throat.
I’m also fascinated by a parallel universe in which Jonny Bairstow doesn’t suffer that horrific leg-break. His batting in 2022 is the best I’ve ever seen from an England player in a single season. He was never quite the same, though he did panel 99 against Australia in 2023 and there’s a decent argument that England drew a line through his name prematurely. The injury also affected his keeping in the Ashes, as you referenced with the mention of Ben Foakes. Against that, Bairstow’s injury led to the introduciton of Harry Brook. Clearly Brook would have made it; I’m just not sure when a vacancy would have opened up.
34th over: New Zealand 147-2 (Nicholls 70, Ravindra 57) Root bowls a wider delivery to Ravindra that turns straight to first slip. There was always a chance this would happen, that we’d be lamenting the absence of Shoaib Bashir, but in the absence of Ben Stokes it was impossible for England to pick a balanced XI.
Updated at 11.45 EDT
33rd over: New Zealand 146-2 (Nicholls 69, Ravindra 57) Ravindra greets the new bowler Josh Tongue with a delicious extra-cover drive for four. I bet Phil Walker’s knees are chattering like comedy dentures after that stroke; he’s Ravindra’s No1 fan.
It’s the first of three boundaries in the over. A square drive takes Ravindra to a charming fifty from 79 balls; he celebrates by stiffening the wrists to work Tongue through midwicket for four more.
New Zealand are taking this game away from England in a hurry. Since tea they’ve scored 52 in eight overs.
32nd over: New Zealand 134-2 (Nicholls 69, Ravindra 45) Joe Root comes on for a quick over, and why not.
31st over: New Zealand 130-2 (Nicholls 66, Ravindra 44) Archer is steaming in, trying to force the wicket England desperately need. Nicholls turns him this far short of Emilio Gay at leg slip; it was so close that the crowd cheered a wicket before Gay’s body language harshed their buzz.
“Ah, Fourth-Innings Miracles (3.47pm),” chirps Matt Dony. “The cult jangle-pop 1980’s band from Derby. Never achieved commercial success, but their second album (Sharp But Wicketless) still appears on greatest album lists.”
Have you been listening to Lowgold again, Matthew? If not, you should – in an admittedly niche field, their debut is the finest album with a cricket-themed title ever released.
30th over: New Zealand 128-2 (Nicholls 65, Ravindra 43) Nicholls threads a beautiful drive for four off Fisher, perfectly placed between mid-off and extra cover. It was such a high-class shot that I assumed it was played by Ravindra.
That boundary brings up a quietly dominant hundred partnership, which has come in less than 22 overs. England need a wicket urgently or they can probably forget it.
29th over: New Zealand 124-2 (Nicholls 61, Ravindra 43) Four more to Nicholls, who has equalled his highest score in a Test away to any of the big three. The financial big three, that is.
28th over: New Zealand 119-2 (Nicholls 56, Ravindra 43) Nicholls square-drives Fisher for four to reach a 72-ball half-century. It’s been a really good innings, a study in how to minimise risk and still have a strike rate of 70-odd.
A deliberate steer past the keeper gives Nicholls another boundary, and Ravindra repeats the stroke later in the over. Thirteen from the over. New Zealand lead by 219 and England are approaching the point of no return.
27th over: New Zealand 106-2 (Nicholls 47, Ravindra 39) Nicholls tries to pull Archer, is beaten for pace and gloves the ball down the leg side for four. Rew leapt to his right but I don’t think he got a touch on it. He may have dived past the ball.
Ravindra shows how it should be done with an emphatic pull stroke between midwicket and mid-on. That’s Ravindra’s eighth four in a score of 39; I’d need to check but I think he’s scored roughly 82.05% of his runs in boundaries.
26th over: New Zealand 97-2 (Nicholls 42, Ravindra 35) Matt Fisher starts after tea with the keeper up to the stumps. Nicholls moves into the forties with a nice square drive for three, then Ravindra chases a very wide delivery and is beaten. Poor shot, that.
Ben Stokes and Gus Atkinson are in action for their counties today. Stokes has bowled 11 sharp but wicketless overs against Northants; Atkinson has figures of 15-7-33-2 against Glamorgan.
England’s performance has been quite good, but they’re still playing catch-up after a miserable day two. They’re not out of this game, not with their record of fourth-innings miracles, but they could be by the close of play.
ShareTea
25th over: New Zealand 94-2 (Nicholls 39, Ravindra 35) Glorious shot from Ravindra, a back-foot drive through extra cover off Baker that races away for four. He follows that with an immaculate forward defensive off the last ball of the afternoon session. New Zealand lead by 194.
Updated at 11.07 EDT
24th over: New Zealand 90-2 (Nicholls 39, Ravindra 31) Archer returns just before tea. He starts with a couple of bumpers to Nicholls, then explores a more orthodox length. After five dot balls, Nicholls plays a lovely back-foot punch to the pont boundary. He doesn’t have a great record in England – six Tests, average 26 – but he’s playing really nicely here.
23rd over: New Zealand 86-2 (Nicholls 35, Ravindra 31) Ravindra cuts Baker into the ground with such timing that the ball bursts through the hands of Gay in the covers and runs all the way for four. Jordan Cox tries to save the boundary, slips and hurts his knee. He’s wincing but is still on the field.
Updated at 10.36 EDT
England have won Tests from this sort of position under Brendon McCullum, even if most of the current XI weren’t involved. At Edgbaston in 2022, for example, India were effectively 285 for 3 in their second innings yet England won by seven wickets. They don’t get enough credit for what was a pretty astonishing victory. They could have chased 500+, mainly because Jonny Bairstow was enjoying the purplest patch of any England batter in my lifetime.
Updated at 10.34 EDT
22nd over: New Zealand 81-2 (Nicholls 34, Ravindra 27) Nicholls brings up an excelent fifty partnership with back-to-back boundaries off Root, a graceful chip down the ground and a wave past mid-off. Lovely stuff.
21st over: New Zealand 72-2 (Nicholls 25, Ravindra 27) Thanks Jim, hello everyone. Sonny Baker switches ends and tests Ravindra’s patience angles a series of rapid deliveries across him. Ravindra ignores the majority of them. Even his leaves are elegant!
Share
James Wallace
20th over: New Zealand 72-2 (Nicholls 27, Ravindra 25) Ravindra and Nicholls do not want Root to settle into a spell, they are looking to be aggressive, knock him out of the attack so England have to rotate their seamers in the mid-afternoon heat. Nicholls prods forward and a teensy inside edge saves him from being trapped lbw! Root whistles through his over, just a single off it.
Rob Smyth scooches his way into the OBO deckchair for the rest of the day, zinc smeared in a thick tramline across his nose. My time here is done. Thanks for your company.
Updated at 10.21 EDT