Image: BULE, via Pexels

“Growing evidence” of unethical submissions to publishing rewards programme has sparked action

South Africa’s higher education department says it is clamping down on attempts to “game” the country’s research publication subsidy, claiming recently released data from 2024 continues to show evidence of unethical conduct.

The message comes in the Department of Higher Education and Training’s Sector Report on the Evaluation of the 2024 Universities’ Research Outputs, which was shared with the country’s public universities last month but has yet to be posted on DHET’s website.

It details how DHET’s publication subsidy—a financial reward for approved research outputs including books, conference proceedings and research articles in vetted journals—was allocated between 26 public universities based on data supplied in the 2024 calendar year.

‘Greater gaming’

The numbers show a continued increase in research publication outputs, which are quantified by ‘units’ for the purposes of the subsidy. Units are calculated by a formula that looks at relative authorship, with single-author papers counting as one unit, for instance, while a part in a multi-author paper contributes a fractional score.

The total number of approved subsidy units in 2024 topped 25,982, a 9.27 per cent increase over the previous year, continuing a trend that has been around since the system was introduced in 2005, the report says.

However, the authors note, this increase is not necessarily good. “There is increasing evidence that the pursuit of quantity is occurring alongside greater gaming of the system, as well as increased publication in lower-quality journals that promise quick turnaround for manuscripts,” the report states.

Closer scrutiny

The department says it is working on addressing the problem, including through a Publication Quality Framework Programme (PQFP), led by researchers at the Centre for Research on Evaluation, Science and Technology at Stellenbosch University.

This programme will investigate unethical publication practices and operate as a national collaborative initiative supported by funding from DHET, the report says. Such oversight should act as a complement, not replace institutions’ own efforts to address unethical submissions, it adds.

The report says DHET has engaged with universities whose submissions were seen as problematic in the 2024 submission round, and notes that it has the power to withdraw submissions that are found to be problematic.

Funding ‘paradox’

The University of Johannesburg claims the most publication units, with 13.52 per cent of the total, followed by the University of South Africa at 10.04 per cent.

Universities that usually top global university rankings in South Africa have fewer units. The University of Cape Town and the University of the Witwatersand received 5.93 per cent and 7.72 per cent of units, respectively.

UCT’s share of units declined compared to the previous year. UCT told Research Professional News this is partly due to a “paradox” in the funding model, which gives fewer subsidy units per institutions for prestigious international collaborative publications than for single-authored or locally-authored publications.   

“The very international collaborations that enhance UCT’s global reputation, research impact and contribution to knowledge can reduce the number of subsidy units attributed to the university,” the university said, adding that it encourages researchers to focus on quality over quantity.

Widening inequality

The report identifies another issue with the subsidy, which is that publication units remain concentrated in a handful of institutions despite efforts to boost research activity in lower-performing institutions.

Three-quarters of the research publication output units were produced by only nine universities, the report says. And the gap in outputs between the top 10 and the bottom 10 is widening, the report states. “This should be of concern if the policy has explicitly intended to contribute to a more equitable higher education system in knowledge production,” it says.

The report calls the creation of a more unequal public university system an “unintended consequence” of the country’s research outputs policy, which dates from 2015. “This is an issue which is currently being addressed by the PQFP and will most likely result in recommendations to the current policy,” it says.