Ireland were made to pay for a litany of first half errors as they fell to a 40-21 defeat to New Zealand, signing off the season with a disappointing performance in Auckland.

Andy Farrell’s side came with belief they could break the All Blacks’ famous 32-year unbeaten record at Eden Park, but they never came close as Dave Rennie’s side made it 53 games without defeat at their great fortress.

Most frustratingly, the home side only had to be good – but not great – in their 19-point win. They were the better team from start to finish and played simple and effective rugby, but were clinical in preying on a dreadfully sloppy Irish attack.

In terms of general gameplay, this was a relatively even contest, but the difference was in the ball skills. The All Blacks looked after the ball as they moved through the hands, while Ireland were careless in possession right from the start, and handed the hosts multiple tries in the opening half through knock-ons and dropped balls.

The game was over by half-time, New Zealand running into a 28-7 lead through Patrick Tupuloutu, Ardie Savea, Will Jordan and Asafo Aumua’s tries, with Jack Conan scoring the Irish try which briefly got them back to 14-7.

Ireland’s try came while New Zealand were down to 14 players after Luke Jacobson was shown a yellow card for a dangerous head-high shot on Josh van der Flier, and while the All Black was very fortunate to escape a 20-minute red, it would be unfair to say it had a great impact on the game.

18 July 2026; Joe McCarthy of Ireland is tackled by Ardie Savea of New Zealand during the 2026 Nations Championship Round 3 match between New Zealand and Ireland at Eden Park in Auckland, New Zealand. Photo by Brendan Moran/Sportsfile

Ireland improved in the second half, with tries for Joe McCarthy (above) and Hugo Keenan, but the damage was done by that stage, and each time they scored their hosts had a response, Damian McKenzie and Anton Lienert-Brown rounding off the scoring to send Ireland back home from their three-game tour with plenty to think about.

It was an error-ridden start from Ireland, with two from Garry Ringrose inside the opening five minutes; the centre first knocked on a ball from a setplay move, before he was held up in a choke tackle two minutes later.

New Zealand looked sharp on their opening attack, with Damian McKenzie roaming the backfield and picking his running lines, and Rob Baloucoune saved Ireland early with a great covering tackle on the All Blacks full-back.

A jackal penalty from Dan Sheehan gave Ireland another chance to attack on 10 minutes, but once again some good early phases were wasted when James Ryan dropped a simple pass.

18 July 2026; Players including Dan Sheehan of Ireland tussle during the 2026 Nations Championship Round 3 match between New Zealand and Ireland at Eden Park in Auckland, New Zealand. Photo by Brendan Moran/Sportsfile

By contrast, New Zealand’s handling and attack looked precise and crisp, and on 13 minutes they went from touchline to touchline with Jordan and then Tupou Vaa’i to break into the Irish 22, before taking Ireland on up the middle, with Stuart McCloskey and Tom O’Toole leaving a huge gap for Tuipulotu to break into, as he barged over for the opening try.

Another Ireland attack ended in frustration as Tadhg Beirne offloaded forward to Joe McCarthy, before Jamison Gibson-Park gave away a cheap penalty for a shove on Love and then another penalty allowed New Zealand take a scrum, from which Savea took the direct route, breaking and running straight through O’Brien and Gibson-Park for a second All Blacks try and a 14-0 lead, with 22 minutes played.

Five minutes later the home side were back on the attack, but Jacobson’s vicious head shot on Van der Flier allowed Ireland to escape their 22 with a penalty, with the sin-bin giving them a man advantage for the next 10 minutes.

They did initially make that advantage count, with another penalty allowing them into New Zealand’s 22. Going off the top from the lineout, McCloskey, Conan and Beirne all carried hard to the line, before they came back inside for another Conan carry, which saw the number 8 barge over for a try, converted by Prendergast to make it 14-7.

However, within a few seconds of the restart, New Zealand’s 14-point buffer was restored, as another moment of calamitous Irish passing saw McCloskey pull a blind pass into empty space in his own 22, and Jordan happily running onto the loose ball for a third New Zealand try.

18 July 2026; Sam Prendergast of Ireland during the 2026 Nations Championship Round 3 match between New Zealand and Ireland at Eden Park in Auckland, New Zealand. Photo by Brendan Moran/Sportsfile
Sam Prendergast sizes up his options

Three minutes before half-time, the home side pulled further clear, and again it stemmed from an Irish mistake; Baloucoune losing the ball in contact before Love drilled a 50:22 to put his side on the attack, and eventually Aumua forced his way over, as Love’s fourth conversion made it 28-7 for the break.

Ireland started the second half desperate to change the scoreboard fast, as Gibson-Park and Beirne put some pace on their attack, before a penalty in the New Zealand 22 allowed them go to the lineout, and after camping on the All Blacks’ line they got in for an early try, McCarthy squeezing in under the posts, as Prendergast’s conversion cut the deficit to 28-14.

It didn’t spark the epic comeback, as New Zealand quickly went back on the attack, with a Jordie Barrett 50:22 getting them into striking range, and while Beirne and Hugo Keenan both came up with vital tackles, it proved in vain as McKenzie eventually crossed for the fifth All Blacks try, pushing them into a 35-14 lead.

The game was becoming incredibly loose, particularly with a flurry of substitutions on both sides, and Ireland got in for their third try on 62 minutes after two excellent contributions from Prendergast.

First, the out-half drilled a penalty from the halfway line deep into the New Zealand 22, before floating a pass out to Keenan on the left wing as he ran in to score, and he then landed a conversion from the left wing to make it a 14-point game, and put Ireland within reach of a bonus-point.

Both sides had further chances to score across the next 10 minutes, Lienert-Brown breaking into the Irish 22 only for the All Blacks to concede a penalty, before the same happened Ireland when Ciarán Frawley was caught holding on after he connected with a Prendergast crossfield kick.

A try for Ireland could have been crucial, with two bonus points available, but in the end they would leave with none as Lienert-Brown’s try with two minutes left capped off a dominant New Zealand victory, and delivered his side a fourth win in a row in this fixture.

Scorers

New Zealand: Tries: Patrick Tupuloutu, Ardie Savea, Will Jordan, Asafo Aumua, Damian McKenzie, Anton Lienert-Brown

Cons: Ruben Love (5)

Ireland: Tries: Jack Conan, Joe McCarthy, Hugo Keenan

Cons: Sam Prendergast (3)

New Zealand: Damian McKenzie; Will Jordan, Quinn Tupaea, Jordie Barrett, Josh Moorby; Ruben Love, Cam Roigard; Ethan de Groot, Codie Taylor, Tyrel Lomax; Josh Lord, Patrick Tuipulotu; Tupou Vaa’i, Luke Jacobson, Ardie Savea (capt)

Replacements: Asafo Aumua (for Taylor, 31), Xavier Numia (for De Groot 49), Fletcher Newell (for Lomax, 4-14 HIA, and 56), Anton Segner (for Tuipulotu, 58), Peter Lakai (for Jacobson, 72), Cortez Ratima (for Roigard, 72), Anton Lienert-Brown (for Tupaea, 67), Caleb Clarke (for Love, 56).

Ireland: Hugo Keenan; Rob Baloucoune, Garry Ringrose, Stuart McCloskey, Jimmy O’Brien; Sam Prendergast, Jamison Gibson-Park; Tom O’Toole, Dan Sheehan (capt), Tadhg Furlong; Joe McCarthy, James Ryan; Tadhg Beirne, Josh van der Flier, Jack Conan.

Replacements: Rónan Kelleher (for Sheehan, 67), Jeremy Loughman (for O’Toole, 67), Thomas Clarkson (for Furlong, 59), Nick Timoney (for Van der Flier, 56), Sean Jansen (for Ryan, 58), Craig Casey (for Gibson-Park, 75), Ciarán Frawley (for O’Brien, 12-21 HIA, and 56), Bundee Aki (for Frawley, 19-21 and for McCloskey, 60).

Referee: Nic Berry (Australia)