She attributed it to her taking on “too much work” and said that was something she “should not have done”.
During the hearing, her lawyer, Karen Feint, KC, said the tribunal was required to impose the least restrictive outcome and the Standards Committee’s approach was “overly punitive”.
The senior lawyer had been found guilty of misconduct and unsatisfactory conduct, relating to her holding herself out as the director of her firm, despite undertakings to the Law Society that she would practise only as an employed lawyer.
She then failed to supervise her junior staff, treating them in an “appalling” way at times.
Her management led five of her juniors to quit on the same day after being required to work long hours, complete tasks outside their level of experience, and being criticised and questioned when they took sick leave.
The lawyer pleaded guilty to a charge of misconduct relating to another client where she failed to refer them for independent advice.
Feint submitted that the tribunal had not made any findings of “dishonesty, fraud or lack of trustworthiness” and that to be at the high end of the misconduct spectrum, one or more of those would usually be present.
But the tribunal found that a charge didn’t have to involve dishonesty to be considered at the serious end of the spectrum, and factors including the effects on the court, clients and staff, as well as how deliberate and long-standing the conduct was, could all be taken into account.
‘Thumbing her nose’
Aspects of the conduct were also considered “deliberately deceptive”.
“We noted that the manner in which [the lawyer] ran her firm and held herself out to the public as being in charge, was certainly less than scrupulously honest,” the decision said.
“We referred to this conduct as ‘window dressing’ and ‘thumbing her nose’ at her professional body.”
The tribunal considered the conduct could be described as “serious”.
As an aggravating factor, the tribunal noted the lawyer had previously appeared before it, although details cannot be reported because of ongoing suppression orders.
The tribunal noted features of the previous misconduct were similar to the current matter, in terms of non-compliance with a Standards Committee order, and this went towards considering her fitness to practise.
The tribunal considered the biggest mitigating factor was the way her practice was now run, having appeared to have “changed for the better”.
The lawyer had loyal clients and three senior staff members, as well as a former employee, give evidence in the liability hearing.
“All of whom deposed to a positive experience working in the firm under [the lawyer’s] guidance,” the decision said.
“There have been no further client complaints against the firm, and we are not aware of any recent adverse judicial comment such as have occurred in the past.”
However, in considering her overall conduct, particularly with respect to costs, the tribunal noted “repeated non-compliance with timetable orders”.
The lawyer had made “requests for extensions and adjournments, including an application for stay” and the tribunal considered this could be seen as “lacking respect for, or prioritisation of, disciplinary proceedings and directions”.
“Failure to manage deadlines has been a recurring theme both within the charges and the management of these proceedings generally,” the decision said, adding this pointed to a risk of “repeat offending”.
Overall, the tribunal found a moderate period of suspension was the “minimum proportionate disciplinary response”, carrying not only the “condemnation of the tribunal” but also allowing “a period of reflection and reset”.
It said the lawyer would also face “very considerable costs because of the protracted nature of the hearing and the number of witnesses called by both sides”.
Throughout these proceedings and the numerous interlocutory applications made, and in pre-hearing conferences, the lawyer “was warned that the steps she was taking could ultimately result in significant costs awards against her”.
The tribunal ordered the lawyer to pay 80% of the Standards Committee’s final legal costs, which it submitted were about $185,000.
The final costs would be set out in an invoice to be submitted to the tribunal.
She was also ordered to pay $94,531.50 to reimburse tribunal costs, bringing the financial orders listed to more than $242,000.
The senior lawyer was also ordered to pay costs awarded against her clients in other court proceedings that formed the basis of one of the misconduct charges, if she had not already done so.
She was suspended from practice for four months commencing on November 12, censured, and would need supervision for 12 months after returning to practice.
Another lawyer who was charged in the proceedings and found guilty of unsatisfactory conduct was also censured.
The tribunal considered he acted with “lack of independence and naivety in relying on [information provided by the senior lawyer]”.
He briefly took a directorship role to assist the lawyer while she was forbidden to practise on her own account, and had been “well motivated”.
The tribunal said the man had health challenges, was not in a position to pay a fine, and considered a censure the appropriate penalty.
Hannah Bartlett is a Tauranga-based Open Justice reporter at NZME. She previously covered court and local government for the Nelson Mail, and before that was a radio reporter at Newstalk ZB.
Join the NZ Herald’s Open Justice team for Case by Case, a video and podcast series examining the disputes and decisions making headlines across New Zealand.