Summary

Declines in smoking prevalence in Aotearoa New Zealand(NZ) have occurred alongside denormalisation strategies that challenged smoking’s status as an accepted social practice. However, popular culture and social media depictions of smoking suggest it may be undergoing a renormalisation. 

Given young people today have little direct experience of the campaigns that transformed smoking from a desirable to a socially undesirable practice, we urgently need more youth-oriented campaigns alongside stronger regulation of social media and on-going monitoring of smoking prevalence data.

Smoking’s re-emergence 

Smoking’s rising presence in pop culture is evident in fashion imagery, music videos and social media, where historic connotations of sophistication, rebellion and self-confidence have re-emerged. Media stories have described a new smoking aesthetic among young people who, faced with climate change, rising unemployment, cost of living problems and little hope of immediate improvement, may look to the past for hope and glamour not offered by an increasingly dismal present.

Young people today have a different experience of smoking from previous generations, given they have not witnessed the change in smoking’s social standing.1 Most were children when campaigns such as “Smoking not our future” ran nearly two decades ago. Featuring unscripted comments from musicians, sportspeople and actors, the influencers of the pre-social-media era, the campaign positioned being smokefree as the new cool status.2

Image from the Smoking, not our future campaign. Photo credit: Neil Pardington Design.

The failure to continue social marketing campaigns that reinforced being smokefree as aspirational and socially attractive has created opportunities for smoking to regain its former appeal. Although smoking became less visible in traditional media, social media depictions present it as appealing, glamorous and rebellious, attributes far removed from the reality of cravings, addiction and loss of control.

Social media and celebrities, including people from NZ, have extended and reinforced that positioning. Images of Taika Waititi’s 50th birthday featured cigarette trays (a far cry from his role in the Smoking not our future campaign), Lorde smoked on stage, and other celebrities are shown smoking in social media. Instagram accounts like cigfluencers romanticise smoking, evoke nostalgia and create an appeal unchallenged by youth-oriented denormalisation campaigns.3-5

From smoking denormalisation to renormalisation?

Thirty years ago, around a quarter of the NZ population smoked daily;6 smoking was still normative as measures ending advertising and sponsorship had only just come into effect and many workplaces, bars and restaurants still allowed smoking. Tobacco companies’ brand imagery continued to deflect attention from the harms smoking imposes and their skill in taking a fundamentally generic product – a small cylinder containing shredded tobacco – and creating iconic brands continued to persuade many young people to begin smoking.7,8

Over time, the tobacco industry’s efforts to create doubt about smoking’s health effects failed. Marlboro men died of lung cancer, people harmed by smoking told their stories to prevent others from suffering, youth role models rejected smoking and courts accepted arguments that tobacco companies had lied and deceived the public.9,10 Confronting social marketing campaigns systematically dismantled smoking’s glamorous allure and brand imagery gave way to standardised packaging and graphic warnings.11-13

Tobacco products became less visible as the “powerwalls” that once featured behind every dairy counter were dismantled and closed cabinets replaced the display stands that once occupied the most visually powerful place in a store.14 The tobacco industry’s ability to present smoking as a socially accepted and desirable practice weakened,1and smoking prevalence declined to historically low levels among young people.15

However, although young people have not seen the marketing that promoted smoking, neither have they seen denormalisation campaigns. As knowledge of how smoking lost its social acceptability becomes less familiar, social media has created new opportunities to restore smoking’s cachet.

How can we address the historical amnesia about smoking?

We need to fill the void left after campaigns such as “Smoking not our future” concluded by developing youth-led campaigns, such as those created by the US Truth Initiative, which expose tobacco companies’ cynical targeting of young people.16 Truth Initiative campaigns have also reminded celebrities featured smoking in social media as “Unpaid tobacco company spokespeople” that their actions shape the beliefs and behaviours of young people. We also need to unravel the links between tobacco companies and social media promotions of smoking, given history shows these connections do not occur by chance. Finally, we should refresh on-pack warning labels; ensuring some warning themes (eg, impact on others or addiction) resonate with young people could reduce experimentation.17,18

We must also monitor smoking experimentation and irregular smoking patterns, such as “social” smoking.19 NZ Health Survey data indicate that daily and current (at least monthly) smoking among 15 to 17-year-olds and 18 to 24-year-olds have not increased. However, monitoring current smoking is crucial as this measure may be the first to indicate increases in social smoking, which typically leads quickly to daily smoking.20,21

While marketing restrictions decreased smoking’s visibility in traditional media, social media has created new opportunities to restore smoking’s cultural appeal. Policy measures may also need to address influencer marketing, undisclosed commercial relationships and the algorithmic amplification of smoking imagery to young people.

Denormalising smoking greatly reduced its appeal to young people, but campaigns run nearly two decades ago have lost salience. Ensuring smoking prevalence remains low among young people requires new strategies that challenge efforts to renew smoking’s cultural appeal and ensure it does not become renormalised among young people. 

What this Briefing adds

The emergence of aspirational smoking imagery in popular culture and social media poses a potential threat to health campaigns that denormalised smoking.Campaigns designed to reduce smoking’s appeal to young people have not run for several years, leaving young people unexposed to messages that challenge smoking’s social acceptability.Monitoring current smoking among young people has become more important as it may signal rising smoking uptake even if daily smoking prevalence remains stable.Implications for policy and practiceYouth-focused health promotion campaigns should be developed to challenge smoking’s rising normativity, reinforce being smokefree as aspirational, and expose the tobacco industry’s long history of deceit.Smokefree campaigns need a strong online presence and should consider international approaches, which question celebrities who promote smoking and document connections between tobacco companies and influencers.Further thought could be given to social media regulation, particularly influencer marketing and algorithmic amplification of imagery featuring smoking.Increase surveillance of current smoking among young people to monitor any changes and ensure these do not translate into increases in daily smoking.Authors’ details

Professor Janet Hoek, Co-Director of ASPIRE Aotearoa Research Centre, and Department of Public Health, Ōtākou Whakaihu Waka | University of Otago

Dr Lori Leigh, ASPIRE Aotearoa Research Centre, and the Department of Public Health, Ōtākou Whakaihu Waka Pōneke | University of Otago, Wellington