Loneliness and isolation among older Americans have mostly returned to pre-pandemic rates. That means more than one third of people age 50 to 80 years old, still feel lonely and isolated ( JAMA 2024).

While research suggests that loneliness impacts physical and mental health, loneliness is a yearning for connection and belonging that people may be able to address in unexpected ways. One way is to draw upon the power of music.

Elvers ( 2016) considers that private music listening may bring us to the presence of others. “ Listeners subconsciously perceive music as the emotional expression of an imagined individual.”

What happens when you listen to the song that was playing when you met your partner for the first time?
Does the music of the band you traveled miles to see with too many people in the van, bring you back to those friends?
Have you ever had the privilege of seeing barely responsive seniors in a Nursing Home, light up to sing every word with a Frank Sinatra look-alike?

Music as a Social Surrogate

Ceren, Geibel, Kussner et.al. 2025 studied music as a social surrogate to alleviate loneliness in older adults. The social surrogacy hypothesis predicts that people can make use of temporary substitutes for interaction with other people.

In a qualitative study, they explored the role of self-chosen music as a social surrogate. A sample of older adults (N = 35) was asked to name three pieces of music that would choose to make them feel better if they were feeling very lonely and to explain their choices.

From the responses, the researchers identified seven factors underlying individuals’ social motives for listening to music: Comforting Company, Reminiscence, Shared experiences, Isolation, Understanding others, Culture, and Group identity.

Music as A Social Surrogate in the Face of Painful Events

In another study researchers, Schafer, Saarikallia and Eerola, 2020 sought to find out if comforting music would be chosen as a social surrogate in the face of serious personal injury like the loss of sight or loss of a loved one.

They hypothesized that comforting music would reduce loneliness and heighten empathy.

To test these assumptions, sadness was induced by an approved guided imagery method for which participants visualized either their father dying (social loss), or losing their eyesight (non-social loss), or shopping for groceries (control condition). After the mood induction, the listening task included choosing either comforting music or self-selected music

The results showed a significant reduction of loneliness and a relevant rise in empathy and mood due to listening to the “self-selected music”. It is interesting that the music chosen was not particularly “comforting” but rather the personal choice of the listener. This suggests the importance and emotional significance of our private musical choices in the service of mood repair and in fostering the use of music as a social surrogate.

In his book Your Brain on Music, Daniel j. Levitin unlocks the way in which music stimulates our brains.

According to Levitan:

Music activates the same neural circuits responsible for the pleasure we derive from eating, intimacy, and social participation. The result is a release of dopamine and other mood-enhancing chemicals which amplify the impact of the music.
Particularly important is the fact that the cerebellum, one of the oldest parts of the brain, gets activated when we listen to music but not when we listen to noise! The cerebellum is the part of our brain that “ tracks the beat.” It becomes activated when people listen to music they like. It is related to our gait and certainly to our dance steps.
Moving to music even in a seated position is a brain and body activity.
Further study reveals that the cerebellum contains many connections to the emotional centers of the brain. Music lights us up “only when we like it” and can bring us to tears – because we love it!

Relative to the importance of a person’s personal choice of music as a social surrogate, is Levitin’s explanation that In Western Culture, choice of music has Important social consequences. Usually in the teen years we listen to the music our friends listen to. Levitan describes music as “ a vehicle for social bonding and societal cohesion.”

It makes sense that music – the songs and lyrics we love can serve as Social Surrogates for loneliness at any age.