5 Hollie Davidson

A pioneer in every sense, Davidson has shattered ceilings across rugby officiating. She became the first woman to referee both a European final and a Springboks test, earning praise for her composed leadership and sharp decision-making. Fans and coaches often describe her as professional and quietly authoritative.

Focused on performance rather than publicity, Davidson’s approach continues to redefine what excellence in refereeing looks like.

4 Luke Pearce

Few referees have progressed as smoothly as Pearce. Starting at 16 with local club games, he built his reputation on clear communication and empathy with players.

Supporters appreciate his ability to let games breathe, though some feel he errs on the side of leniency. Pearce believes the best officials guide rather than control — an approach that’s made him a fixture in major internationals.

3 Angus Gardner

Gardner’s approachable, conversation-led style has made him one of rugby’s most familiar refereeing figures. Starting young and rising to the top, he was named World Rugby Referee of the Year in 2018.

While fans admire how he encourages a free-flowing game, others prefer a firmer hand. Nonetheless, Gardner’s consistency in high-profile matches shows the respect he commands within global rugby circles.

2 Nic Berry

Once a promising halfback, Berry turned to refereeing after repeated concussions ended his playing days. His rapid ascent to the elite ranks has been impressive, though not without controversy — particularly during the heated Lions series against South Africa.

Berry’s calmness and empathy, rooted in his experience as a player, have won him loyal supporters who see him as one of rugby’s most balanced officials.

1 Ben O’Keeffe

Calm under pressure and consistently composed, O’Keeffe has become rugby’s gold standard for officiating. Holding records for the most first-class and test matches by a referee from his country, he’s handled everything from World Cups to Lions tests.

Though he’s faced harsh online criticism, his measured response and top-level performances have earned him admiration across the sport. O’Keeffe’s consistency sets him apart from his peers.

EDITORS PICKS:

Like this:

Like Loading…