Lewis Silkin are most popular:


within Cannabis & Hemp, Privacy and Law Practice Management topic(s)
in United Kingdom

Two consultations have been published on changes to trade union
law set out in the Employment Rights Bill. These give a useful
steer on the government’s preferred options – although
some key details remain unknown.

The two consultations set out more detail on proposals for union access rights and the new duty to inform workers about their right to
join a union
, and are open for responses until 18 December
2025. In the Implementation Roadmap published in July, the
government indicated that both sets of changes would come into
effect in October 2026.

Union access rights

The Employment Rights Bill will introduce a new right for trade
unions to access workplaces for campaigning and organising
purposes. The Bill outlines a complex new legal framework through
which unions will be able to request voluntary access from
employers, failing which they will then be able to apply to the CAC
to order access arrangements. Access for these purposes can include
physical access to premises and/or electronic access to workers
through digital communications. However, as key details will be set
out in secondary legislation and a statutory Code of Practice, up
to now we’ve had limited information about what this new right
will mean in practice for employers.

The consultation document provides welcome new information about
the right of access, setting out the government’s proposals on
requesting and negotiating an access agreement, factors the CAC
must take into account when determining whether access takes place,
and enforcement.

How will the process work?


The government has proposed a short, fixed timeline for
negotiations over access arrangements before unions can apply to
the CAC. Employers will have an initial period of 5 working days to
respond to a union’s request for access, after which they will
then have a further 15 working days to negotiate access terms.

However, unlike with the existing rules on statutory
recognition, unions will then have a deadline of 25 working days
after first submitting their initial request to make an application
to the CAC. While having a hard deadline after which applications
cannot be submitted will provide employers with certainty, it will
also force unions to make more applications to the CAC to protect
their position, rather than continuing to engage in voluntary
negotiations for a longer period. It remains to be seen whether the
CAC, which at present has a very small staff, will receive the
resources to manage this significant new caseload.

What restrictions will there be on the new right of
access?


Small businesses with fewer than 21 employees in total will be
exempt from access requests. This threshold is aligned with an
equivalent exclusion under the existing statutory recognition
framework.

In contrast, already recognising a union won’t
automatically block another union from being able to secure access
at the same workplace. The government has instead proposed that the
presence of a recognised union would be one factor for the CAC to
take into account when deciding whether it would be reasonable to
refuse an access request. Leaving the door open to access requests
where there is already union recognition in place may mean that we
see increased competition among unions to recruit new members, with
a destabilising effect on industrial relations. We anticipate that
the Bridlington Principles (which regulate disputes between unions
which are affiliated to the TUC) may need to be amended to account
for this new dynamic.

Similarly, the government has proposed that, when deciding
whether to grant access, the CAC should take into account the
principle that employers should not have “to allocate more
resource than is required” to facilitate access arrangements.
The consultation document cites the specific examples of having to
construct new meeting places or implement new IT systems as
disproportionate steps, which would be a reasonable basis for the
CAC to refuse access. While this may be some comfort for employers,
it suggests that businesses will still be required to incur some
costs to facilitate access arrangements.

The consultation also asks respondents for their views on
further matters which the CAC should have to consider when deciding
whether to grant access. Given the range of practical issues which
access arrangements are likely to raise for businesses, employers
are likely to push for additional grounds on which it would be
reasonable for the CAC not to grant access, such as where it would
be incompatible with national security, health and safety,
confidentiality obligations or the need for continuity of service
or production.

How will access arrangements work in
practice?


Access agreements will be required to have a fixed duration,
with a term of no more than 2 years. Employers are likely to
welcome this measure, which will stop them from being permanently
bound by legal obligations to facilitate outdated access
arrangements.

The consultation document indicates that the government will
publish a “model agreement”, which the CAC will take into
account when it decides whether to grant access to a union. Unlike
in statutory recognition applications, where the CAC must
automatically order the specified method of collective bargaining
if the parties are unable to reach agreement, the CAC will not
order these model terms if the parties cannot agree. However, the
model terms are still likely to shape market practice, as unions
will want to closely align requests to them to maximise their
chances of being granted access.

The government proposes that the model terms will specify that
access should be granted on a weekly basis (whether physical,
digital or both). This will be an onerous obligation for employers
to facilitate for up to two years. For comparison, the existing
Code of Practice on access during statutory recognition ballots
only recommends access meetings should be held once every 10 days
during the short period in the run-up to a ballot. Given limited
resources, unions will struggle to provide sufficient staff to
attend a large number of workplaces on a weekly basis.

The model terms will require unions to give at least two
working days’ notice prior to each time they access a
workplace. While a requirement to give notice is helpful, we
anticipate that two working days may be insufficient time for many
employers to make suitable arrangements.

How will access agreements be enforced?


A party will be able to submit a complaint to the CAC about a
breach of an access agreement. If the complaint is upheld, the CAC
will have powers to order steps to be taken to ensure the agreement
is complied with. If a complaint is brought about another breach
within 12 months, the CAC will then be able to impose financial
penalties.

The government has proposed a two-stage system of penalties,
with a standard cap of £75,000 (in line with the maximum
penalty for breach of information and consultation rules) and an
increased cap of £150,000 for repeated breaches.

In deciding the size of a penalty, the CAC will have to take
into account a number of factors, including the gravity, duration
and reasons for the breach, the number of workers affected, the
number of workers employed by the business, and any previous
history of non-compliance.

What do we still not know?

While the consultation provides useful insight into the
Government’s likely approach to the forthcoming regulations on
the right of access, key details remain unknown. Beyond the fact
that the model terms will provide for weekly access on two working
days’ notice, we have very limited information about what the
CAC will consider to be reasonable access in practice. For example,
in relation to physical access, it’s unclear how many union
officials will be able to enter a workplace or for how long,
whether management will be able to attend their meetings onsite, or
whether staff will be entitled to paid time off from their usual
duties to meet with the union. Similarly, it remains unclear what
digital access will mean – in particular, will it be
sufficient for an employer to send an email on behalf of the union
to its staff, or will it be required to provide access to its
electronic systems or to disclose employees’ contact details to
enable the union to contact them directly?

We anticipate that the statutory Code of Practice on the new
right of access will provide much-needed practical guidance on how
employers will be required to comply with this new obligation. The
government intends to run another consultation on the Code of
Practice in spring 2026.

Duty to inform workers of right to join a union

The Bill will create an obligation on employers to provide new
workers with a written statement that they have a right to join a
union at the same time as their statement of employment
particulars. It leaves it up to the government to prescribe in
future regulations the content and format of the statement, and any
additional times it must also be provided.

The government is proposing that the statement should include
the following information:


A brief, neutral overview of the functions of a trade
union

A summary of the statutory rights in relation to union
membership

A list of all trade unions that the employer recognises (if
any)

A signpost to a GOV.UK website with a list of trade unions

The government’s preference is for it to produce a single,
standard written statement, to which employers would only need to
add any further information that is specific to their organisation.
This is a sensible suggestion, which will remove the administrative
burden that would otherwise fall on employers and reduce the risk
of challenges over compliance with this duty (particularly noting
the relative complexity of the information that the statement may
be required to cover). It will be vital for the government to
ensure the standard written statement remains a neutral, factual
document, particularly given that the individual right to choose
not to join a trade union is protected under the European
Convention on Human Rights.

This new duty will impose an additional compliance burden on all
employers, including very small businesses who will not benefit
from an exemption. It will be enforced in the same way as the
existing requirement to provide a statement of employment
particulars – so workers won’t be able to bring a standalone
claim in the Employment Tribunal, but if the worker wins another
claim, breach may result in an award of between two and four
weeks’ (capped) pay.

It is unclear, however, whether this new requirement will
achieve the Government’s stated aim of reversing the long-term
decline of trade union membership in the UK, which is likely more a
reflection of unions’ reduced relevance to the modern workplace
than a lack of awareness of their existence among workers.

The full consultation documents can be found here and here. Lewis Silkin will be submitting a
response to both consultations, so please do get in touch with us
if you’d like to share your views.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.