Part One of a Series
Note: For a more dynamic presentation of these ideas in which everything is explained with images and animation, see: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VExITmJUjUA
For well over a century, Darwin’s theory of natural selection has served as biology’s grand unifying framework, explaining how species adapt and evolve through the differential replication of randomly generated variations. Given the success of the theory of natural selection in biology, it’s natural to wonder whether it might explain another kind of evolution we see all around us: that of human culture. A scientific framework for cultural evolution could potentially integrate the social sciences under one explanatory umbrella, as natural selection did for the life sciences. It could help us understand how we got here, who we are, and where we’re headed. It might help us document human civilization, or mine trends or analyze gaps in technological change, and shed light on what factors lead to ground-breaking innovations. This piece investigates the soundness of applying the theory of natural selection to culture. Segments of the analysis presented here can be found in previously published works (Gabora, 2001, 2004, 2011, 2013; Gabora & Steel, 2021); a much more in-depth analysis is forthcoming in (Gabora, in press).
Culture Does Evolve
Cultural innovations such as technologies, artistic styles, and social practices build on earlier ones, and tend to benefit their bearers, and become more useful over time. Culture exhibits cumulative, adaptive change; it evolves. The question is: How? What kind of scientific framework can accommodate it?
Cumulative, adaptive cultural change was demonstrated in a computer model of cultural evolution in which neural network-based agents creatively invent new actions and imitate their neighbours (Gabora, 1995). The computer model exhibited phenomena typical of biological evolution, such as drift (fixation on one trait despite that others are equally fit due to random fluctuation in trait frequencies), and epistasis (where the effect of one trait depends on another). This suggests it’s worth investigating the possibility that natural selection, the theory designed to explain how organisms evolve, can also explain how culture evolves.
Culture Doesn’t Have the Problem Darwin’s Theory Was Designed to Solve
To assess this, let’s start by looking at what problem Darwin’s theory was designed to solve, and whether culture faces the same problem. Darwin observed that living organisms are exquisitely adapted to their environments. For example, the finches on different Galápagos Islands have beaks that are perfectly suited to their local food sources. Moreover, these adaptations accumulate gradually over time, as evidenced by the gradation of beak shapes across related species.
However, the traits that organisms acquire during their lifetimes aren’t transmitted to their offspring. If you get a tattoo or a degree in geology, your child isn’t born with a tattoo or knowledge of geology. This creates a paradox: If each generation’s acquired adaptations are discarded, how do species become increasingly well-adapted over time?
Darwin’s genius was to shift the focus from individuals to populations. He realized there are two kinds of transmission: traits that are acquired over a lifetime (like a tattoo), and traits that are inherited (like eye colour). Though acquired traits disappear each generation, inherited traits are transmitted to offspring (in what we now call DNA). He realized that these inherited traits undergo random variations, and variations that improve an organism’s ability to survive and reproduce are more reliably passed on to offspring. They thereby become more common in subsequent generations. This is natural selection: cumulative, adaptive change through differential replication of randomly generated heritable variations. In this way, Darwin explained how adaptive changes get retained across lineages despite that acquired traits aren’t transmitted.
Culture doesn’t face the problem Darwin’s theory was designed to solve, the problem of how change accumulates despite acquired changes getting obliterated each generation. Once someone invented a teapot handle, teapots could thereafter have handles. If we apply natural selection to culture, we’re trying to use a framework specifically designed to explain evolution in systems where acquired traits aren’t transmitted, to explain evolution in a system where they are.
Culture Doesn’t Possess the Algorithmic Structure of Natural Selection
John von Neumann (1966) later showed that the minimal structure capable of evolving through natural selection is a self-replicating automaton: a set of instructions that, if followed, produce a copy of the instruction set itself—a self-assembly code. For natural selection to occur, this self-assembly code must serve two functions. First, it is passively copied during reproduction to produce gametes: sperm and egg cells that join to form a zygote, the starting point of a new organism. Second, the self-assembly code is actively interpreted during development to turn this zygote into a functioning organism. Changes acquired by the organism are shielded from gametes (the “Weismann barrier”), thus not inherited.
Unlike biological organisms, cultural units aren’t self-replicating automata. A hammer or a painting doesn’t autonomously make copies of itself. It does not consist of a self-assembly code that is interpreted during development and passively copied during reproduction.
Dawkins claimed that cultural units, like genes, are replicators. He defined a replicator as “any entity in the universe which interacts with its world, including other replicators, in such a way that copies of itself are made.” However, the replicator concept doesn’t capture the algorithmic structure of a self-replicating automaton: the minimal entity that can evolve through natural selection. Moreover, it lacks the signature feature of natural selection: the lack of transmission of acquired traits.
Only One Form of Inheritance
Dual inheritance theory, the idea that culture is a “second system of inheritance” (Boyd and Richerson, 1978; Henrich and McElreath, 2007), is profoundly misleading. In biological inheritance, offspring receive genetic information for traits that may never have been expressed in their parents. For example, even if your parents never break a bone, and the genes for bone repair never turn on in their lifetimes, you still inherit those genes, and they still work fine if you break a bone. In contrast, if your parents know how to ice fish but never teach you, you don’t have that knowledge. That’s because the knowledge of ice-fishing, like all cultural information, is acquired, not inherited. We have two systems of transmission, but just one system of inheritance.
For Psychology Today blogs on related topics, see Catalyzing Creative Cultural Change, Computer Models of How Ideas Evolve and How We Became Creative, and Documenting Cultural Lineages.