Do you think that you have a good sense of your own level of attractiveness? Recent research by Greitemeyer (2020) suggests that very few of us accurately estimate our own physical attractiveness. In a series of six studies involving more than 1,000 participants from both undergraduate and community samples from Europe, Greitemeyer showed that people who are less attractive most often overestimate their level of attractiveness while those who are more attractive underestimate theirs.
In each of the six studies individuals were asked a series of questions about themselves including how attractive they perceived themselves to be. These self-ratings were compared with either the researchers’ ratings of the physical attractiveness of those same individuals or with ratings made by other participants. Although in general observers tended to agree with one another about the attractiveness of a target person, the target person themselves tended to disagree with the observers’ ratings.
However, the pattern of disagreement was different for more attractive and less attractive individuals. In general, individuals who were judged as less attractive by others rated themselves as more attractive than observers rated them; individuals who were judged as being of average attractiveness made more similar ratings of their own attractiveness to those of the observers; and individuals who were highly attractive rated themselves as less attractive versus the ratings made by observers. It was also the case that less attractive individuals overestimated their own attractiveness by a larger factor than more attractive individuals underestimated their own attractiveness.
Interestingly, unattractive individuals may be worse at judging their own attractiveness as well as the attractiveness of others. Less attractive people tended to differentiate less among attractive and unattractive stimulus persons when judging the attractiveness of other targets. Alternately, it may be the case that less attractive people can recognize whether others are more or less attractive, but they find a broader range of targets to be appealing than their better-looking peers.
Even when less attractive people were asked to imagine how others viewed them, they overestimated how attractive they would appear to others. Unattractive people tended to rate themselves as about average in attractiveness rather than below average while more attractive people rated themselves as only slightly less attractive than they were perceived by others to be.
A limitation of the present research concerns the purely physical definition of attractiveness. Greitemeyer acknowledges that other factors such as kindness or intelligence may influence our perceptions of an individual’s attractiveness. However, the present research involved only attractiveness ratings made by strangers who were unfamiliar with these other qualities. Individuals who know the target person well might make better judges of attractiveness which encompasses other factors than just physical beauty, and we may judge our own attractiveness as encompassing rather than excluding these other factors. Another limitation of the present research is that the author found more agreement about who was attractive versus agreement about who was unattractive. Therefore, not only beauty, but also its converse, may be in the eye of the beholder.
Facebook image: Cristina RasoBoluda/Shutterstock