Carmichael said the only positive outcome may lie in potential access to the remaining DEFRA-controlled portion of the fund: “If that does prove to be possible it would go some way to reducing the harm and I shall be pursuing this further with the government.”

 
Evidence From Committee Hearing

During the committee session, Mr Carmichael questioned UK officials about who had pressed for devolution of the Fisheries and Coastal Growth Fund.

When asked by the Chair, Emma Reynolds said: “It is my understanding that there was a request for this fund to be devolved because there were concerns that under the previous Government the seafood fund that they had was not devolved.”

David Hill added: “They expected these sorts of arrangements to be devolved and the Westminster Government listened to that.”

Pressed on whether fishermen’s organisations had requested devolution, Hill responded: “I cannot speak for the fishermen’s organisations themselves,” and confirmed he had “not personally” discussed the issue with them.

Hill also said the devolved administrations had expressed a preference for devolved arrangements, which in turn triggered Barnett consequences.

When asked whether the remaining DEFRA-controlled funding could still be open to Scottish fishing businesses, Hill confirmed the scheme was designed to “support fishing communities in all parts of the United Kingdom” and that support for “scientific innovation and technical innovation” could extend beyond specific geographic areas.

 
Industry Reaction

Scottish fishermen have already expressed outrage at receiving only 8 per cent of the fund despite landing more than 60 per cent of the total value of fish in UK ports. The committee testimony has reinforced industry concerns that the Scottish Government’s handling of negotiations has eroded the sector’s access to support.

 
Next Steps

Carmichael told the committee he expects further clarification from the UK Government on whether Scottish fishing businesses can apply directly for components of the remaining national fund. He also committed to pressing this matter further, warning that any failure to act risks compounding already severe pressures facing the Scottish fishing industry.