A police force has admitted unlawful arrest after sending six uniformed officers to detain two parents who had complained about their school on WhatsApp.

Hertfordshire constabulary originally defended its arrest of Maxie Allen and Rosalind Levine but has now agreed a £20,000 payout. The force admitted that the legal criteria for arrest were “not made out” and formally accepted liability for wrongful arrest and detention.

It stood by its decision to investigate, citing the volume of correspondence sent by Allen and Levine to their daughter’s primary school.

The case led to a national debate about police overreach after The Times revealed that Allen and Levine had been detained in January in front of their young daughter before being fingerprinted, searched and left in a police cell for eight hours.

• Police arrest parents who complained in school WhatsApp group

They were questioned on suspicion of harassment, malicious communications and causing a nuisance on school property. After a five-week investigation, police concluded that there should be no further action.

Six officers, who arrived in a police van and two marked vehicles, arrested the couple after Cowley Hill Primary School, which their daughter attended, complained of a high volume of emails and disparaging comments on WhatsApp.

In April, Andy Prophet, chief constable of Hertfordshire, defended the arrests.

Andy Prophet, Chief Constable of Hertfordshire Police, wearing glasses and uniform.

He said that the inspector who had approved them did not believe Allen and Levine would consent to a voluntary interview and also needed to preserve electronic devices.

However, the force’s lawyers admitted this month that the criteria for arrest, under the Police and Criminal Evidence Act, were not made out “therefore rendering the arrest unlawful”. The force agreed a payout of £10,000 each to Allen, 50, and Levine, 47, noting that the sum was “significantly above that required by the case law and reflects the constabulary’s desire to bring matters to a conclusion”.

Allen, a Times Radio producer and Liberal Democrat councillor, said: “We’re very pleased Hertfordshire constabulary have recognised, albeit belatedly, that our arrests were unlawful. I hope the debate around our case has a positive effect on how these issues are handled in future. The police should not be a tool for public authorities to close down legitimate comment and scrutiny.”

Bryn Harris, chief legal counsel at the Free Speech Union, which supported the couple, said that they had been rightly compensated for their “appalling treatment by officers”.

Harris added: “The next step, for Hertfordshire and other forces across the country, is to learn what went wrong and never repeat this mistake. A good place to start would be a recognition that the criminal law is not a tool for protecting delicate feelings, or wounded reputations, and officers must not allow it to be abused in this way.”

Allen and Levine had been in dispute with the school over many months before the arrests took place. They had been banned from entering the premises, including being blocked from attending the parents’ evening for their daughter Sascha, 10, who suffers from epilepsy and is neurodivergent and registered disabled.

The ban came after Allen, a former governor, had written to school governors questioning the recruitment process for a new head teacher.

Maxie Allen and Rosalind Levine with their daughters, Sascha and Francesca, arrested and charged with malicious communication.

Allen and Levine with their daughters, Francesca and Sascha

SIMON JACOBS FOR THE TIMES

The school complained to the police in June last year of a social media campaign by the parents, and again in December complaining of “persistent” emails. Allen and Levine say that they emailed regularly to address issues relating to Sascha’s needs and repeatedly tried to persuade the school to overturn the ban.

After the parent body was warned about “inflammatory” comments on social media, Levine used WhatsApp to make a disparaging comment about the acting head teacher at the time and cast aspersions on the abilities of the head of governors.

A police officer issued a warning to the couple in December and told them to take Sascha out of the school, which they did the following month, a week before they were arrested. Prophet had claimed that the force had a “lawful reason to arrest” on January 29 after the school reported “more persistent contact and communication”.

The authorities have acknowledged that Allen and Levine never used abusive or threatening language.

Hertfordshire constabulary has maintained that, because of the cumulative effect of the allegations and email contact from Allen and Levine, it had reasonable grounds to suspect a criminal offence had been committed. Its lawyers reiterated that there was a “reasonable suspicion” of an escalation in behaviour between the December warning and the arrest in January.

Videograb showing three police vehicles parked on a street outside Maxie Allen's home.

Police vehicles arriving at the couple’s home on January 29

It cited other complaints made about Allen and Levine. The couple said that they were not relevant to the investigation or had not been put to them during their police interview.

Hertfordshire police have conceded only that the arrest was wrongful, not the investigation.

The force said: “Whilst there are no issues of misconduct involving any officer in relation to this matter, Hertfordshire constabulary has accepted liability solely on the basis that the legal test around necessity of arrest was not met in this instance. It would be inappropriate to make further comment at this stage.”