By Eric Levine, Ed.D., with Becky Shipkosky
We’re sensitive organisms, far more than we may realize. And the holidays can be a mini-trauma for the body and mind. We all have different traditions, but let’s imagine a fairly typical holiday: a long drive or a day spent in air-travel purgatory, followed by cookies, the world’s saltiest gravy, and drinks out with the old crew. Or maybe your evening is more focused on reminding the kids that Grandma’s porcelain clown collection is not toys while you sip rosé from a box, prep potatoes, and consume 30 or 40 black olives.
When it’s time to turn in, your accommodation is some version of a sleeper sofa, air mattress, or your childhood bed. Was it always this lumpy? You toss and turn all night, wake up unrested, and consider a hotel, ultimately choosing family togetherness over sound sleep. It’s no wonder the holidays are exhausting, and January feels like it’s 17 weeks long.
The Nuts and Bolts
So, what’s happening under the hood, and what can we do to come through it a little better this year? We dug into the research and found five main categories of neurobiological effects that negatively impact your mood when you start packing in the charcuterie and champagne. We’ll dig a little into each of them, and we’ll go over some strategies for coming out of the holiday season on a sunnier note.
Note: Naturally, how we eat is always influencing our mental health, but the assumption here is that your January-through-October diet is different and more balanced than what you’re consuming between Thanksgiving and New Year’s.
The Blood-Sugar Rollercoaster
It’s no secret that our blood sugar spikes when we eat sweets. What happens from there is more complex and varies from person to person. The body, seeking to compensate for a sudden increase in blood glucose, may overproduce insulin, which causes blood sugar to drop below baseline (Altuntaş, 2019). This is called reactive hypoglycemia, and a significant minority of people experience some amount of it.
The glucose rollercoaster isn’t the worst part, though. Our bodies sense an emergency when blood sugar drops, which initiates a stress response. Cortisol, adrenaline, and other counter-regulatory hormones put us into a mild fight-or-flight state (Sulaiman, 2021). Within approximately one to four hours after eating, we may feel anxious, restless, irritable, or a sense of doom. (It’s not just the clowns.)
Immune Response
It is well established that a pro-inflammatory diet can harm mental health over the long term, being linked to a 23 percent increase in risk for depression compared to the most anti-inflammatory diets (Wang et al., 2018). The novel nugget here, however, is that there’s mechanistic evidence of acute inflammation from a rich meal or two being enough to trigger “the funk.”
Within about the same time frame as our sugar crash above, we also get increased cytokine release and oxidative stress, plus reduced dopamine signaling. Here, we may feel the effects of something science calls sickness behaviors. This is the classic immune-response symptom set—low mood or anhedonia, fatigue, brain fog, social withdrawal, and reduced motivation.
Circadian Disruption
“Saving ourselves” for the big holiday meal, eating late at night, and grazing on gift basket contents in place of eating lunch are some of the highlights of December, are they not? But when combined with jet lag or staying up until 4 a.m. with your sister to commiserate about your parents, you’re really starting to cut into the rhythms your body depends on for restful sleep (Kim et al., 2025). No one will be surprised to learn that research finds we are more anxious, sad, and emotionally reactive when we’re sleep deprived (Zohar et al., 2005).
Neurotransmitter Rebound, a.k.a. Hanxiety
And this brings us to alcohol, perhaps America’s favorite circadian disruptor. Most folks who partake do so more during the holidays, whether that is to enjoy the season or to cope. It turns out it’s terrible for both. Before we get to the really exciting neurobiology of alcohol, let’s just get dehydration out of the way: It causes headaches, fatigue, and irritability.
The real meat of why alcohol has special joy-sucking powers, however, lies in a couple of neurotransmitters: dopamine and GABA. Dopamine is responsible for pleasure, mood, focus, motivation, and reward, while GABA calms us. Alcohol consumption initially causes both to surge (Kumar et al., 2009; Boileau et al., 2003), which is why the first drink or two might make you feel like liquid gold.
And then, as we sleep it off, GABA suffers the same fate our glucose levels did after the third slice of pie. An excitatory neurotransmitter called glutamate comes in to clean up after GABA’s wild night (Becker & Mulholland, 2020), and it calls in stress hormones to help (Stephens & Wand, 2012). This does tend to disturb sleep, but worse, it’s basically an anxiety cocktail.
Honorable Mention: Gut Flora
Something that feels intuitively true but lacks sufficient human studies is the role of gut flora in mood. We do know that the population can change dramatically and quickly with dietary changes (Leeming et al., 2019), and we know that about half of the body’s dopamine and most of its serotonin are made in the gut (Chen et al., 2021). But human studies have not been able to sufficiently differentiate between genuine chemical effects on mood and “grumpy bubble gut syndrome” (not a scientific term). The connection is, however, well established in animal studies: gut bacteria transfusions from depressed humans make rats act depressed (Chen et al., 2021).
So What Can We Do?
If you maintain a macrobiotic diet rich in fiber and fermented food through the Pie Holidays, then you’re among the chosen—carry on. But let’s be realistic. No one still reading by now is going to skip the peppermint eggnog. We need some guidance we can live with, so:
Blood sugar: To prevent or offset a sugar crash and reduce the risk of reactive hypoglycemia, eat some protein or fiber with your sugar. Eggnog is a great choice, actually!
Immune response: To minimize inflammation, get a double helping of the salad and consider taking a DHA/EPA omega-3 supplement to get you through the season if your holiday traditions don’t involve fish. And always go whole-grain if you can!
Circadian disruption: Try to keep your regular sleep routine as best you can, and while the foods may change, maintaining something close to your usual eating schedule will go a long way toward preserving circadian sanity.
Hanxiety: Skip booze if possible. If you do partake, drink a glass of water for every alcoholic beverage, stop consuming alcohol two or three hours before bed, and have an electrolyte nightcap.
Gut messaging: Take your probiotics and bring some kimchi to the potluck!
A little extra effort goes a long way, and even small adjustments can help soften the January crash without dimming the joy of the season. Keep the holidays happy, and don’t let the clowns get you down!