Hannah Finster’s articles from Marks & Clerk are most popular:


within Intellectual Property topic(s)
in United Kingdom
with readers working within the Automotive industries

On 4 December the IPEC handed down its judgment in the case of
Dryrobe Limited v Caesr Group Limited t/a D-Robe Outdoors.
It relates to the trade mark infringement and passing off case
brought by Dryrobe, the well known outdoor clothing manufacturer
and retailer.

Dryrobe survived invalidity and revocation challenges brought by
the defendant, and ultimately succeeded in their claim for trade
mark infringement and passing off in respect of the defendant’s
use of the mark D-ROBE.

What is particularly interesting about the judgment (and what I
focus on in this article) is its detailed analysis of D-Robe’s
counterclaim that the DRYROBE trade marks should be revoked as they
had become generic pursuant to s46(1)(c) Trade Marks Act 1994
(TMA).

s46(1)(c) TMA states that the registration of a trade mark may
be revoked on grounds that “in consequence of acts or
inactivity of the proprietor, it has become the common name in the
trade for a product or service what which it is registered.”
It covers a situation where a previously distinctive trade mark,
which has functioned as an indication of origin, has become a
generic name and therefore ceased to perform that function.

D-Robe (the defendant) argued that the brand DRYROBE had become
synonymous with a category term for the products in question (i.e.
it had become the common name for changing robe products). The
Court accepted the assertion that, because of the descriptive
nature of the DRYROBE trade marks, the claimant had a heavier
burden to take steps to prevent it becoming a common name than in
the case of someone who registers an inherently distinctive mark
(as per the judgment from Richard Arnold QC (as he then was) in
Hormel Foods v Antilles [2005] EWHC 13 (Ch)). However, the
Court felt that Dryrobe had discharged its burden, and therefore
the DRYROBE marks had not become generic.

This was due to the quite significant steps Dryrobe had been
taking to educate the public/third parties and police its marks.
This is where it becomes extremely useful for brands who may be in
a similar position regarding potentially generic marks to be able
to consider the steps Dryrobe had taken and compare them to their
own strategy.

The steps Dryrobe had taken to combat generic use of ‘dry
robe’ and ‘dryrobe’, which played a pivotal role in
their ultimate success in this case included (see paras [42]-[50]
of Melissa Clarke J’s judgment):


Budgeting for legal work and online brand protection;

Writing to/communicating with third parties who described their
products as ‘dryrobes’/’dry robes’, notifying them
of the existence of the trade marks and, from 2021, specifically
suggesting they describe their products as changing robes;

Taking advice from a marketing consultant and working with an
IP solicitor to address the risk of genericisation by:


Posting on social media “no substitutes” videos
explaining only a genuine Dryrobe from the Claimant could be called
a Dryrobe;

Creating posts demonstrating the Dryrobe’s superior quality
and performance;

Creating a section on the Claimant’s website explaining how
to use the term DRYROBE and asking others to use the ® sign to
highlight it is a registered trade mark;

Instructing the social media team to actively search on social
media for ‘dryrobe’ and ‘dryrobe on a weekly basis and,
if found in relation to third party products, contact the user in a
friendly and informal way to ask them to remove the reference and
use ‘changing robes’ instead;

Investing in further legal action, where appropriate, if
informal action did not resolve the issue etc.

The Claimant also had extensive documentary evidence relating to
these activities, including for example, records of all social
media posts which it found and objected to from December 2020.

We rarely get jurisprudence on genericism where we can clearly
see the exact steps a company has taken to discharge the burden of
ensuring its trade marks do not fall into this trap and become
liable for revocation. All brands who have trade marks that are at
risk of becoming the accepted and commonly used category term for
an item would do well to consider this, especially if their trade
mark is of low distinctiveness.

You can find the entire judgment here. Please do reach out if you require
advice on this topic.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.