Lewis Silkin are most popular:
within Cannabis & Hemp, Law Practice Management and Criminal Law topic(s)
in United Kingdom
with readers working within the Retail & Leisure industries
The UK government’s plan to remove the statutory cap on
unfair dismissal compensation would be one of the most significant
employment law changes in decades. But how would Great Britain
compare internationally if this change goes through?
As we explain in our previous article, the UK
government plans to remove the current ceiling for unfair dismissal
awards in Great Britain (the lower of one year’s gross pay or
£118,223). In this article, we look in more detail at where
this would leave us internationally.
Caps are the global norm – even in traditionally
employee-friendly jurisdictions in Europe
Most major economies impose structured limits to balance
fairness with predictability. For example, France introduced the
Macron scale in 2017, which caps damages based on an employee’s
length of service with their employer. The cap is around three and
a half months’ salary for at least two years’ service,
rising to a maximum of 20 months’ salary for employees with 29
years service and above. Spain applies a formula awarding 33
days’ salary per year of service (for employees employed after
February 2012), capped at 24 months.
Italy operates a dual system; employees hired after March 2015
face capped compensation of six to 36 months’ salary for large
employers and three to 18 months for small employers. A recent
Constitutional Court ruling declared the previous rigid cap of
three to six months for small employers unconstitutional, granting
judges discretion to award between three and eighteen months’
salary, ensuring proportionality. Employees hired before 2015 enjoy
stronger reinstatement rights but compensation will still be capped
within defined monetary bands.
Ireland caps compensation at 104 weeks’ total remuneration
and Sweden caps awards at 32 months’ salary, depending on
length of service. Switzerland caps compensation at six months’
salary, whilst Denmark’s compensation cap, in addition to
notice pay, is up to 52 weeks’ pay under collective agreements
and up to six months’ pay for salaried employees depending on
length of service.
Beyond Europe – economic powerhouses and global
comparators
Outside Europe, caps are also common. For example, in Australia,
the Fair Work Commission can order compensation for unfair
dismissal claims of up to a maximum of six months’ salary.
Where are caps missing? Rare exceptions to the rule
Uncapped compensation is rare globally, with most systems
applying structured limits. Some of the exceptions include
Luxembourg, which does not have a fixed cap on compensation for
unfair dismissal decided by the court.
Canada also lacks a statutory cap, but compensation for wrongful
dismissal is based on damages calculated according to the
reasonable notice period that the employee would have been entitled
to if properly notified.
The United States generally operates under an ‘at-will’
employment model, meaning there is no statutory unfair dismissal
regime. However, employees can bring wrongful termination claims in
certain circumstances, which may lead to substantial awards,
including punitive damages.
India does not have a statutory cap on unfair dismissal
compensation under the Industrial Disputes Act. Tribunals usually
order reinstatement with possible back pay or, in some cases, a
fact-specific lump sum. Where termination is lawful for reasons
other than misconduct, employers must pay severance of at least 15
days’ average pay per completed year of service; this is a
minimum requirement, not a cap.
Brazil also lacks a formal statutory cap with severance being
dictated by legal and contractual standards. If an employee is
entitled to statutory protection against dismissal, courts
typically restrict damages to lost wages and moral damages. If
courts do not award reinstatement, damages will be similar to
statutory severance obligations such as a 40% penalty on the
employee’s FGTS fund (a mandatory savings account system
designed to protect employees in case of dismissal without
cause).
Is Great Britain heading towards becoming a global
outlier?
Overall, the examples discussed in this article show that most
major economies prefer some sort of compensation cap or structured
limit to maintain predictability for employers while offering
fairness to employees. If the UK moves toward an uncapped system,
most other countries, including France, Ireland, Italy, Spain,
Switzerland and Australia, would still apply clear, structured
limits.
Understanding these differences matters not only for
multinational companies managing cross-border risks but also for UK
employers who want to benchmark against global norms and anticipate
how this shift could affect competitiveness and employee
relations.
Note that these proposed changes relate to Great Britain
only. Employment legislation is devolved in Northern Ireland and it
remains to be seen if a change in Great Britain would also be
adopted in Northern Ireland.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.