The British government has been running a consultation on potential changes to UK copyright law focusing on AI training.

It included canvassing opinions on four options. The first was leaving copyright and related laws as they were – doing nothing – while the second was strengthening copyright by requiring licensing in all cases.

The government also mooted introducing a broad data mining exception to allow AI firms to train their models on copyrighted material without licences; and introducing a data mining exception that allowed rightsholders to reserve their rights – opt out – “underpinned by supporting measures on transparency”.

That was its preferred option, and the UK’s music industry protested fiercely, arguing that an opt-out system would be unworkable and undermine the creative industries. Well, the survey findings were published yesterday, and the bulk of the 11,500 responses back this view.

“88% expressed support for option 1 – require licences in all cases,” explained the government in a progress report. Meanwhile, 7% of respondents supported doing nothing (which, quirkily, was described as ‘option 0’ in the survey), 3% backed the government’s preferred option of an opt-out exception, and 0.5% supported a broad data mining exception.

No surprises in the breakdown of responses by industry: “most of those from the creative industries were strongly against the option which, in the consultation, was framed as the preferred one, and in favour of requiring licenses in all cases,” explained the report.

“Most of those from the technology sector, including AI developers, favoured option 3 – the exception with rights reservation – and option 2 – the broad exception.”

Clearly, the majority of the responses came from people in or supporting the creative industries. Even so, it’s a firm pushback on the option the government had preferred, so it’s no surprise to see the UK’s music bodies quickly celebrating – and calling for the lesser-supported options to be ruled out.

“It is imperative that the Government unequivocally drops its previously preferred option of a Text and Data Mining copyright exception, which is unnecessary and harmful to the UK’s creative industries and jobs it supports,” said BPI chief strategy officer Sophie Jones.

“The government must now unilaterally drop its anti-creator, anti-business proposal and back British music and creative industries,” added UK Music chief Tom Kiehl.

Will it, though? The government is due to publish an economic impact assessment and report by 18 March next year, as the next steps towards actual legislation. The lobbying will continue full-bore until (and yes, beyond) then.

Related Stories