“Prediction markets are increasingly being framed not simply as gambling, but as a form of intelligence, strategy, forecasting, or participation in internet culture itself,” she argues.
The platform homepages resemble the Bloomberg terminals used by people who work in finance, and they are integrated into some investment apps.
“In many cases, platforms present themselves more as information markets or trading environments than betting products, even though behaviourally they can resemble gambling quite closely.”
She says there are questions around whether operators and influencers are properly explaining the risks involved in using these platforms.
The prediction markets capitalise on the vulnerability of young men who are suffering from “economic nihilism”, Cohen says, and men might think: “If I have $20,000 – which feels like it’s worth nothing – and put it in the S&P 500 then it’ll be worth more in 20 years, but if I invest it in one of these prediction markets now I’ll be rich quick.”
The idea that it feels like you are outsmarting other men could be part of the appeal, too. “The lottery is not interesting [to young people] because it’s picking random numbers,” Cohen says. “But a bet makes you feel smart because you picked the game or the politician. It’s like ‘identify the alpha because he beat them all at the prediction markets’.”
He adds that many regular people on the platforms aren’t really gambling peer-to-peer but “against a load of hedge funds who are going to eat their lunch.”
Both experts say that more detailed data is needed on who exactly is using prediction markets.
Kalshi and Polymarket, both of which are primarily taken up with sports betting, do seem aware that there is a perception that prediction markets are typically male places. Both look like they’re trying to attract more women to their platforms with female influencers sharing friendly videos about the platforms, or official accounts posting memes from the films such as Mean Girls and Clueless.
Kalshi told the BBC that the proportion of women users on its platform had gone from 13% to 26% over the last year. It said that it partners with organisations to tackle problem gambling and that it promotes responsible trading.
It added that, under commodities futures trading regulation in the US, the influencers it pays are not required to talk about risk when advertising its website or app.
Polymarket told the BBC: “When a conflict breaks out, people turn to the news for commentary and they come to Polymarket for information.”