But that was the just the beginning.
Months later, the player who had led Pandemic Horde for more than 10 years announced a shock departure.
Not only was he leaving the game, but the alliance would also be making a dangerous journey to a new part of space, as its new leaders wanted a fresh start.
Rival groups pounced, bombarding Horde’s members for up to 24 hours a day as they scrambled to protect themselves and their belongings.
Pandemic Horde suffered such a staggering defeat that the group ultimately disbanded.
Estimates of the cost of the assets destroyed during the battle vary.
The EVE Online super-fan who contacted the BBC about this war shared a complex spreadsheet and believes gamers’ assets worth £700,000 were lost.
But developer Fenris Creations calculates losses to be more in the region of £400,000 – stressing this is not an “official figure”.
James prioritised protecting his “big-ticket items” and managed to pull off a successful escape. He lost about £200 of assets. Others, he says, were not so fortunate and lost thousands.
The overall destruction, paired with the collapse of a major alliance, made 2025 a defining year for the game. Fenris Creations reports that November and December of that year were the two highest-revenue months in the game’s 23-year history.
James says the fall of Pandemic Horde, which cost him his virtual job and home, still hurts.
“Building these assets and taking territory takes a lot of time… You’d log in and that’s where you and your friends are. It’s like our neighbourhood – and then one day it’s gone.
Many players have lost contact with each other after scattering across space in search of new adventures.