Tommy Freeman
England’s persistence with one of the world’s best wingers at outside centre continued to underwhelm.
Freeman was penalised inside the opening minute for failing to release, handing South Africa the platform from which they launched their devastating early assault.
There were flashes of attacking promise. He linked nicely with Seb Atkinson, distributed well after half-breaks and produced a powerful carry from a lineout in the build-up to England’s second try.
However, he never looked entirely comfortable in the midfield and was badly beaten by Cheslin Kolbe’s footwork before eventually being moved back to the wing.
His afternoon ended with a yellow card after catching Damian Willemse high.
JOHANNESBURG, SOUTH AFRICA – JULY 04: Tommy Freeman, Ben Earl and Immanuel Feyi-Waboso of England appear dejected after conceding their teams fourth try during the 2026 Nations Championship match between South Africa and England at Ellis Park Stadium on July 04, 2026 in Johannesburg, South Africa. (Photo by David Rogers – Nations Championship/Nations Championship via Getty Images)
We are still none the wiser as to whether Freeman can become a top-class international centre. There are no such doubts about his ability on the wing.
Replacement: Move Freeman to the wing and bring in Henry Slade
The experiment should end. Freeman should return to his strongest position, with the experienced Slade restored at outside centre.
Tom Curry
Curry worked tirelessly, making 16 tackles in just 55 minutes, but there were few standout moments from the Sale Sharks flanker.
Much of his work came at the ruck as England attempted to stop South Africa from slowing possession, yet he was unable to pose his usual threat at the breakdown.
He was penalised early in the second half under the new maul law after going beyond the ball and was also involved in the defensive lapse that allowed Grant Williams to score.
Curry eventually made way for Guy Pepper after 54 minutes.
The concern for England is that his season has provided growing evidence that the current Curry is not quite the destructive force of old.
Replacement: Henry Pollock
Pollock has been one of England’s most explosive forwards and deserves an opportunity from the start against Fiji. His pace, carrying and relentless energy could provide exactly the spark Borthwick’s back-row needs.